• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Can and should sociology be science?

Extracts from this document...


Can and should sociology be science? By definition, sociology refers to systematic study of human behavior and society whilst science literally means knowledge collected in a systematic manner. It is a popular debate in sociology concerning whether sociological research should adopt similar methods to those of natural science. There are 3 main approaches relevant to this debate, those being the positivism, phenomenology and realism. First of all, positivists would argue that sociology can and should be a science. This is because positivists believe that some features of natural science can be found in the area of sociology. Positivists argue that sociology has methods and theories like science. Sociological study is empirical in the explanation of social world. As well as scientist, sociologist collects data as evidence in order to verify a theory. For example, the studies of Mods and skinheads conducted by Stanley Cohen in order to verify Marxist sub-cultural theories. Hence, positivist would support the view that sociology can and should be a science. However, phenomenologist would reject the view. For phenomenologist, studying the social world is fundamentally different from studying the natural world. Alfred Schutz argues that social world cannot be objectively observed and measured. Unlike inanimate objects, both sociologist and subject matters are human with consciousness. ...read more.


Hence, phenomenologists argue that there is no objective reality beyond these subjective meanings. Furthermore, Max Weber rejects the possibility of finding laws of human behavior as well as the causal and correlation relationship of a behavior as he argues that individual possess different meanings and motives to their actions. Weber identified various types of action that are distinguished by the meanings attached, those being the affective, emotional, traditional and rational action. These actions are attached with subjective meanings which cannot be measured objectively. As such, Weber argues that instead of adopting scientific methodology, understanding of human behaviors can be achieved through Verstehen. Therefore, Weber argues that sociology should not adopt the methods of science. However, feminist would argue that even if sociology adopts scientific methodology, the date collected will still be unobjective. Feminist claimed that science is a male world where women have always been exploited or excluded. For example, Hilary rose stated that it is male science that seeks to control women's fertility through contraception and childbirth. As well as Sandra Harding who argued that male central science claimed to have prone women as biologically and socially inferior to men. Therefore, feminist argue that sociology is just as unobjective even if it emulates the achievements and aspirations of natural science as it itself is bias. ...read more.


Besides, Auguste Comte's view that sociology should be a science. He believes that scientific knowledge about society could be accumulated and uses to improve human existence so that society could be run rationally without religion or superstition getting in the way of progress. Moreover, through scientific methodology, sociological knowledge obtained can be more credible as it is empirically, rigorously, and systematically tested. Hence, Comte argues that sociology should be a science. As a matter of fact, Karl Popper sees it as highly desirable that sociological research method can be based on methods of natural science. However, he argued that science must adopt the deductive method where facts are only admitted into a theory through the process of falsification. Science must abandon the inductive method of attempting to make theories fit facts. For example, although 999 white swans may have been observed floating past a point on river, it is illogical to assume the next swan will also be white. Therefore, popper suggests that science itself can strive to be a more rigorous science. Withal, whether or not sociology can or should be a science depends on how science is defined. If science is narrowly defined as in the case of Popper, it is very difficult for sociology to meet the expectation and standard demanded. However, if it is much more broadly defined as Realist, then sociology can be a science. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Sociological Differentiation & Stratification section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Sociological Differentiation & Stratification essays

  1. Can and should sociology be a science?

    way as natural phenomena can be as people attach meaning to their social actions. According to Weber, the cause of a social action can only be discovered through the understanding of the meaning attached to it, he labeled this understanding as verstehen.


    However, others believe it is a patient's right to be able to give their informed consent to such a last-resort operation. It is difficult to evaluate the effectiveness of psychosurgery when so few operations are carried out, and the criteria for success cannot be agreed upon.

  1. Sociological Theories

    Within these four epochs were again two classes. In ancient society there was masters and slaves, in feudal society there was lords and surfs, in capitalist society there was capitalist and wage labourers, lastly in primitive communism classes didnt exist.

  2. Emile Durkheim - suicide

    Anyway, egoistic suicide leads to a high suicide rate in a society and it is common in modern society after the industrialization. In altruistic suicide, there is no individual interest and individual is renunciation. The social needs are more important than the individual needs.

  1. Sociological theories and Healthcare.

    They believe these changes take place in society due to the rapid growth of media and communication systems, of a global culture. Post modernism feel that institutions such as families are constantly changing e.g. there are more single parented families now than others so you cannot explain society by the

  2. Assess the view that sociology can and should model itself on the natural sciences

    However, not everyone accepts this definition and a number of sociologists put forward quite different pictures of science. Karl Popper puts forward the idea of falsification, meaning that theories should be falsified rather than verified, as it is impossible to prove everything.

  1. Major Theories in Sociology

    interpretivism do not agree with this and argue that sociology is not a science that behaviour of individuals cannot be explained properly through data or experiments. REFERENCE: Olivia. (09/05/2011). Difference between positivism and interpretivism.Available: http://www.differencebetween.com/difference-between-positivism-and-vs-interpretivism/. Last accessed 11/11/2012. PAGE:2 SOCIOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVES A perspective is way of looking at things, since

  2. Assess the view that sociology can and should not model itself on the natural ...

    Interpretivist sociologists however do not believe sociology should model itself on the natural sciences. Interpretivist criticise positivists scientific approach as inadequate for the study of human beings. All interpretivists seek to understand actors? meanings, however divided whether or not we can combine this understanding with positivist style casual explanation of human behaviour.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work