• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent did Jesus intend to replace the Torah?

Extracts from this document...


?I have not come to abolish, but to fulfill? (Matthew 5:17) To what extend did Jesus intend to replace the Torah? 1. John Drane (sub-election on Jesus replacing the law) ? in booklet 2. N.T.Wright (especially the section on the antitheses) ? in booklet 3. E.P.Sanders : historical figure of Jesus (Pg. 206 ? end of chap) very useful for the disputes with Pharisees and Antitheses Jesus and Judaism ( pg 251 ? 264 ) ? very good for ?let the dead burry their own dead? and the sayings on divorce The sermon represents the first and the most extensive of five blocks of teaching. The Sermon on the Mount came before the mission Discourse (Mtt 10:5 ? 10:42), the kingdom parables (Mtt 13:10 ? 13:51), the pastoral care and forgiveness (Mtt 18:1 ? 18:35) and the judgment (mtt 24:3 ? 25:46). The five didactic structures are possibly meant to be a reflection of the five books of the Torah. This comparison appears to be confirmed by the message of fulfillment of the law. The teachings in the Sermon on the Mount therefore have a close relationship with the teachings in the Torah. The presentation of the Sermon sets rigorous standards ? interpreted by the early church as a distinctive, universal ethic of Jesus in comparison with the Mosaic Law. ...read more.


Pharisees had done, Israel was challenged by Jesus to discover the meaning of the commandments in terms of a totally integrated loyalty of heart and act. Additionally, N.T wright suggested that Jesus did not intend to replace the Torah, but instead produce a radically different way of being Israel in real-life Palestinian situations as the ruling interpretations of the Torah would lead to being Israel in the wrong way, leading to destruction. He rebuked the interpretations and modifications of the Torah and oral traditions by the Pharisees, suggesting a totally different approach and result following the very basic commands of God. Pericopes that emerged in response to challenges from Jesus? opponents, predominantly the Pharisees, suggested that Jesus was proposing some form of Torah replacement in his teachings. The dispute in the cornfield (mark 2:23) took place when Jesus was going against the Sabbath law ? ?plucking heads of grain?. Jesus seemed to go against the Torah and setting example to abolish it. However, this accusation is not justified as it is only contravening the oral tradition, not the Torah. Furthermore, technically it was the disciples who broke the law - ?his disciples began to pluck heads of grain?. ...read more.


Similarly in the story of the rich young man, Jesus implied that it is not enough that the man had kept all the commandments. It got to be matched with active faith, an ethical requirement that was originally in God?s commandments implicitly. Jesus is therefore reiterating hence intensifying the demands and wills of God, laying out moral teachings basing on the obedience required to enter the kingdom. The works of Torah functioned as symbolic praxis, as the set of badges which demonstrated both to observant Jews and to their neighbours that they were the people of the covenant. Jesus did not intend to replace the Torah despite the fact that throughout the Sermon it might seem, but intended to reinforcing and intensifying the spirit of the Torah in order for us to meet the demands of God required to the entering of the coming kingdom. Further, he criticized the oral Torah and modified it with a more universal ethic ? the original will of God. Jesus?s teachings can also be seemed as interim ethics for an audience awaiting the imminent arrival of the Kingdom. Therefore Jesus?s intention was not to replace the Torah. ________________ [1] N.T Wright: c.7 Stories of the kingdom (2) [2] N.T Wright [3] Sanders: Jesus and Judaism pg. 252 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Christianity section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Christianity essays

  1. 'The Jesus' parables of the Kingdom of God were about a future hope of ...

    This could be because the original meaning of some parables may have been lost in transmission of the early church and the parable uses such metaphorical language, that the connotations are unclear. Nineham states: (3) "The word of God...was so misunderstood and rejected because of people's sin and ignorance, that it became in fact an instrument of judgment and condemnation".

  2. Outline and examine Jesus attitudes concerning wealth and the poor. To what extent do ...

    Another attitude was that Jesus warned that wealth would make individuals self-righteous, with a key example being the parable of the Rich fool, in which the man is confident with what he has done, as Tannehill says that he has no concern for anyone else apart from himself, as he

  1. Why are the I AM sayings so controversial? Exodus 3: ...

    Marsh explains the "I am the light of the world" saying when he said, "Jesus rather than the candlesticks of Judaism, is the light and the light of the world".

  2. Outline and Examine Jesus attitudes towards outcasts in Lukes Gospel.To what extent do these ...

    that need it, which in this parable is Levi, as people considered him to be committing sin by being a tax collector. Tannehill agrees with what Jesus says in this parable, as he says that the banquet wasn't just an ordinary meal, but one of celebration, which in Tannehill's eyes,

  1. The Ideas of Hell and Purgatory: A Wide Shift from Then to Now.

    In previous decades, the idea of a fiery hell with horrifying punishments was used to make people afraid of the possible consequences for their bad actions. On the other hand, freedom is a privilege, and when freedom is abused, penalties are given. God's law and man's law are different, however.

  2. Discipleship revolves around following Jesus both physically and spiritually. Both the first disciples and ...

    He then took a child, put his arm around him and said, "Whoever welcomes in my name one of these children, welcomes me, and whoever welcomes me, welcomes not only me but also the one who sent me"(Mark's Gospel - 9: 37).

  1. Bible is the combination of 66 books, divided into 2 parts -The Old (39) ...

    Therefore, the combination of 66 books is the Bible. Divisions of the Bible The arrangement of the Bible is based upon the type of books and the author as well. Genesis to Deuteronomy - Pentateuch (Greek for 'five') This is the first five books of Moses. They are 'Torah' or 'Teaching' of the Jews.

  2. Jesus Did Not Intend For His Parables To Be Easily Understood - Discuss.

    These verses should not be understood as the only purpose for which Jesus used parables, as in other cases it is clear from the context that He used them to illustrate the teaching for His disciples or to challenge people in the crowd and even His opponents to respond like in the Parable of the Lost Sheep.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work