• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Assess the view that the symmetrical family exists in modern day society

Extracts from this document...


Emily Duffy Assess the view that the symmetrical family exists in modern day society. The symmetrical family is Young & Willmott's view that in modern day society privatised nuclear families are more equal in the roles that the husbands and wives participate in. The husband does domestic labour and childcare as well as keeping the role as the breadwinner and the wives go to work and have careers as well as caring for the children and participating in domestic labour. The symmetrical nuclear family is becoming more common in modern day society according to Young & Willmott, because of the changes in society such as women's positions, geographical mobility and new technology that makes house work easier. The symmetrical family can be viewed by the 'march of progress' and from a feminist view, both of which disagree with each other. The march of progress view is that of which sociologists Young and Willmott agree with. Young and Willmott see the symmetrical family improving and becoming more common in modern day society. The symmetrical family is when the husband and wives do not completely have the same roles but are much more equal in modern day society. ...read more.


They blame the inequality on men still dominating society and families. Sociologist Ann Oakley rejected Young and Willmott's 'march of progress' view that families in modern day society are symmetrical. Oakley's study in 1974 showed evidence that husbands helped with house work very little and there was no symmetry within the families. Oakley's study also showed that only 15% of husbands participated in housework and only 25% participated in childcare. Therefore, childcare is more likely to be shared and equal between husbands and wives than housework. Feminists also argue that the impact of paid work has created a dual burden and a triple shift for women in today's society instead of leading to a more equal share in domestic labour. Feminists see no evidence of the 'new man' who would do an equal amount of domestic labour. A third of women who are married or co-habiting are more economically active and less dependent on men's income and therefore have to handle both domestic labour and paid work, and childcare if they have children. Feminists believe that because of the dual burden and triple shift in today's society, instead of symmetry between husbands and wives, men now benefit from both women's incomes and domestic labour. ...read more.


Men take control over the family this way by pooling. Pooling is when the parents have a joint bank account, which involves having joint responsibility of how much money they spend and both have access to the income. According to feminist sociologists Jan Pahl and Carolyn Vogler in 1993, the amount of couples pooling is increasing, suggesting that the symmetrical family is not common in modern day society. Their studies showed a 31% increase of pooling between couples, mainly among those where both of the partners had a full-time job. Despite this, men still made the majority of the financial and leisure decisions of the family making the family un-symmetrical. In conclusion, one believes that the symmetrical family does not exist in modern day society because, as studies show, the vast majority of couples are not equal in the roles they share and the financial and general leisure decisions that are made that effect the family because of pooling. Also, as feminists studies show, women are now taking on a dual burden or triple shift and men benefit from both their wives' incomes, housework and child care. However, there is little evidence that the symmetrical family does exist in modern day society as Young and Willmott show in their studies because of the commercialisation of housework and childcare. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Family & Marriage section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Family & Marriage essays

  1. Assess the view that gender roles and relationships have become more equal in modern ...

    was more common among younger couples, those who are geographically and socially isolated. The young couples who had moved away from Bethnal Green and were living at a distance from the extended family and workmates were more likely to have a symmetrical relationship.

  2. Discuss the view that the modern family is becoming more diverse

    One issue that arises is the confusion of the family within the household. Households in Britain basically have the general form of a nuclear family rather than extended families. From the sixteenth to the nineteenth century the average household accommodated less than five people (Laslett and Wall 1972).

  1. Is the modern family breaking down or is it simply changing?

    The mothers in these reproduced families have a high tendency to paid work while the grandmothers have a key role in supporting their daughters and caring for the grandchildren. Barrow suggested that slavery distorted West Indian family relationships as the slave owners often prevented nuclear families and settled relationships forming amongst slaves, which lead to the traditional matriarchal family life.

  2. Discuss the view that the modern family is becoming more diverse

    This highlighted that Murdock's definition and functions of the family did not apply and was therefore either too narrow or that the family is not universal. Murdock also saw the family as having four functions, sexual, reproductive, economic and educational.

  1. Some sociologists argue that, with the rise of the symmetrical family, the patriarchal power ...

    There was however a difference between the working and middle class. The middle-class women were not expected to do any work only to supervise the cleaning lady or nanny, while the husband would go out to work to provide for the family.

  2. Diversity in Modern Family Life

    have 'chosen' their own path, but that this may be because they have few other options. She points out that the men involved may not have jobs to support these single mothers and because of this, and various other negative reasons, they could be a bad role-model for the children in question.

  1. Is the nuclear family in decline?

    as it best matches the reality of modern times, however some feminists thinkers also points out that the nuclear family is still a massive source of control for women, therefore diversity is a way of challenging this control, since women now have more options.Giddens believed the family is now more democratic and equal than ever before.

  2. Gender roles/expectations that exists in contemporary Japanese society

    Changes in the family can be seen in the presence of omiai, the traditional arranged marriage. Women are also marrying later, with the average age of first marriage at 28-29 years in 2005, compared to 25 years in 1983. For increasing equality between gender roles, the government began to pass

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work