• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  7. 7
  8. 8
  9. 9
  10. 10
  11. 11
  12. 12
  13. 13
  14. 14
  15. 15
  16. 16
  17. 17
  18. 18
  19. 19
  20. 20
  21. 21

The issue of two interwoven entities - personal identity and ethnicity

Extracts from this document...


Word count: 3,994 INTRODUCTION This essay is devoted to the specific problem presently current in the multicultural societies - the issue of two interwoven entities - personal identity and ethnicity. In the following essay, I am going to locate the focal point of this problem in the one particular community - Highland Park High School. Highland Park is a small town in New Jersey, Middlesex County, where many emigrants from Eastern Europe, Asia, and Latin America are there. At the Highland Park High School, although not apparently seen, the question of identity and ethnic belonging is still a problem among the American youths. While staying a year at Highland Park, I have been thinking a lot about the problems characteristic for the multicultural societies. All the questions I have asked myself may be boiled down to one single question - namely, whether ethnicity and identity should be treated as interdependent variables, or rather one of them is more fundamental? ON 'IDENTITY' - ITS MALLEABILITY AND FIXITY To begin with some conceptual clarification, what is needed is to disclose possible ramifications of the problem of identity, and its transformation under contemporary conditions. Hence, I am going to devote this section on discussing the descriptive and explanatory power of 'identity' concept. Needless to say, the "identity" concept is embroiled in many controversies and especially recently encourages many debates. However, within the confines of my present essay, I will restrain my analysis to two basic dimensions usually linked to this category. As I see it there are two crucial features attributed to identity expressed by pairs of oppositions: the opposition of solidity and fluidity as regards its nature which seems to be parallel to fixity vs. changeability of identity, to its uniformity vs. its variability, etc. Identities: Collective or individual? It is important to mention that the different uses of the identity should be singled out. ...read more.


This type of the ethnic ideology could be named by the term "Salad bowl". It is important to emphasize, that this "Salad bowl" ideology stresses the separateness of the ethnic groups. This ideology put together with the melting pot ideology gave birth to another ethnic ideology often described as "Stew and Stir Fry". This is a metaphor by which one should understand that "the ethnic groups when blend together or come in contact with each other, they are better than all original ingredients alone"(Kelley). Based on the "Stew and Stir Fry" metaphor, the main goal is that each group will become richer and more resourceful, and yet each will maintain the integrity of the original group. However, what is significant here is not the exact description of each ideology itself, but an attempt to associate these ethnic ideologies with the features of one's identity i.e. its weakness and strength. I assume that teens have been equally exposed on these dominant societal ideologies, but their influence on students depends on their individual profiles of identity. Thus, the 'melting pot' ideology can be attributed to a very weak, flexible identity as far as newcomers are concerned. Those, who are characterized by such an identity, do not form strong bonds with their ethnic group they belong to. Their goal is to become a member of the society as whole and to avoid being stigmatized as 'the other'. As one of the students, a newcomer from Ukraine expresses it aptly: "We should all be able to live within the united nation, (...) the point to which we all are leading to, is the assimilation of the representatives of another cultures (...)" In the contrary, the 'salad bowl' ideology may be linked to a very strong identity as far as newcomers are concerned. The individuals, to whom such a type of identity could be attributed, often give emphasis to their difference, by closing themselves in kind of groups of the same origin, at the same time drawing the visible boundaries between them and the other ethnic groups. ...read more.


It has been shown in the questionnaires when a Hungarian student claimed: "I am glad I can still take part in Hungarian festivals organized in New Brunswick". The cultural events can be performed on a large scale as in the case of the Irish, who every year organize Saint Patrick's Day Parade, which takes place in New York City or Polish Americans who organize Pulaski's Parade to highlight their contribution to the American War for Independence and to show the might of the Polish nation. In this particular case, ethnic stratification is meaningful in a way that it either strengthens the bonds that link the individual with the ethnic group he or she belongs to or on the contrary, it weakens these bonds. In general, ethnicity-linked factors often influence the process of developing social bonds. This directly refers to the process of shaping one's identity. CONCLUSIONS The question, which entity of those two is more fundamental - 'ethnicity' or 'identity' has been a topic of many discussions among the social scientists. "Some assume that identity (...) is the most basic aspect of ethnicity (...)" (Eriksen 1995, p. 255). The others agree with Abner Cohen (1974) that ethnic organization - the pursuit of group interests - is the very raison d'�tre of ethnic identity. They also stuck up for his theory that identity would vanish if it had no organizational focus. From my case study, it is clearly seen that neither of them is more fundamental. I have managed to show in this essay that 'identity' and 'ethnicity' are interdependent entities. They mutually influence each other and they are both complementary expressions of each other. To my mind, this observation might be seen as a tentative answer to the research question formulated at the very beginning. Needless to say, the area of 'ethnicity' and 'identity' studies is very diffuse and ramified, which makes the outcome of my research only perspectival and provisional. This is also, why I had to curtail the discussion of 'ethnicity' and 'identity' to the needed minimum, while both of them clearly deserves a bulky volume themselves. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Sociological Differentiation & Stratification section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Sociological Differentiation & Stratification essays

  1. Outline and Assess Whether stratification is either inevitable or beneficial to individuals and society?

    electricians, if theirs loads of demand for electricians then they can earn a lot of money by putting their prices up, as they know people will pay them as there is a shortage for them. The new right says that governments shouldn't intervene in the market or promote equality as

  2. Critically assess the view that social stratification benefits the powerful groups in society

    This benefit was far from generous as it was calculated, for a married couple in 1989, at 54% of the state pension for an equivalent couple (Haralambos & Holborn, 1995), which effectively amounted to �84 per week (Weir, 1994). Moreover, although state pensions were increased in line with inflation it

  1. Demography topic revision notes. The study of populations and their characteristics is called ...

    For example, as Tranter observes: "As late as the 1930s, levels of obstetric knowledge and technique were so poor that they were more likely to increase rather than decease death rates in childbirth." However, after the 1950s, improved Medical Knowledge, techniques and organization did help to reduce death rates.

  2. Culture & Identity

    This creates more advanced relationships of the ideas of culture because as our understanding develops we come to understand social hierarchies , the relationships between groups and the ability to organise our environment to make it understandable. Durkheim's work makes importance of the idea that culture is of a social derivation.

  1. Is the Underachievement of Ethnic Minority Children due to a Racist School System?

    It mentioned a study commissioned by the London mayor Ken Livingstone, it found that black boys complained of racism and stereotyping from teachers, and their 'chances of success were also limited by an archaic curriculum'. Livingstone believed that some of the problem was that there wasn't enough ethnic minority teachers,


    The Equality Act 2010 also makes it unlawful for a company to discriminate against anyone on the grounds of race, sex, pregnancy and maternity, marriage or civil partnership status, gender reassignment, disability, religion or belief, age or sexual orientation. It is also possible for employees to claim for discrimination on a combination of two of these grounds.

  1. Should we assume that stratification is natural and therefore inevitable? Is class merely about ...

    Education also helps in development of universal literacy and helps student to learn the strategies to fight with racism and other social issues.

  2. Evaluate the view that class is the most important source of an individuals identity.

    more likely to have jobs of their own as it is for men to take some responsibility of the childcare and housework. Children were often brought up to have very limited aspirations. Although some working class children benefited from education many left school at the age of 15/16 to go to work.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work