• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

In what way can the state be accused of taking part in criminal activity?

Extracts from this document...


´╗┐By Elizabeth Dale Sociology In what way can the state be accused of taking part in criminal activity? (21 marks) Many have argued that the state can breach individual?s human rights. Human rights can be defined as ?A right that is believed to belong justifiably to everyone?. Schwendinger (1970) argues that we should define crime in terms of the violation of basic human rights rather than the breaking of legal rules. Cohen believes some acts aren?t illegal even though we find them immoral. However, Herman argues that we should label acts criminal if they go against our human rights. Sociologists should defend human rights even if it is against the state. It is a form of transgressive criminology. This means when states deny the rights of an individual; they must be regarded as criminals. This shows us that the state knowingly, violates human rights when they are committing crimes such as genocide. The term genocide refers to violent crimes committed against national, ethnic, racial or religious groups. A recent example of genocide is Darfur, a region in Sudan, where a civil war has been raging since 1983. ...read more.


However, that the officers denied that the killing was unlawful and claimed that their actions were legitimate. Therefore, the De Menezes case illustrates two aspects of the Neutralisation Theory because the officers denied the victim and denied the responsibility. They were also found not guilty. States have the ability to get others to commit crimes due to obedience. Some sociologists argue that torture and other crimes are part of the role that people are socialized into by the State. They look at the conditions that make such behaviour acceptable. Sociologists like Kelman & Hamilton (1989) have focused on ?crimes of obedience?. They used the My Lai massacre where American soldiers killed 400 civilians as an example. This allows us to understand the people who commit the crimes are just the ?bad apples? produced by the ?bad apple makers?, who are influenced to believe that what they are doing is admissible and legal. Kelman and Hamilton developed three features that produce crimes of obedience: Authorisation: the status of the commander, Routinisation: strong emphasis on turning the criminal act into a routine act and Dehumanisation: the enemy is portrayed as inhuman (e.g. ...read more.


Governments have the power and resources to cover up such activities and can actually control the flow of information and especially the media by issuing legal instructions to prevent journalists from speaking about state crimes in the ?public interest?. State crime is clearly an area of interest to Marxist sociologists, who generally see the government as controlled or at least heavily influenced, by the bourgeoisie. War crimes can be committed by individuals, groups and the state. They are punishable offences under international law. War crimes committed by the state include directing attacks against civilians, torture or inhumane treatment of prisoners, taking hostages, using civilians as shields, using child soldiers, and settlement of an occupied territory. For example a strong argument has been made by International Human Rights lawyers that those held by the American government in Guantanamo have been subject to torture and inhuman treatment in order to extract information. Methods used by the Americans include ?Waterboarding?, which breaches international standards for human rights. Recent war trials include Saddam Hussein, who was found guilty by an Iraqi court and then hanged. It is problematic and controversial to decide what a war crime is and who is a war criminal. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Crime & Deviance section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Crime & Deviance essays

  1. Teenage Suicide in the United States - comparing suicide rates in Europe and East ...

    996 Chinese adolescents who were living in Hong Kong were asked to complete a survey about suicide. Intriguingly, the reason many wanted to attempt or commit suicide was due to major pressure from their parents. Unlike the reasons of teenagers of the U.S which are peer pressure, depression, or the media (Kanalley).

  2. Methods we can use to study and understand crime and criminal beaviour

    It just states that one-tenth of population is Chinese. A lot of people don't understand that statistics should be approached with a strong dose of caution and distance. We cannot believe completely in statistics because it may lead to some really unfortunate misunderstandings and innocent people may get hurt.

  1. Do people choose to commit crime or are they propelled in to criminal activity?'

    This can be seen in Foucault's work2. It sought an emphasis on free will and human rationality. The Classical School was not interested in studying criminals, but rather law-making and legal processing. Crime, they believed, was activity engaged in, out of total free will and that individuals weighed the consequences of their actions in their minds.

  2. Inequalities within the 'Criminal JUSTICE System/Process'

    (Carvel 21/12/2000 in the Guardian) Problems about predicting potential criminality is that there is no accurate way of doing this, psychiatrists cannot decide on a definition of 'dangerousness' (Nash 1999). There are moral, cultural and political judgements used as a basis of risk assessment.

  1. How closely was criminal activity linked to economic circumstances in early modern England?

    This social and geographical distance by 1750 was tantamount to "a division of cultures"2. Gaskill argues that this division of cultures combined with economic necessity led many of the poor to crime and the social attitudes of the time did not condemn it, indeed in poor and certainly in vagrant

  2. "Seventeen years on, a greying Bamber is back in the dock to deny killing ...

    The study that I used to support my first issue of maternal deprivation is by Bowlby. Bowlby found that sixty-four per cent of the juvenile delinquents, lacked guilt and remorse, also known as affectionless psychopathy, had also experienced deprivation in early childhood.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work