• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The chivalry thesis claims that women will be treated more leniently for committing certain crimes, generally shoplifting is often associated more with females than males, but the statistics suggest that males commit many more acts of theft than women, an

Extracts from this document...


Using material from Item A and elsewhere, assess the value of 'chivalry thesis 'in understanding differences in crime. gfg Pollak (1950) was of the opinion that police and magistrates tended to be more 'chivalrous' and 'lenient' towards female offenders, resulting in sentence disparities, and as a result, criminal statistics underestimate the amount of female offending. (Item A). Pollak (1961) argued that men - namely in this case police officers, magistrates and judges, are socialised to be protective towards women and thus are less likely to chare or prosecute them, and are also treated more leniently in court. Pollak goes further to argue that women are accustomed to deceiving men, for example in faking orgasms during sex, or lying in a relationship to gain material wealth. This skill in deceit mean that their crimes, such as poisoning and infanticide, are less easily uncovered (item A) leading to women being underrepresented in criminal statistics. The chivalry thesis claims that women will be treated more leniently for committing certain crimes, generally shoplifting is often associated more with females than males, but the statistics suggest that males commit many more acts of theft than women, and this may be because females are let off with a warning rather than a conviction. ...read more.


Although these findings may not show the severity of the specific offences. Campbell through self report studies in 1976, of urban schoolgirls, compared to 16 year old males, these sources showed that 1.33 offences were committed by males for every 1.0 for females, this hugely contrasted to 1976 official figures on convictions, which showed 8.95 convictions for every female 1.0. This shows how official statistics can be greatly misleading, that although males may convict more crime, the gulf between the amount of offences shown by statistics, and popular opinion, is not as wide as it seems. Although these studies do give evidence towards the chivalry thesis, the bulk of research does not give this indication. Steven box 1981, reviewed data from self report studies in UK and USA, and concluded that 'the weight of evidence on women committing serious offences does not give clear support to the view that they receive differential and more favourable treatment from members of the public, police or judges'. Although it has to always be remembered that in a self report study, the validity and reliability relies upon the respondent's ability and willingness to tell the truth, which is not always apparent. ...read more.


Frances Hiedensohn 1985 slated the theory greatly, stating that is was based on analysis that had very little evidence and many unsupported assumptions, she regarded it as being based upon an unsubstantiated stereotypical image of women. In conclusion, although some parts of Pollak's chivalry thesis, namely the parts saying women are naturally more likely to conceal crime are quite unsupported and base, studies associated with the theory have hinted that women are often in some cases treated more leniently by the criminal justice system. Although the extent of this cannot really be measured, statistics would have us believe that the gap between male and female criminality is huge, but upon closer investigation this is not the case. Reasons for this may be that criminology and sociology is largely dominated by males that the research is done on males by males, leading to an underrepresentation on female crime, or that perhaps female crimes are comparatively seen as trivial and are not deemed worthy of research. Whichever way it is looked it, there is a case for the argument that females are often not treated as harshly as males upon committing crime, but of course the opposite argument could be valid also. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Crime & Deviance section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Here's what a teacher thought of this essay

4 star(s)

Overall this is a really strong essay. The content never drifts from the focus of the question, there is a good even debate on both sides of the discussion and the use of the item has been applied well. The studies applied are also very effective and support the evidence throughout. At times there is opportunity to apply key terms such as iceberg theory or the hidden figure of crime.

Marked by teacher Matthew Wilkin 04/04/2013

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Crime & Deviance essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    Assess the Usefulness of Official Crime Statistics to a Sociological Understanding of Crime

    4 star(s)

    Police often have a bias against working class delinquent and they will often target low-income estates as it is perceived more crime is committed in an under privileged area. If a fight involving young people breaks out the police see this as evidence of delinquency yet, if the same incident

  2. Sociological Theories on Crime and Deviance

    Conflict theory posits that the economic organisation of capitalist societies produces deviance and crime. The high rate of crime such as theft, robbery, prostitution, and drug selling are a result of the economic status of these groups. Rather than emphasising values and conformity as a source of deviance as do

  1. Examine the reasons why some sociologists choose to use official statistics when conducting their ...

    They are complied in a standardised way by trained staff, following set procedures. For example, the Government statisticians compile death rates for different social classes following a standard procedure that uses the occupation recorded on each person's death certificate to identity their social class.

  2. Assess the view that ethnic differences in crime rates are the result of the ...

    of offending by blacks, this is generally not borne out by the results of self-report studies.

  1. Marxism is a structural theory, as people's actions are shaped by society and in ...

    Marxists point towards white collar and corporate crime, which often goes undetected or is dealt with leniently. White collar crimes are crimes committed by an individual against the business e.g. fraud. This work has been studied by E.Sutherland (1940). He found that white collar crimes are substantially underestimated in official criminal statistics.

  2. Examine the pattern of, and reasons for, domestic violence in society.

    For example, Millet and Firestone argued that society has been built of the foundation of patriarchy. They regard men as the enemy, the oppressors and exploiters of women. Radical feminist argued that the widespread of domestic violence is predetermined in the partricahal society and it seeks to sustain men's dominion over all women.

  1. Using material from Item A and elsewhere assess the view that the growth of ...

    Jihadi fighters believe that they are fighting a war against the killing of Muslims by killing innocent British and American civilians. Alternatively, secularisation can cause extremism, as Steve Bruce believes the decline in religion and modernisation of society undermines traditional religious faith.

  2. Evaluate the contribution of Marxist theories to our understanding of the role and functions ...

    through performing rituals such as the tribes of the Western Pacific who performed rituals before ocean fishing to ease tension because it was dangerous and the outcomes were unknown, so this served to help them to keep them calm, because ocean fishing is different from lagoon fishing where it was much safer.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work