• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Critically compare and contrast two theories of Western schooling with respect to the following statement: Education acts as an agent for the reproduction of the social order and the preservation of status of the privileged in society.

Extracts from this document...


Critically compare and contrast two theories of Western schooling with respect to the following statement: Education acts as an agent for the reproduction of the social order and the preservation of status of the privileged in society. The term 'school' has its origins in a Greek word meaning leisure or recreation. In pre- industrial societies, schooling was available only to the few who had enough time and money available to pursue to it (Giddens, 1989). However, education in its modern form, involves the instruction of pupils within specially constructed school premises (classrooms). Also, in advanced industrial societies education is provided by the state as a matter of right for all its citizens. The acquisition of knowledge has become increasingly based upon abstract learning rather than upon the mere transmission of specific skills from parents to their children. In a modern society people have to be equipped with basic skills such as reading, writing and calculating on top of having knowledge of their physical, social and economic environment (Gittler, 1957). Modern education has been studied immensely by various sociologists. There exist a number of theories on the nature of modern education. We will review, compare and contrast two such theories of modern schooling in this essay. The primary goal of an educational institution is the socialization of young people. Human culture is not biologically inherited but learned (Giddens, 1989). Also, very young people develop social personalities through adult care and teaching. It is due to these two reasons that educational institutions are of utmost necessity (Hebding and Glick, 1992). ...read more.


They propose that the student's lack of control over work in school reflect his or her future situation in the workplace. Lack of personal involvement and fulfillment in schoolwork results in alienation from work in later life. Thus they conclude that individuals are prepared for their work roles by a close correspondence between the social relationships which govern personal interaction in the work place and the social relationships of the educational system (Haralambos and Heald, 1980). Finally, Bowles and Gintis examine the relationships between education and occupational rewards. They reject the claim that higher qualifications result in an individual obtaining a highly paid job. They argue that the main factors accounting for occupational rewards are the individual's class of origin, race, and sex. Thus, Bowles and Gintis conclude that the intellectual abilities developed or certified in school make little causal contribution to getting ahead economically (Haralambos and Heald, 1980). Hence, Bowles and Gintis viewed educational system as a means of promoting inequality in the society. This is because educational attainment as well as occupational reward is based on merit. Education creates the belief that those at the top deserve their privilege and those at the bottom have only themselves to blame. Having established the principles of the two theories, we can now compare and contrast them in relation to the above statement. Durkheim was of the view that education acts as an important agent which helps in the subsistence of social order. Education helps in the transmission of norms and values but many critics view these as norms and values of the ruling class and not those of a society as a whole (McNall and McNall, 1992). ...read more.


Durkheim's approach was more functional whereas that of Bowles and Gintis took an approach from an economic perspective. Although both the theories are contradicting of each other in most aspects, they agree with one another in that education is a key element which plays a dominant role in shaping the society. Although Bowles' and Gintis' approach have attracted many criticisms, Durkheim's theory is also not fully accepted. It is now accepted that education does produce inequalities among the members of the society, also, as Bowles and Gintis claim the inequalities exist due to one's own actions. Thus, as Durkheim portrayed, any individual can attain education as long as he or she tries to attain it and thus ascend to the level of ruling class. Until this happens however, there will always be a fissure amongst those in the ruling class and those of other classes in the society. Thus although education is not the only factor responsible for inequalities in our society, it plays a major role in distinguishing individuals from one another based on the level of education attained. Although several studies have been carried out by sociologists to understand the nature of education and schooling, it is not possible to conceive the nature of these with the help of a single theory. A number of theories must be reviewed carefully and future research is required to understand schooling and education completely. We reviewed a couple of such theories in this essay to try and comprehend what we can from them about education. Although there exists a number of differences between the two, both of them serve their purpose of providing a fair explanation about the nature of education and schooling. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Work & Leisure section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Work & Leisure essays

  1. What is education for? Critically evaluate the diverse functions of education with reference to ...

    There were three categories of schools, these were, grammar, secondary modern and technical schools- There was not many of the latter built so the system more or less became bipartite- If an individual passed the eleven plus there place at grammar school where an academic curriculum would be pursued was guaranteed.

  2. Examination of the Functionalist view that schools serve the interests of both society and ...

    They argue that it is necessary to instil this subservience in order to create a docile workforce, which ensures false consciousness and avoids revolution. Secondly they argue that the education system produces the acceptance of hierarchy, there is a clear hierarchy in schools, i.e.

  1. Functions of the family for individuals and for society

    These two factors achieve love and security within the family which helps to protect them from the stresses of the industrial life. Parsons stated that this unit is vital to the well being of society. However, Murdock and Parsons Structural Functionalists analysis of the functions of the family has been

  2. Examining equality in Education.

    Indians in Britain are one parent families in which the parent is in paid employment and the child is left without close parental supervision for the early years of its life. Over the years, sociological research into educational attainment has focussed mainly on class.

  1. a) With reference to the Items and elsewhere, assess the view that the introduction ...

    Bordiue created the idea of a cultural capital, a dominant culture that rules society and is present in the education system. It is the middle class culture with their language, norms, values, beliefs and attitudes. It is taught in the school which disadvantages working class children and give the middle class an advantage.

  2. Higher Education in the USA. Finishing school is the beginning of ...

    Schet Adequate - Adekvatnyj Admission - Dopusk Admitted - Dopuschennyj Advantage - Preimuschestvo Agriculture - Sel'skoe hozyajstvo Amount - Kolichestvo Applicant - Pretendent Application - Zayavlenie Association of American Colleges(AAC) - Associaciya Amerikanskih Kolledzhej Available - Dostupnyj Aware - Znaya B Bachelor's degree - Stepen' Bakalavra Be either - Byt'

  1. 'The function of education is to reproduce and legitimate social inequality. Discuss.'

    Pierre Bourdieu (1997) claimed that it was cultural capital - chiefly commanded by the middle classes - which reinforced social inequality within society. The advantages of cultural capital are particularly evident in children at a young age and can be viewed as one of the major arguments against the Tripartite system which divided children at eleven.

  2. Using material from Item A and elsewhere assess the contribution of functionalist sociology to ...

    There are a number of criticisms of Davis and Moore; one is that income is only weakly linked to educational attainment. A second criticism is that intelligence has little effect on educational attainment and also that social stratification prevents the education system from efficiently grading individuals in term of ability.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work