• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Evaluate the accuracy of official statistics of crime.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Evaluate the accuracy of official statistics of crime. Official statistics of crime are collected by the home office which means that patterns and trends can easily be found. Positivists favour this as they believe them to be social facts. Durkheim used them in his study of suicide, he felt that society was not reducible to individuals. And he found out that there was a significant variation in rates of suicide of different populations and that they stayed remarkably consistent over time. From this he found four different types of suicide which showed why a person may have committed suicide. He concluded that suicide is not an individual act but has its roots in society. However, Interpretivists would question the usefulness of official statistics, Douglas suggested that statistical approaches into suicides like Durkheim's ignore meanings that individuals have for committing suicide. Douglas believed that to interpret why a person had committed suicide you had to get into the 'inner world' of the suicide person, i.e. read their diaries and suicide notes. Positivists argue that official statistics are useful in gaining an insight into crime as they show who, what and where. Another key strength is that patterns and trends can easily be identified and so therefore analysis is easy which allows correlations to be made. ...read more.

Middle

Many crimes such as corporate crime and victimless crimes are excluded and crimes against under 16 year olds are also excluded. Despite victim surveys being anonymous it seems that people it seems that people still seem to under-report sexual offences, and also basing statistics on victims memories can be biased. There are also problems of accuracy as the BCS often chooses the sample used, also as the participants are given a computer to key in offences committed against them the BCS can get away with not putting official or legal categories into the computer, further effecting the validity of ant crime statistics. Figures like these do not appear in official statistics so its validity could be questioned. The police play a large part in official statistics as it is left to them to decide what is considered to be or not to be a crime; only 40 % of crime that is reported to the police is actually recorded. Many police departments want their area to look like its crime statistics are under the nation's average. There are many ways for them to do this one of which is 'cuffing' this is where a current prisoner will be asked to admit to crimes he/she did not commit, they will not be prosecuted for this. ...read more.

Conclusion

Only about 30% of crime is solved therefore we cannot tell to what extent convicted criminals resemble un-convicted ones. Offences are cleared up by either primary means or secondary means which can be unreliable as secondary means involve a prisoner admitting to a crime which due to cuffing they may not have done. New counting rules saw the clear up rates for England and Wales go down from 38% in 1981 to 29% in 1998-99. Crime statistics in England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland can't be directly compared as the legal systems differ. Also the counting rules differ as in Scotland each individual offence occurring within an incident is recorded whereas in the other countries only the main offence is counted. Institutionalists reject the objectivity of official figures and attempt to show how they are neither valid nor reliable. They say that statistics do not show the real picture as most crime is out of sight out of mind. However, Realists would argue that the figures are objective indicators of the social phenomenon they are supposed to reflect, they deny that the problems arising are a result of power but are instead the product of technical incompetence. Marxists believe that law and its enforcement reflects the interests of the ruling class. The crimes of the poor are strictly enforced and the immoral activities of the rich are either ignored or not defined as criminal, statistics well reflect these inequalities and scapegoating. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Crime & Deviance section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Crime & Deviance essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Assess the Usefulness of Official Crime Statistics to a Sociological Understanding of Crime

    4 star(s)

    This victimization of ethnic minorities through police discrimination and racism is an important element in the assessment of official statistics. This can be seen from figures issued by the Home Office in June 2000 where there was an over representation of ethnic minorities in prisons in Britain and where 19%

  2. Outline and assess the usefulness of official statistics in measuring crime and deviance

    the fact the majority of the public believe that the police will not think their crime is a priority therefore doesn't matter. However it is believe this is made ineffective by the growth of the insurance industry and companies needing a crime number before they handle people cases.

  1. Describe the meaning of official statistics, victim surveys and self-reported studies as ways of ...

    Various tests such as lie detector tests have been carried out to check the accuracy of self reported studies. It has been found that approximately 80% of those questioned tell the truth. Self reported studies are there for not total reliable, although the do locate many more offenders placed in

  2. Critically evaluate Marxists contributions to the study of crime and deviance.

    Quinney adds that crime will increase and there will be greater demands for more and more police. When the cost of policing become so great that they are no longer economic, then the state will drop its mask of neutrality and the bourgeoisie will resort to direct political rule through dictatorship.

  1. 'Evaluate the use and importance of official crime statistics both in the tracking of ...

    Therefore, if we do not have a clear picture from true and accurate statistics, it would appear to be futile to rely on these for the purposes of tracking crime or, indeed, in applying the measures taken against it. The 'dark figure' of crime (unrecorded crimes)

  2. Does the media heighten fear of crime?

    (Robbie and Sutton 2005). Research methods are unquestionably problematic. In conclusion to their finding that men lie much more when being questioned about their fear of crime, they suggest that future surveys should, where possible, include a lie scale. This would allow researchers to statistically control for socially desirable responding when looking at the responses of participants.

  1. Official Crime Statistics Analysis

    "A positivistic method is like instructions on a child's chemistry set". 2% of all crimes committed result in conviction because of trivial, seriousness of offence and allocation of resources. "Hidden" figure number of unrecorded crime Heidensohn: Most sociological theories based on OCS have solely focus on male criminality and neglect the fact that 20% of crime is committed by females.

  2. Outline and evaluate Durkheims theory of suicide.

    The social integration such as their mental state, where they lived, how old they were, which religion, the social class, what kind of work history they held, their income, wealth and what sex they were just as Durkheim did. Hindess however attacked the interpretists approach to the statistics used.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work