• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Inequalities within the 'Criminal JUSTICE System/Process'

Extracts from this document...


Issues: Inequality in the underlying ideology Inequality in the definition of 'the crime problem' Inequality in practice in the CJS Policy...Addressing inequality? Ideological underpinnings: Talk about JUSTICE. In any society, actions taken in the name of the nation state need to be seen as 'just' in order to preserve legitimacy. When they are not seen as just then we get discontent and then often challenges to the authority of the state. We could argue that in simple terms, society is held together in part, by a type of social contract whereby individuals agree to abide by state law in return for the protection of the state. In order for this to work however, the majority of people would need to believe both that the law is generally beneficial to them, and that the administration of the law is fair and just. The presence of inequality in this process would suggest that some have a more fair and just experience than others, which is potentially problematic in as much that it causes dissatisfaction amongst some groups. However, what do we mean by fair and just? This might depend upon our perspective on what should shape criminal justice...How ideology penetrates the CJS. Stepping back from the CJS Gelsthorpe (2001 p105-6)1 suggests that there are six key competing perspectives, which influence how the system is, or should be run. These are: Due process Crime control Welfare and rehabilitative Critical socio-legal Bureaucratic Management When we look at CJ policy we will see how these pervade that policy. Explain four most significant to this lecture. Due Process: Associated with the Legal profession: 'Formal equality before the law' * Justice should be administered according to publicly known legal rules and procedures, which must be seen as just. * The court should act as an impartial arbitrator of conflicts arising between citizens * There is a presumption of innocence, a requirement to seek a measure of judicial equality, and the restraint of arbitrary powers. ...read more.


cold per year 50,000 Serious DIY accidents 1997 85,000 Homicides per year by people with mental health prob 40 Suicides per year by people with mental health prob 1000 Children murdered per year 45 Children murdered per year outside family 4 Deaths due to prescription drugs 2000 1,200 Deaths mentioning Heroin on death certificate 754 (various articles on BBC News site) Not going to go into complexities of why this is the situation, in this lecture, however the important issue here is that despite risks from elsewhere, the CJS is mainly concerned with what we see as 'the usual suspects'. When it comes to identifying 'the usual suspects' ... 'the poor, the unemployed, the unemployable, the homeless, the physically ill and the mentally disturbed,' there are opportunities to exercise discretion at every stage of the CJ process and this may be affected by the 'type' of person, the criminal justice practitioner thinks you are, could be related not only to issues such as race, class and gender, but also things like demeanour: Descretion occurs when decisions are made: Whether to stop and search. Whether to caution/charge. Whether to remand in custody or bail What type of penalty to administer. How long that custody should be. What happens in custody. Wilson and Ashton (1998 p83) argue that discretion provides opportunities for discrimination. Important because this is when 'subjective decisions' are made on an individuals 'criminal tendencies'. This is where the CJS is underpinned by the crime control model rather than the due process model. It also can potentially bring in an assessment of risk from managerialism, or the possibility of individual treatment in terms of a welfare approach. Look at race as an example: Political comment is important as it may affect public perceptions of a particular issue: July 95 Paul Condon, the then Metropolitan Police Commissioner urged ethnic community leaders to recognise that: 'it is a fact that many of the perpetrators of muggings are very young black people' (cited in Wilson and Ashton 1998 p81). ...read more.


argues that the government is more concerned with ensuring conformity rather than addressing poverty, social exclusion and inequality. Social exclusion unit about getting people out of poverty by 'New Deal' work, but in practice concentrates on undesirables such as Rough sleepers, truants and pregnant teenagers. Hough (5/6/2001 Guardian) Although there is a reform agenda eg Drug treatment and testing orders (DTTO's), that the authoritarian approach is also important, with curfew orders, parenting orders, anti-social behaviour orders, and drug testing orders all being pushed. Also he talked about the government's 'custody plus' plan, where sentencers would be able to 'pick and mix' sentences to include custody and community tariffs. Hough however is concerned that sentences might be ratcheted up, so that the offender obtains two forms of punishment instead of one. Going back to our original study about inequality in respect of race, there is a seven line statement in the crime reduction strategy about combating race hate crimes, and attempting to keep ethnic minority staff in the police. Sivanandan director of the institute of race relations (21/2/2000 Guardian) notes that nothing has been done to dismantle the policy of stop and search, which is clearly discriminatory to ethnic groups. Also according to Sivanandan, nothing has been done about the accountability of the police in respect of deaths in custody, in fact the situation has got worse in as much as 'The freedom of information bill' has exempted the police from having to make full disclosure of their actions in all areas of policing. Also police culture tends to result in officers closing ranks on such issues. (See work by Reiner 2000 on cop culture) Conclusions: Inequality exists at many levels within the CJS. Whilst some attempt has been made to address general inequality in labours policies, ideological underpinning of the CJS in terms of 'crime control', and concepts within managerialism and welfare such as decisions about individual treatment and an assessment of risk and danger, as well as the unproblematic definition of 'the crime problem' may still ensure that inequality in the CJS persists. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Crime & Deviance section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Crime & Deviance essays

  1. The Justice and welfare debate.

    They argue however that the police should make greater use of cautioning for minor offences. They point out that this would keep young people who had committed minor offence out of the criminal justice system and leave the courts free to deal with more serious offences.

  2. Crime and its effects on society. Police Reform Act 2002 The police ...

    A reprimand is a formal verbal warning given to a young person by a police officer due to a minor crime being commited. They are sometimes reffered to a youth offending team. A final warning is also a formal verbal warning to youths, they are then assed to find out the causes of their offensive behaviour.

  1. How far does Becker's account (The Outsiders 1963) of the processes underlying the selective ...

    This emphasises Becker's point of how society's reactions create deviants, if no one points it out, then deviant behaviour is not found. By negotiation, the equilibrium is not disturbed. Also, there is always the possibility of private sanctions, the employer could simply just sack the thief and not involve the police.

  2. Why is the prison population not a reflection of the ethnicity of Britain, is ...

    This could be why there is such a high crime rate among ethnic minorities. A factor that could account high crime rates in ethnic minorities is the lack of confidence in the police.

  1. Literature Review: The Impact of Heroin Prices on Robbery Trends

    in 1953, when heroin was criminalised, however there is inadequate data available on the link between the price of heroin and crime. Similarly, although Platzspitz in Switzerland, and the Netherlands28 have trialled heroin injection, heroin prescription and decriminalisation - this has not affected the cost of heroin available to the majority of heroin users.

  2. Are women underrepresented in crime statistics because of sexism within the criminal justice system?

    However Stephen Jones disagrees and argues that there is no real evidence for Pollak's claims and Heidensohn points out that typical crimes that Pollak would suggest as female, such as shoplifting, are in fact mostly carried out by men. Although much evidence has been put forward which indicates that the

  1. Assess the view that ethnic differences in crime rates are the result of the ...

    Based on a sample of 2,500 people, Graham and Bowling found that blacks and whites had very similar rates of offending, while Indians, Pakistanis and Bangladeshis had much lower rates. The findings of self-report studies challenge the stereotype of black people as being more likely than whites to offend, they

  2. In what way can the state be accused of taking part in criminal activity?

    serious questions were raised about the fact that the firearms officers? conferred with each other before writing up their statements.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work