• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

In my opinion is Friedrich's view consistent with Rousseau's ideas from The Social Contract. Question two considers what evidence there is in David's paintings to show whether he would have agreed with Friedrich's statement.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

TMA 05 Art History and Philosophy Question '[T]he feeling of another person should never be imposed upon us as a law' (Casper David Friedrich, in Block 3, p.194). In an essay of 1200 words, consider the following questions: 1 In your opinion, is this view consistent with Jean-Jacques Rousseau's ideas as expressed in The Social Contract? 2 Consider what evidence there is in Jacques-Louis David's paintings to show whether David would have agreed with Friedrich's statement. Question 1 In this essay I will answer two questions that relate to Freidrich's quote, '[T]he feeling of another person should never be imposed upon us as a law'. Question one will answer; in my opinion is Friedrich's view consistent with Rousseau's ideas from The Social Contract. Question two considers what evidence there is in David's paintings to show whether he would have agreed with Friedrich's statement. Rousseau was a French philosopher who in 1762 published his book The Social Contract. In his book he asks the question of how should a state be run? What is the correct way? Rousseau was a strong believer in freedom. However he did not believe man should live in the 'state of nature' as '...stupid, limited animal[s]' (Block 3, 2003, p109). He thought that '...as we are naturally free people, we are right to obey the state only if it does not detract from our freedom.' ...read more.

Middle

In the painting The Oath of the Horatii the arrangement of the figures is grouped into three sets. The group of soldiers on the left of the painting are the three Horatii. Each has an arm outstretched to the swords in the centre of the painting, those are held by the man in the centre. Behind him at the right of the painting is a group of three women and two children, their faces and poses display exhaustion. The most striking colours in this painting are the red shawls over the shoulders of the man in the middle and the silver of the three glistening swords he is holding. The viewer's eyes are instantly drawn to them. This is the intention as he is the most important person in the painting due to the fact that he is anointing them. Coincidentally the lines of perspective converge to the point that is at the base of his left wrist, the hand that holds the swords. I believe that from evidence taken from this painting, David would not have agreed with Friedrich's quote. This painting is set in Ancient Rome, a society that was oppressive, and did not encourage freedom of speech. This painting is highly political and displays severity due to the subject matter. It has three soldiers taking an oath upon swords, which are used to kill. ...read more.

Conclusion

The evidence in this painting suggests that David would have agreed with the statement made by Friedrich. The final painting I have chosen is David's The Death of Marat. It shows Marat, laying in the bath with his body slumped towards us. In his left hand he holds a note and in the other he holds a quill. Below his collarbone is the neat wound from a knife. This knife rests on the floor next to him for the spectator to see. The most striking colour in this painting is the white of Marat's body. The darkness of the background furthermore helps to distinguish him. The lights sweeps in from the above right, in doing so it catches the sheets in which he rests and also his face, shoulders and parts of his arms. David has depicted Marat as a hero; he casts him in rays of light and even rids him of his unsightly leprosy to make him more appealing. David who was a supporter of Marat wants the viewer to imagine a hero. So essentially this painting is intended for propaganda. I think that this propaganda painting is David's way of trying to force people to feel a certain way to by conveying an image that is inaccurate. Therefore this does not convey the message of agreeing with Friedrich's statement. In conclusion, I weighed up the evidence from The Oath of the Horatii, The Death of Socrates and The Death of Marat and I found two of them to be highly against Friedrich's statement. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Art section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Art essays

  1. Romanticism vs Classicism

    Classical architecture, however, is simple and consistent. It has stuck by sound architectural methods throughout its long history. This architecture is very straight, formal, and easy on the eye. Classical architectural design borrows much of its techniques from Roman and Greek buildings.

  2. Art is the best way of expressing religious ideas

    As one approached, one was naturally compelled to study the portrait, for the eye was drawn to it by it's integration into the gallery.

  1. The boundaries between culture and nature have collapsed and the body has become flexible

    celebration of the carnivalesque in the representation of large, laughing women having a good time on holiday, escaping everyday pressures, refusing the judgments of others. A large woman in stretched bathing suit with the number 13 emblazed, behind her is a sign 'Beauty competition' and the two male judges raise their eyebrows in horror.

  2. My name is Sarah..... I am but three, My eyes are swollen I cannot ...

    If these walls could talk they would say that it's all right, God sends His angels to look over me at night. They'd encourage me, say though I am alone it doesn't mean I'm on my own. He watches me, from above and showers me with all His love, if only these walls could talk.

  1. We are more likely to be mistaken in our generalization than in our particular ...

    about R$ 10 and of course the beverages and all, and while eating I asked why a cheeseburger here in Brazil is much more expensive than a burger in the USA given that the same ingredients are used.

  2. Waltons View on Photography.

    Some sense of reality is lost and you believe you have been tricked into an illusion. He claims it is similar when you discover a guard at the wax museum is not real. So although looking through a photo isn't meant to duplicate being somewhere and looking directly at the

  1. Theresa Gill Paintings

    Rossetti's imagined space shows great novelty. The Virgin's bedroom is shockingly simple. Rossetti places Mary in a room that is almost claustrophobically small. The use of perspective is unconvincing: Mary's bed appears about to slide out of the painting and the floor on the left of the painting blends into the wall, furthering the precipitous plane effect.

  2. TMA 05 Rousseau and Democracy

    In such a scenario, we cannot totally agree that the Horatii were comfortable with the title as champions. They might be indulged to obey the state because they ought to, or because they are afraid of the consequences. In contrast, they might be honoured to be chosen as champions of

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work