• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Critically examine the relationship between gender, religious participation and religious organisations

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Critically examine the relationship between gender, religious participation and religious organisations. (40) Many feminist sociologists argue that religious institutions and beliefs help legitimise gender inequality. Like Marxists, feminists argue that religion is a source of domination and oppression. However, unlike Marxism, they see religion as a product of patriarchy, rather than capitalism. They argue that religion is patriarchal in that women are exploited by men and seen as subordinate. Feminist sociologists are interested in how women have become subservient and how religion has promoted patriarchy. This view is not just shared by female and feminist sociologists. Anthony Giddens argues that; " The Christian religion is a resolutely male affair in its symbolism as well as its hierarchy. While Mary, the mother of Jesus may sometimes be treated as if she had divine qualities, God is the father, a male figure, and Jesus took the human shape of a man. Woman is portrayed as created from the rib taken from a man." (Giddens 1997). Similarly, Karen Armstrong argues that; "None of the major religions have been particularly good to women." She argues that women continue to be excluded from key roles in religion despite the fact that woman participate more in organised religion. Evidence from the British Social Attitudes Survey suggests that 65% of church attenders living in Britain are women, compared to only 35% of men. This evidence suggests that women are subservient within religion as a result of patriarchy. ...read more.

Middle

Similarly, in 1992, the Church of England supported the ordination of women. Simon and Nadell (1995) conducted a study on women in religious organisations by interviewing 32 female Rabbis and 27 female Protestants. Their results showed that women conducted themselves in a totally different way than the male religious members. Female Rabbis were asked whether they "carried out their duties different to the male Rabbis of the same age and training". Almost all of the women replied "yes", describing themselves as less formal, more people orientated, more inclined to touch and hug, and less concerned about power struggles than the male clergy. This evidence suggests that some religious organisations allow women to have an important religious role. However, Simon and Knells study showed that female Rabbis conducted themselves in a totally different way than male Rabbis. Female Rabbis were more interested than caring for other people, rather than interested in power. Many Christian feminists argue that there will never be gender equality in the church if God continues to be associated with masculinity. Simone de Beauvoir (The second sex,1953) has a similar view on religion to that of Marxists. She argued that religion is used by men to control and oppress women and is a way of compensating for their low status. Like Marxists view, religion gives women the false belief that they will be rewarded for their low status in the afterlife. ...read more.

Conclusion

Similarly, in India, the rise of Hindu fundamentalism has made it difficult for the government to intervene with family life or to encourage greater freedom for women. Likewise, in Afghanistan, Iran and Israel, they insist on conserving women's traditional positions, making it difficult for women to gain control. Cohen and Kennedy (2000) argue that "the desire to restore fundamentalist religious values and social practices is associated with the fear that any real increase in women's freedom of choice and action will undermine the foundations of tradition, religion, morality and, it could be argued, male control." This evidence suggests that fundamentalism has restored traditional values in fear of increasing women's freedom. However, not all women are unwilling to return to traditional roles. Research by Woodhead and Heelas (2000) suggests that women converted to Orthodox Judaism in the U.S, as they were attracted to the status in the home that it provides them with. Overall, evidence suggests that gender; religious organisations and religious participation are linked together. Feminists argue that religion has promoted patriarchy, and that women are seen as subordinate to men, however, there is evidence to suggest that this has not always been the case. This is linked to women's status within religious organisations, as many women have a restricted role within religion, with few religions allowing women to have an important role, for example, a priest. However, despite women having a limited role within religion, evidence suggests that women are more religious than men. Jessica Pemberton ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Sociological Differentiation & Stratification section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Sociological Differentiation & Stratification essays

  1. Growth of Religious Fundamentalism

    For example in counties such as Pakistan, Afghanistan and Somalia have differing views despite sharing the same Islam religion. Postmodernism tends to make an impact on the secularism of society. It is often defined as free combinations of thought in several different orders so it is hard to explain the exact theory of postmodernism.

  2. Assess the view that cults, sects and new age movement are fringe organisations that ...

    this means normal people in modern society would not particularly stray from there lives in mainstream society to lead strict lives. However their self denying ways means their social and status rises bringing them greater public acceptance, but this means they are contacting more with mainstream society so they are

  1. Examine the extent to which husbands and wives now have a relationship based on ...

    He sampled 38 middle class couples and examined the conjugal roles in each, finding that none of the couples had joint conjugal roles in relation to housework, yet 44.6% of them did have joint roles in relation to childcare, even though women spent more time on them.

  2. Evaluate sociological explanations of the relationship between gender and religious belief and practice.

    Durkheim sees religion not only as the source of social solidarity, but also our intellectual capacities. This suggests that for Durkheim, religion is the origin of human thoughts, reason and science. In contrast, Durkheim's functionalist approach has been hugely criticised by postmodernists for example who argue that, Durkheim's ideas cannot

  1. Assess the view that religious beliefs and practices are changing to reflect a new ...

    Stark and Bainbridge argue that religion thrives in the USA because there?s never been a religious monopoly there but this differs in Europe. Therefore they conclude that the main factor influencing the level of religious participation isn?t the demand for religion like the secularisation theory suggests but the supply.

  2. The relationship between religious beliefs, religious organisations and social groups is complex and diverse. ...

    She supports the Marxist perspective and suggests that religion is oppressive and serves to control and reimburse the second class status given to woman. Which is similar to Marx?s viewpoint on the polerteriants who believe religion gives women a false belief that they will be compensated for their suffering on earth by equality in heaven.

  1. Assess the view that sects and cults inevitably turn into denominations and churches. 33m

    aspects from all organisations; Aldridge argues that groups such as the church of the latter day saints (Mormons) have an ambiguous positions, in the USA they are seen as a denomination but in the UK they are seen as deviant and are therefore regarded more like sects.

  2. Creating Gender: Nurture Vs. Nature

    If a parents daughter approaches them asking if they could join the cheerleading team at school then it is likely that they will be happy and may even praise their child. On the other hand, if a boy were to approach his parents asking to join the cheerleading team at

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work