• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"Society originates because the individual is not self sufficient and no two of us are born exactly alike". How does Plato get from that claim to the view that philosophers should rule? Are you convinced by his claims that philosophers should rule?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

"Society originates because the individual is not self sufficient and no two of us are born exactly alike". How does Plato get from that claim to the view that philosophers should rule? Are you convinced by his claims that philosophers should rule? It is in Plato's Republic that we first get a discussion of his ideal state and the components needed for its proper function. Plato's model, known as Kallipolis, is introduced by Socrates during his dialogues with his friends and it is throughout Books I-VIII that this state is built up through three distinct stages until Plato concludes that only philosopher kings should rule. Socrates starts with what Plato labels the "first principals of social organization"1, namely the basics which are needed for an "economically self sufficient city"2; in the second stage he goes on to develop this idea. He adds luxury to the state necessitating the presence of armed forces which in turn become the governing class from which come the philosopher kings, selected by the process of the education system that Plato set up to discern those best qualified to rule. The first stage is primitive at best and simply contains the key elements needed to fulfil the "underlying principles of any society"3. ...read more.

Middle

So the city now consists not of economic equals but of people pursuing their economic function. They co-operate with each other to make life pleasant for others preparing each to subordinate his own interests to those of others. Kallipolis now has three classes, the producers, the Guardians and the Philosopher-Kings and "each member will perform that function, and only that function, for which he is destined by nature"30. To distinguish between these classes and discover to which class each person belongs Plato brings in education and also his theory of a tripartite soul. Through this education process which is a "concern of the state"31 , all people reach their full potential and thereby acknowledge their social position. To understand the nature of the philosopher kings we examine Plato's theory of the soul. There are three types of desire in the "tripartite soul" which "correspond to the three parts of the state"32; appetitive desires (base ones for things such as food, money and sex), spirited desires (for honour, victory and reputation) and rational desires (for knowledge and truth). In each person one of the three desires rules, thereby determining their class and values. ...read more.

Conclusion

The taking away of the family from the philosopher class would also in my opinion make him a worse ruler, less in touch with society and less developed as a character. Also from a secular viewpoint it is not right to put only educated rulers from one strata of society in power when those from a less education background could be more in touch with society and its needs. Also the prospect of a state education system selecting the leaders of the city is a matter of concern as the "relevant knowledge" which Plato advocates is purely a matter of opinion and therefore may be biased. Also these rational desires, that the philosopher king is supposed to have, are not I believe the monopoly of the educated. They can be found at all levels of society. Also Plato denies personal advancement in his city, especially once a person has been graded. In reality however once people have met their basic needs there is a desire for more. Also it is not natural for people to forgo private property even if they are a ruler. Therefore I would conclude that Plato's view, that the philosopher kings should rule, is incorrect and unrealistic in terms of any real society and its values. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Work & Leisure section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Work & Leisure essays

  1. Assess the claim that the nuclear family as a dominant form of family structure ...

    Graham Allen and Graham Crow support the Rapoports and argue that it is a continuing trend. Furthermore, The New Right, a conservative perspective, opposes diversity but admits that it is replacing the nuclear family, which, in their view, is the best type of family unit for society.

  2. Examination of the Functionalist view that schools serve the interests of both society and ...

    They therefore did not want to do well and actually wanted low status, manual jobs This then would suggest that 'the lads' resisted capitalism and were not turned into a docile, ideal workforce. However, whilst 'the lads' seem to being resisting capitalism they actually reproduce it by in fact wanting the low status jobs that capitalism deems they should have.

  1. Examining equality in Education.

    All of these changes have been encouraging students of all backgrounds to stay in education and attain more academically. In 1900, just 1.2% of 18 year olds entered full time further of higher education: by 1990, 36% of 16-18 year olds were in full time education, (Haralambos and Holborn, page 725).

  2. SOCIAL CLASS DIVISION

    It is claimed that teacher observation of pupils and the judgements about pupil ability and attitude which result, can have profound effects on the future performance of pupils. Interactionists argue that the labels that teachers attach to pupils are often not based on objective criteria.

  1. Obesity in todays Society

    As a general idea, the American Dietetic Association provides these thresholds for obese weight. Obesity occurs when a person has a greater calorie intake than he or she burns during that day (Hwang 1999). David F. Williamson of The New England Journal of Medicine (1999)

  2. a) With reference to the Items and elsewhere, assess the view that the introduction ...

    They say then most talented will succeed in the education system. It prepares the people for their role in society whilst allocating the most powerful jobs to those with the most ability. This shows a very strong link between education and the economy, because it shapes what the economy will be like in the future.

  1. The recent rise in support for NRMS comes mainly from an increased desire to ...

    These groups are not exclusive, and try to seek as wide a membership as possible, often by selling individuals services commercially. Unlike world rejecting groups, affirming groups have little social control over their members. This evidence suggests that individuals may reject mainstream religious values in favour of a world-affirming NRM.

  2. Does Utopia describe an ideal society

    More is able to use Hythloday's character in the book to create discussions about problems that clearly need resolving, rather than use his character as a mouthpiece as More doesn't always seem to agree with Hythloday's views. During these discussions and whilst Hythloday is offering resolutions to many of the

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work