• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Using the seminar case study material consider to what extent train crashes such as Hatfield, Paddington and Potters Bar should be seen as examples of White Collar crime.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Using the seminar case study material consider to what extent train crashes such as Hatfield, Paddington and Potters Bar should be seen as examples of White Collar crime. A white-collar crime refers to crimes committed by business people, entrepreneurs, professionals, or public officials. It was a term first coined by Edwin Sutherland who defined the term as "crime committed by a person of respectability and high social status in the course of his occupation" (Sutherland 1974) and was the first to bring attention to the matter. White-collar crimes are different then street crimes because they are through deception and not force or violence. There has been much debate as to what qualifies as a white-collar crime, the term today generally describes a variety of non-violent crimes usually committed in commercial situations for financial, organisational or personal gain. Many white-collar crimes are especially difficult to prosecute because the perpetrators are sophisticated criminals who have attempted to conceal their activities through a series of complex transactions. (Bologna 1984). For most individuals, white-collar crime is not viewed as a crime at all, because of its non-violent nature. Violent crime has an immediate and obvious impact on its victims, which raises the attention of the public, whereas white-collar crime frequently goes undetected or is viewed as a bending of the rules (Geis, 1982). ...read more.

Middle

It is much harder to perceive whose criminality resulted in the crashes. There are a numbers of players whose direct actions have a part in the incidents that have happened. If the crashes are indeed White Collar crimes then whose criminality is it? In Potters Bar, the crash was due to poor maintenance as nuts and bolts were missing. This is someone's criminality but whose? The tracks have clearly not been perfected resulting in a loss of life. Railway companies contract out to private companies such as Thames and Railtracks who carry out track inspections and maintenance. There's a lot of input from different directions, this results in a huge confusion of responsibility and accountability. Systematic problems therefore arise, it can be seen that the train companies are not responsible due to companies like Railtracks who are supposedly maintaining tracks and points are over and over again not doing very well and getting reprimanded. There is a behaviour that keeps repeating itself which shows an element of criminality on their behalf. In Ladbroke Grove, there are also a number of people who may be perceived to have a shared responsibility in the crashes. The driver went through red light, there was poor communication with the man at signal box and there is a pre history to it all in terms of the training received by the driver. ...read more.

Conclusion

As discussed, it is hard to determine who should be punished for the crashes as there has been input from a wide area. It is also clear that there are many underlying reasons behind the faults that led to the crashes. When taking a legal perspective the offences cannot be a direct action of corporate manslaughter as a senior manager director has not been held responsible for making a key decision which has directly led to the crashes under this current law. Therefore a prosecution cannot be made for this. When taking a global perspective at the situation as a whole. It is clear that train company's are under increased pressure to perform. They are also in competition with other companies in terms of speed, efficiency and profits. This may be the reason for the corners that have been cut, which have been done to satisfy the businesses needs and to please members of the general public who want fast, but cheap transportation. This brings me to the conclusion that the crashes are not immediate forms of White Collar crimes again because the intent to harm these people was not there. The crashes are based on accidents. Yes, they could have been prevented if a little more effort and guidance was put into the training of staff and the inspections carried out but I do not think that punishment in terms of prosecution is the answer to these incidents. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our AS and A Level Crime & Deviance section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related AS and A Level Crime & Deviance essays

  1. Assess the view that sociology can and should be seen as a science

    Sociologists can't be expected to predict exactly what the divorce rate will be in a couple of years. Popper believes that a theory proven correct cannot be correct all of the time; he believes that scientists do indeed spend much of their time experimentally finding that the results of their

  2. Describe the concept of a 'Moral Panic' and explain how this may impact on ...

    Jock Young's supports these theories and believes the three ways in which the media can do so, is: "By mass manipulation, by commercial 'laissez-faire', or by consensual paradigm" (cited in Jones, 2003; 86). By allowing the media to influences upon ones perception of crime they are perceived by theorists as

  1. Critically discuss the practical and ethical difficulties involved when researching White Collar Crime. Give ...

    Although Sutherland (1949) still drew upon class boundaries, his definition opened up acknowledgment to crime being carried out amongst all the classes, even if the class divides were stereotyped to certain types of crime. He argued that those upper class white collar crime offenders should be inclusive in the definition of crime.

  2. Drawing on examples from your reading, explore the medias impact on the fear of ...

    This also raised concerns about safety in prisons within the public as their fear of crime had been increased and a 5 month public inquiry was held as a result of this absurd media depiction of events of what was ultimately a peaceful process.

  1. Criminology - "Corporate and white-collar crimes are less serious than other kinds of crime, ...

    However, as White and Haines argue, white-collar and corporate crimes "affect a large number of people directly or indirectly simply because of the capacity of the capitalist to do harm on a large scale"3. One example of a crime by the capitalist that effects the whole of society is medifraud,

  2. Referring to the John Duffy "Railway Rapist" case to illustrate, discuss the strengths and ...

    Britton (1997) also admits that a large number of cases continue to be solved, not by profiling, but by routine police work, or the use of forensic evidence. However we should also be aware that police officers may be reluctant to admit that 'outsiders' have helped to solve a crime.

  1. Describe law and order in London in the late 19th century

    the police increased security in Whitechapel, and as the panic reached its height, the case went international, appearing in newspapers from Europe to the Americas and helping out with any suspects fleeing to other countries. Whitechapel to the other countries seemed like another world.

  2. How far does Becker's account (The Outsiders 1963) of the processes underlying the selective ...

    Therefore, if nobody was affected by the act, then a whistle would not have been blown and the boy would not have been labelled a deviant, so does this relate to the selective enforcement of white- collar crime and domestic violence?

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work