• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss, critically evaluating the ways in which positivist ideas have found expression in explanations of crime and criminality.

Extracts from this document...


FOR THE ATTENTION OF PROFESSOR ADAM CRAWFORD 'The positivist method leads to the categorisation and differentiation of criminal types without end. It also tends to treat people as lacking free will, as they are perceived as destined to criminality by some prior factor or characteristic.' Discuss, critically evaluating the ways in which positivist ideas have found expression in explanations of crime and criminality. Over the years, the ideas and theories of criminologists have developed and as new theories have emerged, those surrounding the causes of crime have been widely studied. Early criminologists adopted a classical gaze, focusing on the crime committed as opposed to the criminal committing it. Beccaria and Bentham were two key role players in the eighteenth century, believing that everyone acts out of their own free will and that most crime is an exploitation of opportunity. They believed in deterrence and that clear laws should be set down so that everyone knew the consequences which would befall them were they to commit a certain crime. The theory was that human beings wished to avoid pain and loss in the pursuit of pleasure and profit and therefore, in order to deter committal of a crime, the punishment (pain) should outweigh the pleasure and gain of committing the crime. Classicism places certain crimes into certain categories and believes very much that human beings have the same free will and therefore the same choices of whether or not to commit a crime. ...read more.


Because of his seemingly reliable classification system, Lombroso often got called to testify at trials. S.J. Gould said of Lombroso's testimonies "...we cannot know how many men were condemned unjustly because they were extensively tattooed, failed to blush of had unusually large jaws or arms."1 This seems to be one of the more substantial arguments against scientific criminology. The fact that some people who have the characteristics associated with criminal deviance will overcome their natural criminal tendencies and be able to live normal lives should not go unnoticed. The argument here is that not everyone who shares the 'criminal' characteristics set down by Lombroso should immediately be classified in the same way. For example, in the early twentieth century a pupil of Lombroso's named Garofalo was involved with an American movement which took it upon themselves to sterilise thousands of society's deviants in order to prevent them from reproducing and bringing children who may share the same 'criminal' genes into the world. Although this is an extreme case of eugenics, it sparks the idea that in some cases, scientific criminology has been used in an immoral way, depriving people of basic human rights which even if these people are criminals, they are nevertheless entitled to. If Lombroso's theory that criminals are born bad is to be believed, then it could be said that people with criminal tendencies are in the same way mentally incapacitated. ...read more.


They also discovered that crime rates are higher in areas with social problems. These findings are important in the way we deal with crime today. Being able to pinpoint where criminal problems lie and do something about them is invaluable to the smoother running of a society. Also, the correlation between crime rates and social problems means that it is possible to tackle these problems by building new facilities for example, and therefore hopefully lowering crime rates. The positivist school of thought has helped society a great deal by laying out certain points, characteristics and patterns which should be looked for when dealing with and attempting to explain crime and criminality. The logic behind the theories gives clear, thought out analysis to what would otherwise be a society where the problem of crime is dealt with in a classical way, paying no attention to the root of the problem and heading straight for punishment instead of a cure for delinquency. Thanks to scientists such as Lombroso and Durkheim we can try and explain why criminals offend and why certain areas of a city or country have higher crime rates than others and although no one criminologist has come up with a faultless theory as to how we should best deal with crime, a combination of scientific and sociological positivist criminology is helping us to learn new techniques in crime prevention and the positive rehabilitation of offenders. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Crime & Deviance section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Crime & Deviance essays

  1. Sociological Theories on Crime and Deviance

    and gain status through crime rather than supporting families through a steady job. Murray argues the underclass is not only a source of crime. Its very existence threatens society's cohesion by undermining the values of hard work and personal responsibility.

  2. Assess The Contribution Of Control Theory To Our Understanding Of Crime And Criminality

    The use of scientific techniques was important to the positivists. Data was collected in order to explain different types of individuals and social phenomena. Naturalists and anthropologists formed the theory of evolution, which was a very critical component to the study of human criminal behaviour by the positivists.

  1. Assess the right realist view that crime is the result of biological rational factors ...

    However, these people who get into a good school will learn better core values than people who cannot afford to get into school due to material deprivation. So an informal control of better housing and education would be a good way to sort out his material deprivation which is socialising these 'criminals' into deviance.

  2. Outline and asses the different ways of measuring crime

    This means that similar crimes can not be compared with the statistics as there may have been confusion over the classification; thus making it difficult to measure the crime. Since victim surveys allow for crimes that may have had insufficient evidence to reach the courts or crimes that the victims

  1. What are the key differences between positivism and classicist approaches to crime control? Which ...

    There are numerous drawbacks to the theory such as the issue of equality and poverty.

  2. The Classical School of Criminology

    From charge to conviction, the Canadian criminal justice system is quick to comply with the certainty aspect of deterrence, yet the problem of its effectiveness lies in its inability to possess celerity-the average delay across Canada is about 18 months.

  1. Child Called It

    He was also influence by his mother. "Mother would simply grab me and smashed my face against the mirror... then she would order me to say over and over again, I'm a bad boy!" David's mother forced him to believe that he was a problem child. These are all forms of child abuse If anyone is in

  2. What explanations have been suggested for occupational crime? Is it different from conventional ...

    finding new ways to make ends meet, and that means going on the fiddle. If wages are low and prices are high, it is not surprising that ends have to be met in other ways. Is the government to blame for the vast amount of fiddling?

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work