• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Assess the role of the media

Free essay example:

Assessing The Role Of The Media

In society the media is, arguably, one of - if not the - most powerful of institutions however some sociologists would argue, for example Baudrillard, that its’ power is diminishing or weak. The media is debated widely both assessing its’ influence and functions, or in some cases dysfunctions. The media’s primary function is to inform the masses  which is the origin of its’ overwhelming power in society because obviously through manipulating what the masses are informed of - censorship - and the altering the portrayal of parts of the news the media - propaganda - they are able to control our thoughts - ideological control.

The media is associated with not only informing the public but furthermore representing the public and bringing up moral, political and social issues on behalf of the public. Also the media gives the public freedom to express and broadcast their views and opinions; take Youtube for example, Youtube allows anyone to broadcast online videos, newsfeeds and blogs it enforces freedom of speech and Youtube along with other independent media sources, such as The Independent, ITV etc. increase and extend democracy in the UK. Dahl, a pluralist would agree with this view of the media, that the media informs us, and he says that the media demonstrates thousands of millions of different views and opinions, it broadcasts many different takes on various events and portrays parts of the news in millions of different ways. The wide range of media sources, Dahl says, are good because it allows individuals to sift through all the information and opinions and form their own views - it gives us choice in what, or who, we listen to.

Interactionists and Functionalists would support Dahl’s theory and acknowledge that there is choice concerning what sources of information we listen to and those we may choose to ignore. The argument that supports the Pluralist view on the roles of the media are the Post Modernist and to some extent the Post Structuralist view. Post Modernist, Anthony Giddens says that the media has weakened the power of tradition and that it’s been a major part of the globalisation (merging the social and cultural boundaries) of the UK. He says that the media is continuously making our society more permissive - reducing tradition and slackening the norms and values and creating more equality.

An example of where our society has become more permissive is with ethnicity, racism which previously was a massive problem in society has gradually reduced and is not so widespread now and our society is far more diverse and accepting of diversity, also shown in Gay Rights or gender roles - it’s now socially acceptable for a woman to pursue a career alongside or instead of maternal duties. Hakim, a postmodernist-feminist talks about the Myth of Patriarchy saying that there’s no gender inequality nowadays and the traditional feminist argument is out dated.

Other post modernists such as, again Baudrillard, and also Bagguley, Baudrillard says that the media has caused a “death of class” in the UK.

Bagguley adds saying that there is now a class deallignment - people no longer vote on class based issues but rather vote on moral issues and global issues - in summary class is no longer important in politics, which is mainly the doings of the media and New Politics which again without the media would be difficult. The emergence of New Social Movements and Pressure Groups too, which Dianni talks about, would be difficult without the support of the media.

The media itself is a form of democracy, it represents a large proportion of the public

The PostStructuralist view, by Foucault, doesn’t directly address the roles of the media but can be linked as Foucault says that “knowledge is power” and that power comes from experts and intellects. Obviously the primary role of the media is to transmit news and knowledge to the masses - giving them power which obviously is similar to Dahl’s ideas.

So another role of the media would be to act as an extension to democracy.

There is obviously the parallel argument to this that the media shapes the public opinion, controls what the public is interested in and serves only its’ own needs.

Feminists, Marxists and Elites would argue this is the case; the feminist idea  being that the media is a patriarchal institution (dominated by men) and serves what Walby calls the malestream reinforcing traditional gender roles. Marxists, or Neo-Marxists, have a similar view however they would say that the media is a dominant force that serves its’ own capitalist needs and reinforces consumerism through excessive advertising which links into the Radical Elite view that the media uses something that Gramsci calls hegemony, which he says is a form of ISA that pressures us to conform to certain prototypes, it pressures us to buy certain things, to have certain opinions and to act a certain way.

The last theory to consider is that of Weber, who gives the analogy of the iron fist in a velvet glove, the media would be the velvet glove that softens and legitimizes the authority of the iron fist - the government or mass producers - upper classes.

