• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Assess the claim that 'The News is selected according to the demands of the target audience'

Extracts from this document...


Assess the claim that 'The News is selected according to the demands of the target audience'. The extent to which the news is selected according to the demands of the target audience will depend on the perspective from which this is viewed. However, it should be noted that news is clearly a social construction- selected by individuals and organizations based upon differing requirements. Pluralist and Functionalist theorists would support the view that news is selected according to audience demand, as it corresponds to their ideas on the market and libertarian dimension. On the other hand, Classical Marxism would disagree with the view, instead arguing that it is media owners, not audiences, who select the news, and this news in turn reflects the capitalist and owner's viewpoint. Neo-Marxist theorists would also disagree with the view that the news is selected according to audience demand, seeing news as being influenced by other factors including the dominant ideology. It could also be argued that news is selected on the basis of other factors, including practical constraints as well as the norms, values and practices of journalists and producers. It can be argued that the news is indeed selected according to the demand of the target audience. This is backed by the functionalist perspective as well as pluralist theories. ...read more.


This can be seen within the framework of Althusser's Ideological State Apparatus, where the media plays an important role in unconscious social control and the imposition of false class consciousness. However, this perspective can be criticized- namely for being too deterministic and failing to take into account the role of the individual. Pluralists would criticize the Marxist view for assuming that people are passive consumers of media output and news- and argue alternatively that people do and have control over what media they consume. Neo-Marxists would criticize the Classical Marxist view for failing to take into account the role of a wider, invisible ideology while it can also be said that the Classical Marxist view does not cover the role of media professionals in shaping news coverage. Neo-Marxist theorists would also disagree with the claim that the news is selected according to the demand of the target audience. They would argue that news is selected according to compliance with the ruling ideology of capitalism which enjoys cultural hegemony (Bourdieu) over other ideologies. Media professionals such as journalists, producers and editors who select the news and act as gatekeepers and agenda-setters (GUMG) are all indoctrinated in the ruling ideology through the virtue of their predominantly middle-class background and hence reflect this ideology in their work. ...read more.


Journalistic Values and Practices may also have a greater impact upon news coverage than audience demand. This is because journalists learn to follow certain rules and norms in their occupation- what we can call 'news values' (Hall). Bureaucratic and Cultural News Values help to shape news coverage- with an emphasis on currency, simplicity, size, expectations, importance and negativity. However, these arguments can be criticized. Classical Marxists and Neo-Marxists would criticize these views for failing to take into account the power differentials and the influence of a dominant ideology within any news gathering and news-presenting organization, while pluralists would argue that the demands of the audience and the market pressures involve inevitably have a greater influence on the news than media culture. In conclusion, it can be argued that although consumer and audience demand does play a clear role in determining news coverage, other factors, including the existence of a dominant ideology (which, from the Functionalist view, could be seen as the social consensus), as well as practical constraints, media values and finally the influence of ownership also play significant roles in deciding the content, style and nature of news. Therefore, it should be said that the news is determined by a mixture of the above in different quantities- interacting with each other in differing circumstances depending on the news organization and other factors. ?? ?? ?? ?? Edwin Loo 13K 05/02/2008 Sociology Essay Page 2 of 2 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Media section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Media essays

  1. Assess the claim that the Media works in ways that support the ideology of ...

    A second weakness would be that the owners do mot exist as an individual capitalist class who have recognisable interests in common, if this where so then journalist etc would be transmitting the views and ideas of the owners. Nergine argued that that there is potential for direct and indirect

  2. CENSORSHIP - A Liberal and Conservative View

    The liberal will believe that man has choice, and that it is therefore up to man to listen or view vulgar words or images. The Libertarian party of the USA gives us a perfect quote of why vulgarity on T.V and radio should not be censored: Obscenity, including "pornography", as

  1. Outline the three main approaches to Audience Studies assessing the strengths and weaknesses.

    Within the effects approach the audience is seen as impressionable and open to manipulation, summed up by Armand and Michele Mattellart in Theories of Communication book; 'The effects model seems to overlook the fact that possible effects of intervening variables in the communication process and presents the masses as being unquestioning receptacles of media messages'.

  2. What do the Pluralists say about the media generally?

    The media give access to a wide range of opinions, rather than the views of a dominant elite as the Frankfurt School would have argued. In theory everyone has a voice in the media - and gradual change is possible through the competition of different groups and different ideas.

  1. "The British media's coverage of asylum seekers and refugees is characterised by stereotyping, exaggeration ...

    language that indicates this is when they call him a "hook-handed preacher" this describes him as a person who's out to get what he can. In this sentence they also use the word "handout" this provokes normal taxpayers of Britain.

  2. Why do 'outsider groups' seek to influence or manage media coverage? How important is ...

    But prehaps a more important distinction between groups that are based on status and methods rather then particularly narrow aims such as sectional groups and causal groups need to be distinguised Wyn Grant came up with the idea of outsider/insider groups.

  1. Does violence in the media effect peoples behaviours and opinions?

    The Cultural Effects Theory develops the ideas of those presented in the Two Step Flow Model to a greater extent. These suggest that the media effects are not instantaneous, but are a slow build up of beliefs and values, 'much like bringing a kettle to boil'.

  2. To what extent to the news media reflect the "reality of crime"? Select and ...

    As Furedi points out, "newspaper headlines continually warn of some new danger which threatens our health and happiness". Whereas in the past it may have been the 'drug culture' of the fifties and sixties, or the disruptive behaviour of the Mods and Rockers, in the sixties, today we face panics

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work