• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss the ideas about the responsibilities of the individual that these three examples might be used to illustrate.

Extracts from this document...


Discuss the ideas about the responsibilities of the individual that these three examples might be used to illustrate. Jean-Jacques Rousseau wrote 'The Social Contract', published in 1762 and from which the passage for this TMA is taken. He was against the monarchy's 'Divine Right' to rule and believed that the People, or sovereignty, had to be the legislative authority and obey the law because they felt they should not because they are forced to. 'When as 'subjects', we obey society's laws, we 'the people', are really only just obeying ourselves as sovereign 'citizens''1. Rousseau believed that the people, under general will, would vote for laws they believed necessary and would be incapable of breaking them because they deemed these laws morally correct. As all people are members of the state they share sovereign power by means of voting. Therefore when a law is proposed, it is the decision of the general will, i.e. the majority of the people, whether it is accepted or rejected. Because individuals do not vote for their personal advantage but for the good of the people, if their individual opinion is in the minority they accept that they would not be free because their opinion would not be the general will, which is what they want. ...read more.


Our view, is directed to the women in mourning and to the vanishing point which is just above the left shoulder of the taller of the woman in red. The colour and tonal range are both wide; the bright warm colours of the women contrasts with the dark dull colours of the men on the left. Light floods the female figures from the left but only highlights the body of one of the sons and the feet of Brutus which are taut and with clenched toes. The females seem to be sharing their grief whilst Brutus is alone in his own thoughts, separated from the rest of the room by means of turning his back on them. Whilst studying this painting, I am struck by the thought that Brutus is wondering what he has done to both his family and the state. Obviously not wanting to return to life under rule by the Monarchy, he has had no choice in committing his sons to death. Brutus makes a decision for the good of the people - the general will. ...read more.


What does the misty vista reveal to the man? I feel the painting suggests, by means of the vast horizons, that we should look into ourselves, 'and our own resources of feeling and thought in order to discover meaning'4. These three examples define the responsibilities of the individual in contrasting ways. Rousseau believed people should ignore the individual will and that by being noble and good, they would obey the general will which is their will anyway. David's painting of Brutus was 'seen as a representation of a kind of political heroism in which the best interests of society are put before those of the individual'5, whilst the individual in Freidrich's painting is thinking of himself before anything else. I suggest that people have a right to live as they wish so long as it is within the principles and laws of the society or state in which they live. No individual's rights within that society can override the rights of the society as a whole, whilst any changes to the laws must be made as a group in a consensual and democratic way. Individuals have a responsibility to respect and nurture the rights of others whilst the society in which they live also has a responsibility to protect their rights to freedom within that society. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Art section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Art essays

  1. Art is the best way of expressing religious ideas

    A key examples is angels. In all religious artwork, angels' feet do not appear: they are always covered by their clothing. Religious clothing also indicates status e.g. miters on bishops, or an alb on a priest. Height is also used: those who are standing are human, while those sitting are holy.

  2. My name is Sarah..... I am but three, My eyes are swollen I cannot ...

    It is truly sad my old friend On how you react to my relationship in the end. So I'm guessing you're the type of guy Who goes against everything in my eyes. Why is it that I'm running, running from you When I thought you were a friend, one to be true?

  1. Reason and Imagination

    How, then, can the evidence from this manipulated experiment be used as reason? In reality, scientific conclusions are made through inductive and deductive reasoning, and this makes reasoning an essential part of natural sciences. However, it does not act alone.

  2. In my opinion is Friedrich's view consistent with Rousseau's ideas from The Social ...

    The final will Rousseau formulated was the general will. '...a group taken as a whole rather than as a collection of individuals.' (Block 3, 2003, p104) Rousseau's general will is where I believe problems arise. He thought voting would be the best way to assure that individuals get their voice heard.

  1. To what extent do you find the influence of Rousseau's views on the relationship ...

    According to Rousseau, the general will is that which is best for the state as a whole and the particular will is the particular desires of an individual. (p105, Blk 3). As the particular will is a product of appetite and the general will a product of reason, we should obey the general will which makes us noble and good.

  2. TMA 05 Rousseau and Democracy

    These postures, gestures and choice of colours suggest that particular will has been sacrificed for the sake of the general will of upholding the political duty.

  1. Some writers have argued that each discipline has 'essential characteristics'. To what extent do ...

    Cubism wants to get away from the idea of coping scenes/images exactly and painting them onto a surface. 'Clarinet and a bottle of Rum' shows an analytical view of reality. There is limited use of colour so as not to take away the meaning of the painting itself.

  2. Nihilism in Turgenev's Fathers and Sons has several characters that hold strong views of ...

    When Bazarov meets Madame Odintzov we notice distress within our hero. Up to this point Bazarov has maintained his somewhat icy composure and easily passed the tests of his nihilist convictions. But now, chance deals Bazarov a new hand. By befriending Anna Odintzov, Bazarov comes up against feelings which he tries desperately to defeat.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work