The media is able to perform this role because it has class, party and status which Weber says are the three qualities needed to legitimise power, having these qualities makes the media a highly powerful institution as I suggested in the summary but taking into account that the media is mainly owned by Elites (who possess Virtu - having the cunning qualities of a fox and the strong qualities of a lion qualities that classical elitist Machiavelli suggests are the reason the elite rule is so natural) the power of the media can easily be corrupt and used to enforce inequality, control the masses and benefit the already-powerful elites.

In conclusion, there are many different ideas on what roles the media performs in our society: the Marxist and Elite theories both revolve around the same basic principals of class inequality and corruption of the higher classes. These higher classes maintain control through the media, as Althusser says the media is an ideological state instrument, supported by Neo Marxist Milliband who says the media alongside other institutions are instruments of the ruling class.

They both talk of concepts such as the myth of democracy and hegemony which the media externalizes , both of which I mentioned earlier.         

All of these critical theories agree that the media serves the interests of a higher supreme class though the name of this group of puppeteers varies among which theory you’re talking about - Feminists: Men, Marxist: Bourgeoisie, Neo-Marxist: Ruling Class, Radical Elite: Elites.

Then there are the more optimistic views such as the Pluralist, Postmodernist and Functionalist view.

Which also seems to have much truth in it despite being parallell  to  the critical theories which too have elements of truth in them.

Weber and Foucault offer more detailed explanations into each side of the argument, but from what I’ve assessed in this essay I would say that within the vast mass media and all of its sub-institutions all of these roles are performed and it mostly depends on what elements of the media you’re looking at.

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Media section.

(?)

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

3 star(s)

this essay has moments of great clarity in describing some very complex theories. However, the theories are too often jumbled together and not sufficiently evaluated or criticised. To get higher marks the candidate should have made a plan which would have helped him/her to structure this better.

Marked by teacher Lesley Clark 27/02/2012

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Related AS and A Level Sociology Skills and Knowledge Essays

See our best essays

Related AS and A Level Media essays

  1. The mass media have direct and immediate effects on the ideas and behaviour of ...

    However, there may be no dominant consensus about the meaning of media messages, and the two-step flow model ignores the possibility that the meaning of media messages might be imposed by powerful groups within society. McQuail's uses and gratifications model is based on the idea that people use the media in a variety of ways.

  2. Assess the view that sociology can and should be seen as a science

    This would result in a positive science of society, which would reveal the invariable laws. Popper believes in the inductive approach were he believes that theories should come from evidence and data.

  1. Critically examine to what extent do the mass media perpetuate gender stereotypes?

    These messages given by the women's magazines could be a key factor in the rise of eating disorders amongst young women as well as other behaviour patterns of individuals. In her study Ferguson points out this cult of femininity is exclusive to women's magazines, as the magazines available to men do not tell men how to be a man.

  2. Explain and briefly evaluate why high culture is seen as superior to low culture.

    Some customers have been hostile to the idea that the lottery is used to pay for "arty" dance and theatre companies. They suggest its elitist culture - most lottery punters wouldn't get to see it and probably wouldn't like it if they did.

  1. Moral Panic and media folk devils.

    programmes, * Computer games and the Internet. Of these five, two still cause major panic and one more has since evolved into a new culture and has yet again produced panic. Computer games and violent television programmes are blamed for causing anti social behaviour in children, along with this new

  2. How is Crime represented in the Media

    Gender Female involvement in criminal activity is not restricted to a few areas. While females do not tend to commit crimes of violence, they are involved in a wide cross-section of crime. Violence by females tends to occur within the family, mainly as a final response to male violence.

  1. Assess the effects of mass media on popular culture.

    used by the media present a "beauty ideal" through which they show women that they should treat their bodies as a blueprint that is in constant need for improvement. Furthermore feminists argue that women are encouraged by the media to see these achievements as central to their happiness and well

  2. How Media, Advertising and Celebrity Culture Affects Female Body Image

    56% of women said they were unhappy with overall appearance, with an overwhelming 89% wanting to lose weight (www.psychologytoday.com). The silhouette technique (Stunckard et al, 1983) is the most widely used measure of body dissatisfaction in which the participant is presented with an image of a range of body shapes

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work