• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of the use of gene technology.'

Extracts from this document...


'Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of the use of gene technology.' The field of gene technology is an extremely vast and largely unknown one. Within it are many different sections of application and within these come many advantages and many disadvantages. It is a relatively new area of science and as such many people are unaware of the full potential of the applications of gene technology, or even the possible negative repercussions. This gives rise to questions such as, 'Is it right for us to play God?' One of the largest areas of application of gene technology is in medicine. The first practical use of genetic engineering was to use bacteria as 'factories' to make substances that are useful to humans. The prime example of this is insulin, where previously it had to be obtained from animals for those people who needed regular insulin injections. This process was more expensive, but it was also animal insulin, so there was a high risk of side effects. With gene technology, it is now possible to manipulate bacteria to produce vast quantities of human insulin at a cheaper cost with no side effects. Another practical use in medicine is to check unborn babies for possible genetic disorders. With gene technology it is possible to assess the likelihood of an unborn child being born with or developing a disease that would seriously affect their life. ...read more.


On a broader scale, genetically modified crops could be grown in areas where there is little arable land or in areas of drought, as genes allowing plants to do this would be introduced into desired plants that couldn't otherwise grow there. This could provide food in areas of starvation. However, there are many concerns over genetically modified crops. This point leads on to the disadvantages of gene technology, the major one being and the one which all others link to is that there is much we don't know about gene technology. Can we guarantee there will be no side affects in the short term and the long term, and is it right to change nature as some people believe naturally occurring incidents happen for a reason. Ethics and regulation are key issues concerning gene technology which need to be addressed. Firstly, the concerns over genetically modified crops, of which there are many. One which features prominently is the creation of 'superweeds'. It would be very difficult to guarantee that there would be no hybridisation across species e.g pollen from a GM crop spreading to non-GM crops which could easily result in the loss of biodiversity and the creation of a plant or weed which gained a major advantage over natural competitors due to extra genes being obtained that might make it immune to weed killers for example. Also, people have the right to know whether produce they are consuming has been genetically modified, yet often producers are unwilling to say so. ...read more.


There are many other examples of this and the reality is obvious, there would be no privacy for people and prejudice would become prominent even more so in day-to-day life. Another point is would you even want to know? There is a test for Huntingdon's chorea, a devastating, incurable mental disease, which affects people at about forty. If someone knows it occurred in their family would they really want to get a test, find it positive, and live with the knowledge that would you would only lead a normal life until the age of forty? This applies to many other illnesses as well. These three questions are but a few of many ethical concerns which come as a disadvantage to gene technology. Presently, there are many advantages of gene technology, which people know are safe and help millions. This is prominent in medicine. However, the reality is that there is so much unknown, so much potential for disaster and the simple fact that people cannot accept it as it goes against what they stand for. Any progress made therefore has to be made very slowly, but to many people it is worth the wait as there is so much potential. Personally I look forward to some of the prospects of gene technology, and appreciate how it helps society with the applications in use now. I think gene technology should be allowed to develop as long as the process is slow and controlled. The advantages are clear but people fear what they do not know, and unfortunately that is the main disadvantage of the majority of gene technology. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Genetics, Evolution & Biodiversity section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

This is a well-researched essay with a substantial list of references which examines the advantages and disadvantages of gene technology. The writer touches upon a number of contrasting applications of the technology and highlights valid controversies which plague the industry in the developed world.
The essay could, however, have been improved in the following ways:
1: a clear definition of exactly what is meant by gene technology;
2: an introductory paragraph outlining the structure of the essay, i.e. the various categories of GT which were going to be covered;
3: an emphasis on scientific fact when assessing the advantages and disadvantages rather than an over-reliance on opinion or media hype;
4: a discussion of advantages and disadvantages of each application, rather than grouping all advantages together and then all disadvantages together. The ethics of each application are quite distinct from each other making it impossible to generalise across the whole technology.
Nonetheless, the writer has given the topic considerable thought and clearly holds strong opinions on the subject. The challenge is to remain impartial and give a balanced, informed account.

Marked by teacher Ross Robertson 01/03/2013

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Genetics, Evolution & Biodiversity essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Nature vs. Nurture - And its affect on intelligence, personality, and behavior

    4 star(s)

    work cooperatively. Genetics (nature) gives us the ground basics to comprehend what the environment (nurture) attempts to teach us. In the same way that nature played an important role in determining ones intelligence, nurture has an equal importance. Nature (or genetic makeup)

  2. Marked by a teacher

    How light intensity affects biodiversity

    3 star(s)

    1 80 13 6 035 Clover Dandelion Sorrel Moss Grass Bare 31 3 2 9 48 7 5 032 Nettle Grass Moss Thistle Bare 47 5 6 1 41 4 094 Nettle Moss Grass Bare

  1. Edexcel Level 3 Extended Project - Should Embyonic Stem Cell Research be applied to ...

    This law didn't completely halt stem cell research however, as Scientists were allowed to experiment with the 21 lines of embryonic stem cells already established and government funding still covered adult stem cell research. This veto made scientists furious with Bush, as additional funding would've pushed them closer to their 'miracle cures'.

  2. The Advantages and Disadvantages of Genetic Engineering.

    Plants can be produced that are resistant to plant diseases (like fungi) and animal pests (like insects). Plants could also be created that could survive in less favourable conditions, such as poor soil quality, such as giving plants a nitrogen fixing capacity.

  1. The arguments for and against genetically modified foods

    This could lead to cross-pollination with other natural plants creating "super weeds" and other unnatural occurrences, which could have devastating results. The genetic code is very complex and nobody can predict the effects of introducing new genes into any organism.

  2. Discuss the Advantages and Disadvantages of Genetic Engineering

    Another advantage of Genetic Engineering is that is could increase genetic diversity, and produce more variant alleles which could also be crossed over and implanted into other species. An example of this, is that genetic engineering could be used to cross over the genetics of wheat plants to produce insulin.

  1. Biological explanation for anorexia nervosa (Holland et al, 1988): Evidence for a faulty gene.

    These differences were statistically significant. * More controls (31.7%) than patients (19%) were classified as androgynous (showing a mixture of male and female traits). * More controls (43%) than patients (27%) were classified as undifferentiated (not fitting into either masculine, feminine or androgynous categories)

  2. Genetic Engineering in agriculture

    A plasmid is then removed from an agrobacterium (bacteria) and cut open using the same enzyme. The gene is then spliced into the plasmid and then the plasmid is put back into the agrobacterium.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work