• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent can it be argued that violent films cause violence in society?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

To what extent can it be argued that violent films cause violence in society? The claim that violent films, as well as violent media, cause violence in society can be both supported and contradicted with reference to sociological studies and theory. Proponents of the Hypodermic Model would argue that the media message, in this case violence, directly affects and changes the behaviour of the audience, hence resulting in violent behaviour. The Cultural Effects Model argues that a media message of violence will eventually socialize the audience to accepting it as normal- resulting, in some cases, with violent behaviour. On the other hand, the Interpretive Model argues that the violent media and films will depend on the audience, while the Structured Interpretation Model argues that a dominant media message of violence can be read in different ways, leading to different reactions. However, it is clear that violent media can have an influence on society- with the theories differing mainly on the extent and form of this effect. It can be said that violent films can cause violence in society. The Hypodermic Model, within which it is argued that the media message directly affects and changes the behaviour of the audience, can be used in support of this argument. It is also backed up by theorists; including Shannon and Weaver (1949) ...read more.

Middle

The Model argues that a constant or consistent media diet of violence will eventually socialize the audience into accepting violence as normal- and hence resulting in greater violence in society. Parke et al (1977) argued that young children not prone to violence could become more aggressive if exposed to a steady stream of violence in the media- clearly supporting the view as well as the Cultural Effects Model. Anderson and Dill, in the 'General Affective Aggression Model' that involved a survey as well as an experiment based on playing a violent video game, and then punishing 'opponents' with a noise blast, argue that violent media content can stimulate aggressive behaviour. Newson claims that a media diet of violence can result in the distortion of emotions and the de-sensitisation of younger viewers. The American Association of Paediatrics, in a study on the impact of screen violence, argued that the continuous viewing of screen violence can lead to the build-up of wrong messages stressing the effectiveness of violence. Real-life examples also justify the view that violent films and media cause violence in society- note the influence of viewing violent films in the Bulger murder, and the Columbine massacre. However, many of these studies are criticized by sociologists, mainly because most of them are psychological studies conducted within a laboratory setting, hence lacking ecological validity. ...read more.

Conclusion

The extent to which a violent media message results in violence in society is also affected by mediating factors. Merton, Katz and Lazarsfeld's 'Two-Step Flow' Model argues that a media message is interpreted by important people who guide our interpretation. In this case, it can be argued that a media message of violence within a film can be interpreted and presented to people as negative by individuals such as parents, preachers and others- hence breaking the assumption that violent films can directly cause violence in society. Structured Interpretation on the other hand argues that there still is a dominant and strong media message- in this case, of violent behaviour, and the extent to which this message is interpreted again depends on the audience. In conclusion, it can be said that violent films and violent media content can influence violence in society, as pointed out in many studies, but cannot directly cause it. The extent to which violence in society is caused by violent media content will depend mainly on the way which the audience interprets it, and the way in which the audience acts on this interpretation and message. However, it can be said that other factors, including socialization as well as personal experiences probably play a greater role in causing violence in society than violent films and violent media messages. ?? ?? ?? ?? Edwin Loo 13K 08/03/2008 Sociology Essay Page 2 of 2 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Media section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Media essays

  1. Does Media Violence Lead to Aggression and Societal Violence?

    According to the article Teen Health and the Media, "the average American teen spends about 20 hours a week watching television" (Washington State Department of Health). Indeed, we cannot deny the fact that we are exposed to many types of media violence since childhood.

  2. What are some of the key messages and ideas presented in the novella, Fahrenheit ...

    He'd say, that's grass! A pink blur! That's a rose garden! White blurs are houses. Brown blurs are cows. My uncle drove slowly on a highway once. He drove forty miles an hour and they jailed him for two days.

  1. Does violence in the media effect peoples behaviours and opinions?

    The method I have chosen is highly positivist, which aims to provide highly reliable quantitative data that can be collected again if the procedure was repeated. However there are some qualitative portions in my study, this means that my questionnaires will collect some qualitative data, this means that the research will also looks at peoples beliefs regarding media violence.

  2. What do researchers define as 'media violence'? What kind of assumptions do they make ...

    * In 1997, Nathan Brown (16) was jailed for life for the murder of 14 year-old Carl Rickard outside their school in 1996. During his trail it was alleged that he spent most of his time watching violent video games.

  1. Moral Panic and media folk devils.

    This shows the success in the media in stirring up panic as they have convinced most people that far more than 6% of the UK population are black/Asian. 4. 80% of people asked thought there is a problem with the UKs current standing on immigration.

  2. How does the media represent female bodies?

    10 14 5 9 49 Accompanied by positive comments 4 8 7 6 7 32 Images of women 77 84 116 104 118 531 Images of men 61 45 67 47 28 248 From this grid you can see that I included a total number of pages containing images of women.

  1. Media and The Sexualization of Young Girls

    have the ability to make good ideas about their sex lives as well as about all other aspect of their being. ?Empowerment? is a word that has been too much bandied about in the media, used to sell everything from deodorant to pop music. It?s starting to lose its meaning.

  2. Television and How it Affects Society

    That show is about six close friends who are always there for each other, that shows me that having close friends is very important.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work