• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Assess cultural pessimist views of the new media

Extracts from this document...


´╗┐CULTURAL PESSIMISTS ON NEW MEDIA Cultural pessimists have a negative view of new media, arguing the rise in new media has been exaggerated by neophiliacs. Cultural pessimists argue new media is not so ?new?, instead it is an extension of old media. The only novelty of new media is its speed, allowing information to be accessed in the real time. Cultural pessimists believe new media retains negative features of old media, particularly ownership patterns (i.e. concentration in hands of elite groups), which is supported by Marxists. Cultural pessimists argue new media promotes low/candy floss culture of poor quality. Cultural pessimists believe the effects of new media on society are negative, meaning the government should regulate its content. By contrast, neophiliacs disagree, arguing new media brings many benefits to the society, including enhancement of social life and democratisation of the society. Cultural pessimists believe new media is merely an extension of old media. Cultural pessimists argue new media is still run by and for the benefit of major corporations. ...read more.


Furthermore, political elite have constructed sophisticated websites to ensure their views dominate the Internet. Marxists argue this way the elites are able to transmit dominant ideology through new media. Media technologies are strengthening the already powerful rather than promoting alternative views. The elites benefit from the inequality of access to new media: they do not have to respond to concerns of digital underclass, whose grievances are perhaps the most genuine. However, SEATON reports that political involvement online mirrors political participation in reality anyway. Nevertheless, neophiliacs argue that the Internet contains a wide range of political views represented. Besides, neophiliacs note new media can actually be used to challenge elites, as shown by the significance of new media in Arab Spring, which contradicts the one-sided argument of cultural pessimists. Cultural pessimists criticise new media for promoting low culture. Cultural pessimists argue digitalisation of TV had led to a decline of popular culture. HARVEY argues emergence of various TV channels resulted in dominance of repeats of cheap imported material, reality television shows and gambling. ...read more.


New media also leads to digital divide between those who can and cannot access new media. Marxists note this reinforces class divisions. Those who cannot access new media form a digital underclass, whose members are excluded from benefits of new media. Although neophiliacs argue that the poor in fact can access some parts of new media, it is insufficient to argue no inequality exists. Plus, cultural pessimists criticise the fact that new media lacks state regulation has a negative impact on the society, as it is easy to get access to racist, homophobic, violent or sexual content, even for children. OFCOM 2006 reports 1/6 children have come across worrying material on the Internet. Nevertheless, neophiliacs would argue lack of state regulation prevents heavy censorship and allows freedom of speech. In conclusion, cultural pessimists overwhelmingly exaggerate negative aspects of new media, not acknowledging any of the benefits it provides for the society, which are highlighted by neophiliacs. Moreover, it can be argued that some of cultural pessimists arguments are not particularly true in the contemporary society because there?s a diversity of content for people to choose from, and a digital divide is narrowing globally. . ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Media section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Media essays

  1. Moral Panic and media folk devils.

    Both were from broken homes and lived in poverty. Therefore social and economic circumstances which lay blame on the door of the parents were largely ignored in sight of a much easier scapegoat to blame. * How do books and music affect moral panics?

  2. To what extent do the media effects an individual's self-identity?

    One of my magazines studied, Bliss, had a photo of Britney Spears on the cover. She is supposedly an 'idol' for a young teenage audience. Her image is that of the 'perfect' female. Eg) Flawless skin, beautifully made-up, fashionably dressed etc.

  1. How is Crime represented in the Media

    80% of my respondents thought that the media do generate a fear amongst the public, in other words a moral panic. This occurs because the media create folk devils which heighten public concern. As Stanley Cohen, the man who invented the term "moral panic" proved when researching into the

  2. How does the media represent female bodies?

    I would then give them several women's magazines and then ask them the same questions after they have studied them to see if the magazines have made any difference to their viewpoint. This method would result in a more in depth study but I chose not to carry it out

  1. Ethics in the Media

    The book: "People who should be phased out: Guys who wear suits all day and think an earring makes them cool all night."(Carlin;Jurkowitz 3). The column: "I don't get it when guys over forty think they're cool because they wear an earring."(Barnicle;Jurkowitz 3).

  2. Cultural and Media Analysis

    This in essence places the men and women as being in binary opposition to one another. This is not to suggest that men are not looked at during the film of course this would be futile. But what Mulvey suggests is that the men are looked at by other men,

  1. Ireland has a long history of censorship but this has been employed for different ...

    (Carson 1990) This remained so until the demise of the act in 1967. Critique Kieran Woodman (1985) argues that the Catholic Church was the main factor in endorsing censorship in 1929. However, in a recent article in the Irish Times (March 23 2003), Dr.

  2. Do we need Censorship in the Media?

    The film which one thinks sparked up the industry was Andy Warhol's 'Flesh' which was about the day in the life of a street hustler. The 'permissive' have started and now is a time of 'flower power', 'free-love' and drug use, many people were anti-American or anti-government because of the Vietnamese war.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work