• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Did the BATF and the FBI attempt to cover up agents conduct at the standoff with Branch Davidians in 1993

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Waco: Radicalising the Right? An enormous and alarming concentration of resources- taxpayers money, government personnel and time, not to mention many lives were expanded on the social problem allegedly taking place in Waco, Texas. According to news sources, the planned raid of the Mount Carmel Branch Davidian property by the BATF (Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco and Firearms) was one of the largest civilian law enforcement actions in US history. "For years now, the disaster near Waco has been exhibit No. 1 for many who have deep distrust of the American government." From conspiracy sites on the Internet to documentary films, Waco has provided a focus for those who see the government as the enemy. And now they say there is proof the government has been lying. The initial operation involved approximately eighty federal agents, armed with semi-automatic and automatic weapons, orchestrated to execute a single search and arrest warrant. After the failed siege, in which at least six sect members and four agents died in a gun battle, and the ensuing 51 day standoff, in which an estimated 74 Davidians died, 21 of whom were children, the final toll included the tragic deaths of 84 people and cost the taxpayer 100 million dollars. By the end of the whole affair, an army in excess of 700 federal and state officials were involved in one capacity or another. The cruelest irony of all is that it need never have happened in the first place. A careful analysis of the so-called problem posed by the Branch Davidians suggests one that is hardly proportional to the official reaction it prompted. ...read more.

Middle

Mostly it was treated as non-reimbursable (military aid to law enforcement has to be reimbursed to Defense, unless it relates to drug law enforcement). The FBI also drew upon the military for some incredibly high-tech support. Three years later, the Army realized that the operation had been improperly funded, and demanded return of the funds. In March, 1996, the Army's General Counsel advised that the funds had been improperly used and that there is no evidence to suggest that David Koresh or any of the Davidians were ever involved in drugs. In fact, it appears from a variety of sources, including Retired BATF Deputy Director, Robert Sanders that "the planning of Waco and the manner in which it was done was for publicity." In addition to this, Public Relations Manager for the Bureau, Sharon Wheeler, contacted Dallas Television Stations 5 and 8 to warn of a significant event in the near future. Some historians have cited such actions of the BATF as their Congressional hearings were to follow in the following week and "such an event would increase political pressure upon congress to increase their budget". David Koresh's attorney Dick DeGuerin summed up BATF's attitude about the time they planned the raid: "It had looked to them like a dream situation - a bunch of religious nuts their SWAT teams could practice on. Who'd complain? Who'd care? Now that the "cold war" is over, the federal government needs internal enemies. Allowing the government to scapegoat any group puts us all at risk." Once the ATF realised that their assault on the Branch Davidian property to serve a search and arrest warrant on the suspicion that the ...read more.

Conclusion

However, rather than simply degrading, I argue the post-modern movement in general is a distaste reaction to such inequality, conspiracy and injustice experienced by minorities similar to David Koresh and the Davidians. It cannot be denied that the movement is not a dangerous device of those modern day historians willing to use it. However, ones further analysis to the purpose and perspective of the historian often reveals a class based persecution, injustice and struggle suppressed by an elitist opportunist. Citizens do not spend their weekends training with militia in a country at peace with itself. This structural analysis has been critical of both media and the authorities in handling the situation in Waco. The media have contributed directly to development and promotion of the anti-cult paradigm, to the extent that it can reasonably be referred to as a dominant hegemony of thought about new religions among the general public. There is a politically correct ideological position on so-called cults. All indications are that the confrontation between the BATF and the Branch Davidians in Waco, Texas was a set-up, planned for public relations purposes. The BATF had the news media alerted, the cameras rolling, and a search warrant that was obtained on trumped up charges. They disregarded the invitation of the Branch Davidians to peacefully enter the building and have a look around. They ignored opportunities to arrest David Koresh when he was alone. They recklessly ignored the presence of innocent women and children, and staged a paramilitary-style assault on the community. For what? To make a political statement, to enforce the morals of society, or to enforce the psyche of political correctness by retaliating against the religious fringe?" ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Media section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Media essays

  1. To what extent do media representations of refugees and asylum seekers limit their integration ...

    Media briefings have also been organised by the Refugee Council and Media Wise to promote media ethics, and the Home Office CF Project has organised events with representatives from the local media, to explore issues surrounding the portrayal of refugees and to ensure better understanding of the complexities of the asylum situation.

  2. Moral Panic and media folk devils.

    When asked what they thought the main problems in society are they responded with- Drugs and alcohol abuse- 18 votes = 72% Race issues and discrimination- 18 votes = 72% Crime- 10 votes = 40% Crime was more of a concern here.

  1. How might a sociologist account for the high incidence of eating disorders among women?

    and the advent of bulimia in the 1970s' (Brown & Jasper 1993 p27) This may go some way in reinforcing the argument that the media has an effect of the prominence of eating disorders. At the time of these adverts men were being portrayed at healthy but not unnaturally attractive

  2. Cultural and Media Analysis

    'Visual Pleasure and Narrative Cinema'. Within this piece of work Mulvey outlines that both men and women occupy different areas of the text. Women are defined by Mulvey as being the "object of the look and men as being in control of the gaze" (Nelmes, 2003:254).

  1. Does violence in the media effect peoples behaviours and opinions?

    The Two Step Flow model however suggests that our family and friends influence us more than the media because of the fact that friends and family are more direct in helping us to form opinions and regulate our opinions. This argues against the view that the hypodermic model suggests The

  2. Discuss evidence from at least 2 areas where it has been argued that media ...

    Wherever we look, wherever we listen, wherever we go, we are bombarded with media messages and images, billboards, bus side placards, 'in your face' storefront signs and displays, junk mail, bumper stickers, street corner handouts, business cards and blaring radios, newspapers and TV.

  1. War on Waifs: The Enemy in the Mirror.

    In an article entitled, "Dying to be thin," sufferers agreed that they "would like to see the fashion industry present a range of sizes in magazines just like you see in the stores." Susie Orbach, the therapist who treated the late Princess Diana for her bulimia, has similar thoughts on the controversy: "Eating problems are now at epidemic proportions.

  2. Adolescence, Alcohol and Driving.

    * In 1996, over 17,000 people died in alcohol-related car crashes in the United States.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work