• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Is it safe to make international comparisons of crime data?

Extracts from this document...


Is it safe to make international comparisons of crime data? The use of official statistics to measure the level of crime in today's society is currently a popular area of debate both within the criminological and sociological domains. These 'official' figures, which are collected by the police and published annually by the Home Office in 'Crime Statistics, England, and Wales', provide a foundation for comparisons to take place within societies. An importance for the statistics to be accurate and a true indicator of the number of crimes committed is vital as it acts as a method to measure the pattern and correlation of criminal behaviours in Britain for international comparisons. Criminologists, sociologists, and politicians together unite in raising a crucial question over whether these statistics are a reliable and valid means of measurement. Therefore I feel that it is necessary for data to be correct to the exact number before it can be compared with other statistical data from around the world. It is highly important for every country, around the globe, that crime data (also known as statistics) are accurate and act as a true representation to the extent and nature of crimes committed, as these figures are used to construct pictures of what the patterning of criminal behaviour actually looks like. ...read more.


In making any comparison it is necessary to be aware that such data will be the outcome of different legal and administrative systems and may also be derived from different statistical data collection process. It is seen impossible to measure the true extent of crime in any country, however if one does try to do so there are two main measures: The first is of the offence recorded by police. The second being, measures of crime from the results of victimisation surveys carried out on a sample of the public.1 However this still can be weak; although most countries collect information on the number of crimes recorded or reported by the police, absolute measures are misleading. This is due to the facts, some of which are mentioned above: > Different legal and criminal justice system > Rates of which crimes are reported to police and recorded by them! > Differences in the points that crimes are measured-some measure it as soon as it is reported to the police others wait until a suspect is identified. > Differences in the rules of measurement > Differences of the list of offences that are included in the overall crime figures. > Changed in data quality Therefore, it goes to say, that until we have a similar law and order for each and every country comparisons can not be made at an international level, worldwide. ...read more.


So far efforts to standardise statistics has been put behind/into other areas. As Gordon Barclay explained (in the lecture on 13th February) also carries out a survey of crime data worldwide, however it also fails to get complete and accurate information-common definitions are used and countries are expected to reconfigure their statistics as best as they can to fit the definition; Only to find that no country fits meets these definitions and there has been little quality control. The most recent development has been the initiative of the European Union which has set up a new committee under the European Union Crime Prevention Network3. It is carrying out an audit of what data is available on crime in EU countries and is initially focussing on three crimes: street robbery, domestic burglary and car theft. I feel that is this step is split up through the continents, like Asia and Africa and they take the same steps as carried out by the European Union Crime Prevention Network, we may then see a change in the way we look at crime data at an international level. 1 www.homeoffice.gov.uk/rds/pdfs/hosb601.pdf -the two ways of trying to measure extent of crime in any country. 2 Gordon quoted from the report of the committee appointed to revise the criminal proportion of Judicial statistics 12th December 1892 3 Home office statistical bulletin 05/02 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Crime & Deviance section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Crime & Deviance essays

  1. Free essay

    local trends in crime in Britain

    Some sociologists have tried to deny that there has been an increase in crime by pointing to the inaccuracy of the crime figures and the increase in the reporting of crime. Young (1993) argues that the rises have been so great that changes in the recording and reporting of crime cannot account for the increase.

  2. What are the uses of both qualitative and quantitative research methods for the criminological ...

    will have a direct effect on the reliability of the result regarding patterns of crime and victimisation making them more representative. In criticism of quantitative data results can be limited as they provide numerical descriptions rather than detailed narrative and generally provide less elaborate accounts of human perception.

  1. Literature Review: The Impact of Heroin Prices on Robbery Trends

    23 However, this study was completed almost three decades ago internationally, and thus does not provide adequate information for current prices on heroin and its effect on robbery trends in Australia.

  2. How far does Becker's account (The Outsiders 1963) of the processes underlying the selective ...

    Selective enforcement in Domestic Violence and White Collar Crime Official statistics do not reflect the reality of rule breaking, often due to the fact that enforcement agencies, i.e. the police, choose to do nothing about the infractions. There often exists an interaction between the rule breaker and the enforcer this is termed by Becker as "negotiations".

  1. My hypothesis I expect to find that the official crime statistics in ...

    When comparing my results from my victim survey to official British statistics I will need to keep this in mind in order to not be biased and fairly carry out my investigation. I have the official crime statistics for north Somerset, this shows the number of crimes recorded by police

  2. Crime Data

    On the most recent British Crime Survey figures, what is the most commonly experienced form of crime? According to the most recent British Crime Survey, the most commonly experienced form of crime is property related crime. This includes burglary, vehicle theft, vandalism / criminal damage and other theft.

  1. 'Examine developments in biological research into criminality and discuss whether our scientific understanding is ...

    So why think they are criminals? He concluded this research with a study done on Italian criminals, he studied three hundred and eight three of them and discovered that twenty one percent of them had one such listed characteristic, forty three percent had five or more of these characteristics.

  2. As in other areas of sociology, criminological studies have traditionally ignored half the population.

    To them this suggested that the criminals among women would not be as prevalent in comparison to men. He stated that Females were not true 'biological' criminals and those among them that were criminals tended to be more masculine than other women are.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work