• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Discuss the merits of Burgin's statement as a basis on which to distinguish postmodernism from Modernism in the practice of art.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Open University Course A316:- Modern Art: Practices & Debates, 1995 'It quickly emerged that the proper and unique area of competence of each art coincided with all that was unique to the nature of its medium. The task of self-criticism became to eliminate from the effects of each art any and every effect that might conceivably be borrowed from or by the medium of any other art. Thereby each art would be rendered 'pure', and in its 'purify' find the guarantee of its standards of quality as well as of its independence. 'Purity' meant self-definition, and the enterprise of self-criticism in the arts became one of self-definition, with a vengeance.' (Greenberg, 'Modernist Painting', Art in Theory, p.755) 'Greenberg's aesthetics are the terminal point of [an] historical trajectory. There is another history of art, however, a history of representations ... for me, and some other erstwhile conceptualists, conceptual art opened onto that other history, a history which opens onto history. Art practice was no longer to be defined as an artisanal activity, a process of crafting fine objects in a given medium, it was rather to be seen as a set of operations performed in a field of signifying practices, perhaps centred on a medium but certainly not bounded by it'. (Victor Burgin, 'The absence of presence', Art in Theory, pp. ...read more.

Middle

175) which 'plays upon the irony that language is both a medium supposedly distinct from art and the source of information about art's content and meaning' (Modernism in Dispute, p.205). Burgin provides a basis for identifying work as postmodernist rather than Modernist, and also sets postmodernism in the context of its antecedents in, for instance, Heartfield's photomontages and Duchamp's readymades. The concept of postmodernism seems to have become current from the early 1980s onwards, when it began to appear in the work of writers such as Lyotard and Jameson. These writers were not specifically discussing art but more general cultural tendencies. However, Burgin's challenge to the dominance of Greenbergian criticism can be connected with Lyotard's definition of postmodernism as 'incredulity towards metanarratives', in this case the metanarrative of technical development in painting . Early attempts to define postmodernism in the visual arts by writers such as Krauss and Owens, 'started from an assumption that the stylistic diversity of art after Modernism ... conceals from view some underlying unifying principle:' (Modernism in Dispute, p.237). However, it is arguably easier to say that a specific work, or the work of a specific artist, is postmodernist than to define what, precisely, constitutes postmodernism. The range of concepts associated with postmodernism are, as Harrison and Wood admit, complex and prone to a degree of vagueness and instability. ...read more.

Conclusion

This is in direct opposition to the passive contemplation advocated by Modernist critics such as Fried who, in Art and Objecthood, claims that good art should be 'instantaneously present'. This idea of the importance of 'presentness' is contradicted by the title of Burgin's article, 'The absence of presence'. Taking Burgin's statement as a point of departure, it is possible to connect postmodern ideas to a diverse range of works of art, which are in turn associated with a series of contemporary concepts and concerns. While Burgin provides a means of distinguishing postmodernism from Modernism in art, there remains the problem of how to, or indeed whether, one ought to distinguish qualitatively between different postmodernist works. If social relevance is a characteristic of postmodernism, then degree or accuracy of social relevance may be used as an evaluative tool; however, as Harrison and Wood have pointed out (see Modernism in Dispute, p.240) radically critical work may become marginalised and lose its ability to challenge. Furthermore, if the main impact of a work depends on its contemporary relevance, it is likely to lose conceptual value with the passage of time; Haacke's The Safety Net (pl.D24) borrows its meaning from contemporary politics rather than conforming with Greenberg's idea of art as self-defining, and is hence now arguably of historic rather than artistic interest. The aesthetic of Greenbergian Modernism may never recover a dominant position within art history but, as Harrison and Wood have suggested, 'the contingency of the historical is only half the point of art'. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Art section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Art essays

  1. The Representation of Women in Pre-Raphaelite Art

    In Millais' painting "Ophelia", she is floating down a stream, surrounded by bright flowers and signs of spring, which strongly contrast the idea of a drowning girl. The flowers "are emblematic of her fate: pansies, signifying thought and vain love; a necklace of violets, symbolizing faithful chastity and the death

  2. One Art

    the final stanza, the ultimate loss is the loss of a beloved person. The sixth stanza is now directed to "you"-probably not the reader, but to someone Bishop knew quite well and cherished. This final, and most personal example of loss is one that the poet is still struggling with as evident throughout the entire poem with her denial.

  1. Explore the extent to which Fra' Angelico's work engages with new issues in pictorial ...

    This unusual inset not only makes the definite point that Fra' Angelico has understood Massaccio's Trinity but also that he is able to manipulate the new ideas about painting with relative ease and accomplishment. The new ideas that Fra' Angelico was beginning to understand and would develop fully in the

  2. Explore the relationship between painting and photography in the work of David Hockney ...

    On the floor is a white telephone without a lead." Hockney develops his hyper-real and tight painting technique with Sprinklers in 1975. This painting is almost like a photograph when looked at from a distance, and shows a field of sprinklers with spray shooting upward in a heavily stylised and angular way.

  1. Part II: Shih as a concept applied in Chinese Art, Calligraphy,

    Parallel to Sun-tzu's concept of shih in warfare, effecting political change and exerting political power are a matter of the situation's inherent potential, and so are product of the situation rather than qualities our own-it depends not on absolute forced, but rather, on exploiting the potential of power inherent in the positional configuration of power relation.

  2. Theresa Gill Paintings

    died in 1891 and with that Rodin offered to deliver the statue for himself. Their creations relate to the traditional hierarchy of history of painting because their creations were of important people in the pass. People who were admired for their past works and people who were in history.

  1. Waltons View on Photography.

    is fictitious in content, yet the scene is real, just not what you think it is. It's not fiction that you are looking at a mock Loch Ness monster. Whereas in a painting, even if the painting was of Henry VIII, its fiction that you are looking at Henry VIII.

  2. Artist Profile - Michael Brennand-Wood

    sometimes has grave consequences, however the flowers in the piece suggest that there is always a good side to a bad one. The colours are mainly red, which signifies passion, pride but anger, jealousy and blood, many of the emotion felt through war.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work