• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Critically Compare and Contrast Functionalist and Traditional Marxist Perspectives On Crime.

Extracts from this document...


Michelle Deluce Tutor: Joanne Green CRIMINOLOGY Page 1 CRITICALLY COMPARE AND CONTRAST FUNCTIONALIST AND TRADITIONAL MARXIST PERSPECTIVES ON CRIME There are many theories on why crime exists as well has who is committing the crimes and the underlying reasons behind it The two main perspectives being Traditional Marxist and Functionalist both with different views they share very little in common, however they do agree that society shapes the individual and not the individual that shapes society. What is meant by that is that we are all products of our upbringings and learn through socialisation what our beliefs are, what we agree on personally and often shared beliefs and the understanding of what is 'the norm; through our primary interaction with others beginning at home and continuing onto schooling and work. Our beliefs aren't always set in stone and can change through time and growth and the interaction with others once outside the family domain. There are many explanations beginning with Durkheim who was a functionalist, there is Merton who doesn't totally agree with Durkheim but adopted his theory on 'Anomie' and made it his own. In addition there is Hirschi whose theories mirrored that of Durkheim's and before concluding, Marxist view on crime will be looked at. The Functionalist view on crime and society is likening it to the human body to explain it functions. ...read more.


He created his own model of explanation and the type of bonds we care within society that consisted of four elements; Attachment, deals with how we care for others or have an inability not to have concern, typically a psychopath. The second element commitment, based on personal input into our own lives, for example our work and home environment, material things we own and our children and their education in comparison to a single male living in a Michelle Deluce Tutor: Joanne Green CRIMINOLOGY Page 3 bed-sit on benefits whom is more likely to offend due to a sense of having little to lose. The third, Involvement, a business person involved in legitimised dealings is less likely to offend due to having little time to do so. Then there is belief, a person who abides by the rules and conforms to the norms and acceptable standards within society and perhaps is totally against rule breaking. Marxism has a different slant on why crime exists and the origins of law enforcement compared to the functionalist view. Marxism began with Karl Marx and others after him have shared his view and added their own. His idea in the class divide between the richest in society or the bourgeoisie and those on the lower rung of the societal ladder, the working class, has long been documented. ...read more.


Both concepts were interesting and provided thought and the pioneers of both set precedence and have long since been adapted by others. Hirschi seemed a little too vague in his explanations with very little backup in his theories and his model of four elements seemed flawed. How could he say that a law-abiding person isn't likely to offend and he offers no proof to support his suggestion? He also states that a businessperson would be too involved in business matters not to commit a crime, Marxist would totally disagree, and they would say that he is more likely to be deviant within a corporate structure although should it occur it is highly unlikely the public would be made aware of it. However the question of mental state of an individual hasn't even been raised by any of the sociologists to explain why a person may offend. Merton seemed to make a lot of sense but there seemed to be something missing in his explanations on why crime exists why some commit and others don't, perhaps the reality is there is no definite answer on why it exists. Michelle Deluce Tutor: Joanne Green CRIMINOLOGY Page 5 BIBLOGRAPHY Durkheim, E (1985/1987) Suicide: A Study in Sociology, London: Routledge Erikson, K J. (1966) Wayward Puritans, New York: Wiley Hirschi, T. (1969) Causes of delinquency, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press Merton, R. (1938) Social Structure and Anomie, American Sociological Review, Vol 3, 672-683 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Crime & Deviance section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Crime & Deviance essays

  1. Sociological Theories on Crime and Deviance

    in here and now, rather than waiting for a revolution and a socialist utopia to abolish crime. The central idea behind left realism is that crime is a real problem and one that particularly affects the disadvantaged groups who are its main victims.

  2. Evaluate Functionalist Theories of Crime and Deviance

    This theory is predominantly backed by the clear fact that areas termed as "inner city" do indeed have higher crime. However, this theory can be criticized for being too simple, and also because Shaw and McKay's idea of "concentric zones" do not fit in with any city- which have a mixture of different zones in different areas.

  1. describe four studies relating to crime and deviance - each from a different perspective. ...

    For Karl Marx (1848), crime and deviance is simply a product of poverty within the unequal setting of the capitalist society. This can be viewed structural perspective as it presumes that an individuals' behaviour is dictated by the structure of society.

  2. Compare and Contrast the Main Sociological Theories of Deviance.

    favourable to violation of law over definitions unfavourable to violations of law'. By this, Sutherland means that if people are surrounded by others who support law breaking, then they are likely to do so themselves. Clearly, these approaches are working towards sub-cultural explanations of criminal/deviant activity.

  1. How far does Becker's account (The Outsiders 1963) of the processes underlying the selective ...

    In this social process, whether somebody is punished may depend on how much power the victim has and how much power the offender has, as well as the power of the enforcement agency. Becker's school of thought concerning selective enforcement included that of "symbolic interactionism".

  2. Discuss, critically evaluating the ways in which positivist ideas have found expression in explanations ...

    This led to a system of classification for criminals, from which several categories were produced including born criminals, insane criminals and criminaloids. Lombroso's ideas on physiognomy and phrenology became popular in Italy for several reasons. At the time Italy was experiencing social problems, one of which was lack of prison space and funding.

  1. What have theories of deviance added to our understanding of crime? Why are there ...

    Social pathology theories suggest that criminals have distinctive traits - biogenic (genetic oddness), psychogenic (unfavourable family circumstances) and sociogenic (the individual is socialised by parents or their neighbourhood, for example). Lombroso saw it as a mental deficiency, studying 3000 soliders and concluding that those with vitamin deficiency upon the pathology

  2. Outline & Evaluate the Marxist view of crime (45 Marks)

    Chambliss agrees with sneider's argument, he argues that the main focus of laws is to protect private property and the interests of the ruling class. Marxists also say that the upper class have the power to prevent issues from being discussed and never becoming a law, as it enables the

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work