• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Evaluate Marxist and Neo-Marxist beliefs about society

Extracts from this document...


Marxism and Neo- Marxism both consider capitalist society to be divided by class; however Marxists claim that the bourgeoisie supress the poor by using religion as a tool, but Neo-Marxists instead believe it can be a force for social change. Evidence supporting the Marxist view comes from the fact that throughout history and in current time, religions have promoted the fatalistic beliefs in poverty such as the Hindu caste system, and have used religion to suppress rebellion ? such as slavery. This supports Marx?s theory of the ?opium of the masses?. However, Marxist views can be criticised as outdated, so Neo-Marxism may be more relevant to the functions of religion in society today. Other theories such as Feminists and Functionalists criticise the perspective as it ignores many functions of religion, such as the oppression of women and the unifying quality of religion. Firstly the ?role and function? of religion must be defined as the part that religion plays in society, and the effects it has on people according to Marxist theories. ...read more.


Marxists would therefore say this is a sign of religion controlling people, feminists would say that this particular parable sheds light on the gender inequality of Christianity. There is evidence for this use of religion, for example, Protestant religious beliefs provide discipline and a hope of salvation in after life to some of the poorest in America, discouraging them from supporting radical beliefs and supporting US capitalist values. However Neo-Marxist combats this view that religion always keeps the poor oppressed by providing them the means to change their life. Engels believes that because people use religion to cope like Marxists claim, they have a united set of beliefs. When Christian sects opposed Roman rule, he compared them to political movements campaigning for freedom like religious groups today oppose capitalist oppression. Marx saw religion as causing alienation which mirrors the alienation working class feel in the workplace. Because humans invent a God, who has control over them, they deny themselves the right to make their own decisions; this is reflected in life. ...read more.


The Neo-Marxist perspective may be more relevant than Marxism, because it acknowledges the class divide however doesn?t see it as ?black and white?, and there are many examples of religion being radical e.g. in Poland the Catholic Church opposed the ruling Communist party. Instead of being a ?materialist? like Marx, believing that material forces like the economy shaped society, Weber was an ?idealist? believing beliefs shaped society. His ideas include Calvinism (a Protestant form) shaping society to become Capitalist after workers had to behave virtuously and hard working. This idea compliments Marx?s theory that religion can encourage passivity, however Weber highlights beliefs influencing society rather than the opposite. The Marxist perspective is useful for showing the underpinning values that religion teaches, and how these beliefs can benefit the rich in a capitalist society. Because of the decline in religion and the reduction in class divide however, although more relevant in some countries where the class divide is strong, this view is probably more outdated in today?s society than the Neo-Marxist thesis, because due to Marxist theories being formed in the industrial period when capitalism was emerging and the class divide was extreme. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Sociological Differentiation & Stratification section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Sociological Differentiation & Stratification essays

  1. Modern Britain is now a secular society

    Steven Bruce (2001) argues that the opinion poll data show a strong weakening of religious belief. Belief in a personal God has declined markedly, as has belief in "some sort of spirit or life force". Bruce argues that this represents a big increase in skepticism towards religious belief.

  2. Analyse and Evaluate the relationships between religion and social change.

    consensus and the other identifying society as being fundamentally divided and unequal although neither set of assumptions are provable. There are also many instances when religion appears to have had a change promoting effect. Feminism have seen religion as a conservative force, where Marxist as seen religion as maintaining the power of the ruling class.

  1. Assess the nature and extent of secularization in society today. Evidence surrounding church attendance ...

    However, other sociologists have strongly challenged these views. Roof and Mckinney note the growth of conservative Protestant religions, which seem to combine a serious commitment to religious teachings, a strong element of theological doctrine and a refusal to compromise religious beliefs.

  2. Sociological theories and Healthcare.

    For example if someone dies of aids they won't class it as aids they will class it as 'pneumonia'. So we're not always getting the right information or correct information regarding an illness. Basically two people could go to doctors with the same illness and the doctor could say to

  1. Assess The Extent To Which Marxist & Feminist Theories Help Our Understanding Of Religion ...

    This all relates as to how society is kept in place, for Marxists, society composes of these two classes and the position of how these lower classes are kept in place helps us understand that this is the role of religion today.

  2. Compare and contrast Marxist and functionalist views of religion.

    All of these things are dealt with by religious rituals where the whole of society comes together to help each other. This shows social solidarity. Therefore as w hole the functionalist theory sees religion as a positive thing and believes that it benefits society as w hole.

  1. fabric of society

    New Labour is trying to tackle the problem in such areas that are dominated by social housing were a majority of under class are residents. (Gordon, D. Pantazis, C. 2000) The mass media refers to all forms of written communication to the public, for example newspapers, magazines, books and forms of transmitted communication such as radio, television and cinema.

  2. An investigation into people(TM)s belief about Hell

    with religion' something that will be defined by the following questions (questions 1-5) that they will complete if they answered yes to question 1. Question 1 is included so that a comparison can be made between the number of religious people who believe in Hell and the number of non-religious

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work