• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Critical Criminology, as a specific theoretical approach to explaining, understanding and controlling crime is not as clearly defined as one might initially wish when it is called on one to assess its contribution to criminology.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Critical Criminology, as a specific theoretical approach to explaining, understanding and controlling crime is not as clearly defined as one might initially wish when it is called on one to assess its contribution to criminology. It is not, however, certainly not an ambiguous term. The only root of the problems with the precise definition of its constitution lie in the fact that it has so many overlaps (and contrasts) with differing Left, radical theories and, in essence is a term used to group together a large body of leftist criminological theory. This is expressed in Ronald L. Akers's assertation that it encompasses various "radical standpoints"(Akers, 1999; 176). John Tierney adopted a much more deterministic approach to his presentation of leftist criminological theory and attempted to, insofar as possible, polarise Critical " Left idealist" criminology with "left realism", respectively reflecting the two most dominant strands of left criminological theorisation over the past 20 years. (Tierney, 1996; 283-4) At any rate, critical criminology is essentially a left-wing idealist and anti-logocentric approach to criminology, drawing its central body of thought from Marxism and attempting a severe critique of mainstream criminology, often making claims which almost entirely negate the fundamental foundations of criminology as we know it. ...read more.

Middle

It is from this difference that one of the greatest criticisms of critical criminology stems; Criminal criminologists are not concerned with causal explanations or practical solutions per se, instead they focus on the construction and application of the law (Tierney, 1996; 283). In other words they seem to be so occupied with analysing the legal system and the social construction of crime that they ignore explanations and control of crime (Tierney, 1996; 283). One of the other major criticisms of critical criminologists (voiced most fervently by the left realists) is that they, rather than seeking to actively reduce crime (and thus improve society in the present), are more concerned with the establishment of a crime-free socialist utopia as the only (and, they claim, complete) worthwhile effort at solving the crime problem. (Tierney, 1996; 285) This can hardly be interpreted as a pragmatic and dynamic way of practically tackling crime. In my opinion this method of helping history "run its course" in order to allow for the emergence of a crime free society can be interpreted as a cop-out for not having to propose any inventive and new methods of dealing with crime practically. Critical criminologists, when they actually suggest solutions to crime, have adopted overly na�ve and idealistic stances which again have been interpreted as cop-outs by suggesting such solutions as "declaring peace on crime rather than war" (Ibid.). ...read more.

Conclusion

Rather than doing so, in fact, it has merely attempted to negate and discredit any other suggestions and methods in practice on theoretical principals. The Critical movement in Criminology, however, has certainly made a significant contribution to developing a more true and objective field of study. This can be exemplified in the development of "constitutive criminology" of Henry and Milovanovic which consists of a synthesis of critical criminology, "left realism", phenomenology and the sociology of law. (Akers, 1999; 176 and Downes & Rock, 1998; 364) Perhaps it could be said that Critical Criminology has dug its own hole by adhering too much to its own principal beliefs without allowing for reflexive reconstitution of those principals. It's lack of practical suggestions can be demonstrated in Gross's comment that "on crime more than on most matters, the left seems bereft of ideas"(Gross; 1982 in Tierney; 1996 p.283). Its emphasis on which crimes are paid most attention to as a result of arbitrary construction is significant to the field of criminology. Also its attention to the penal system and its abolitionist stance may be significant in a much-needed investigation into the effectiveness of the current prison system. Unfortunately, critical criminologists paid no attention to the practical failings of prison in their denunciation of it as a system. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Crime & Deviance section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Crime & Deviance essays

  1. Sociological Theories on Crime and Deviance

    Thus the increase in crime statistics is just a social construction, not a reality. However left realists argue the increase is too great to be explained in this way and is a real one; more people are reporting crime because more people are falling victim to crime.

  2. Crime: Social construction or reality?

    They were more targeted by the public and police and lead to more arrests and fines. The media had exaggerated the story and labelled the groups "folk devils". The labelling process had lead to more deviant behaviour by the groups.

  1. Durkheims study of suicide has been criticised on theoretical and methodological grounds. Outline Durkheims ...

    reverse, with focus on personal belief and were not bonded or integrated together. He believed the victims of Egoistic suicides usually had few family relationships and were often unmarried and childless. However, in Catholicism as suicide is seen as a mortal sin suicide rates would arguably be lower due to this factor.

  2. Social construction of childhood

    However, even with consideration of these factors childhood today is still seen as a time of protected innocence. This can be seen in the western ideology of children. Childhood is not disappearing, simply changing in its forms and values.

  1. Assess The Contribution Of Control Theory To Our Understanding Of Crime And Criminality

    Classical criminology grew out of a reaction against the barbaric system of law, justice and punishment that was in existence before 1789. It sought an emphasis on free will and human rationality. The Classical School was not interested in studying criminals, but rather law-making and legal processing.

  2. New Right Realism & New Left Realism. The realist approach to crime treats crime ...

    The other Realist approach became popular in the 1990's. It shares several assumptions with the political right and of functionalism. Again like the left realists, they are attempting to address problems by providing solutions to crime. They follow the functionalist theory that a consensus of values upholds itself within our society, and that laws reflect this consensus.

  1. Critically assess the contribution of labelling theory to an understanding of crime and deviance

    Interactionists dispute the functionalist assumption that there was an agreement throughout society as to what behaviour is criminal or deviant. They aimed to find out why certain behaviour was labelled as criminal or deviant in some contexts but not in others.

  2. Is CCTV effective in tackling crime?

    A potential perpetrator enters a space monitored by CCTV and is either already aware of the fact of monitoring or somehow become aware of the fact. 2) The potential perpetrators either: a) already holds the belief that a crime committed in a space monitored by CCTV is more likely to be detected or b)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work