Outline and assess Marxist explanations of crime and deviance.

Authors Avatar

Julie Wilcox

 Outline and assess Marxist explanations of crime and deviance.

In looking at the Marxist explanation of crime and deviance one must also look to the non-sociologist explanations and those of other different groups in order to come to an informed view of the subject.  

The non-sociologist definition of crime and deviance would be that deviance is uncommon behaviour, something that offends the morals or the majority of society, without being harmful or serious enough to be criminal.  Whereas a criminal act is an act which causes harm to someone else enough to warrant a decision-maker passing a law which forbids the act.

The Marxist theory in general splits society in half, the rich and the poor.  With the poor being exploited by the rich.  This theory appears to be the basis for all Marxist perspective including the Marxist explanations of crime and deviance.  Karl Marx stated that crime was the product of poverty and the traditional Marxist view regarding the cause of crime amongst the working classes is competition and the desire to acquire wealth.  The working class people want the ‘things’ that they see the middle classes with but they cant afford them so they resort to stealing. The explanation of the cause of the majority of crime is given as the people fighting back against the oppression of a corrupt capitalist society.  

 

According to the Marxist movement Deviant behaviour is behaviour which if frowned upon by the wealthy and powerful possibly even considered to be threatening their way of life.  Deviant people are considered to be victims of a repressive state.  When deviant behaviour is found to be a threat the people in charge come up with a new law to change deviant to criminal, for example new age travellers who were a threat as they showed young people the option of a different way of life.  At first they were labelled as drug addicts and criminals, then in 1994 the criminal justice act was passed which contained several points specifically aimed at them.  Proving the Marxist point that the rich when faced with a problem use their power to find a way round it without caring how they are affecting other peoples lives.  The laws created by the bourgeoisie (middle class) were created to protect property owned by the bourgeoisie.

Join now!

However when the wealthy are caught in deviant behaviour it is much more accepted even excused they are rarely branded criminals.  In the opinion of the Marxists the difference between illegal and deviant depends on how threatening the act is to the ruling classes and their manipulation of values.  For example if a young working class man from an inner city was involved in a street brawl which resulted in death this man could expect a heavy prison sentence.  However if a factory worker died as a result of exposure to dangerous chemicals the worst sentence to be expected ...

This is a preview of the whole essay