• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Is the photograph (Source 15) likely to be a more reliable source of evidence about life on the canals than the painting (source16)?

Extracts from this document...


Andrew Jefferson Coursework IS THE PHOTOGRAPH (SOURCE15) LIKELY TO BE A MORE RELIABLE SOURCE OF EVIDENCE ABOUT LIFE ON THE CANALS THAN THE PAINTING (SOURCE16)? In my opinion the photograph (source 15) is a more reliable source about life on the canals more than the painting (source 16). In this essay I will write about why I think source 15 is a more reliable source of evidence than source 16. The painting is a snap-shot (taken at the time) and therefore is a primary source. Source 16 is a secondary source of evidence. On the one hand source 15 has limited information, but on the other hand the information it contains can be used and inferred to see how reliable the source actually is. The first thing I noticed in the photograph was the people. I would expect a family to be working on a barge because families needed the money and the companies needed to save money (Companies would pay minimum wage in order to save money, and it is more than like that families would accept the rate because they needed the money) ...read more.


In the background of the photograph there is a house or factory with signs/advertisements on the side, it is likely that these signs are to do with the product producing companies in the industrial towns. I know from my own Knowledge that the canals were a major part of the industries, notice the tow path and how used it is, this shows reliability in the source, I also know that canal life was affected immensely by the industry. This was probably due to higher demands for materials and the canals were one of the best ways to deliver these materials. This would have put pressure on families like these to deliver more, leaving big effects on their lives. It is probably one of the reasons why the people look so unhappy. Again this information was inferred but it does suggest how reliable the source is. I believe this is a strong point, (as are the other points I have made), in how reliable source 15 is and I my opinion, the photograph is a reliable source of evidence. Source 16 (the painting) is different in many ways from source 15 (the photograph). ...read more.


I have also noticed that the women is feeding ducks, and I also know that bargees could not afford to do this either, because of their poor wages. The women is feeding the ducks in a tranquil setting, in her clean clothes, with flowers tied to the chimney, this shows the romantic elements to the painting. On the one hand I believe that this is not believable and the points I have made question how reliable this source is. On the other hand we do not now whether this painting could be by a bargee or someone who has lots of knowledge of canals and canal life. But I know that the painting was made to make money and therefore may not portray the truth about canal life, because not many people would want the truth about life on the canals in their house. In my opinion Source 15 is a reliable piece of evidence in showing what canal life was like, although the information is sketchy. Whereas the other source, source16 is different to source 15 due to its lack of information and truth and there for has no reliability in telling us about life on the canals. Andrew Jefferson 11W History Coursework ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Art section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Art essays

  1. Free essay

    The Life and Work of Salvador Dali

    The corpse strung over the tree is really a self-portrait of Salvador Dali, as he often includes self-portraits in his paintings. Resting on the top of the figure are two inkwells, which generally represent the signing of the treaties but Dali often uses them as a sign of sexuality.

  2. Anna Frank, and the Frank Family.

    Tal y como dice Ana el 14 de agosto de 1942 cuando le ve llegar. Sin embargo m�s tarde, el 23 de febrero de 1944 dice que es un buen tipo y el 27 de ese mismo mes le describe como alguien inseguro, tierno y fr�gil.

  1. Free essay

    History Coursework Pickering Castle

    The Stables area is located on the plan of the Castle but has no dates, and the only other information from the guidebook is that they were likely to have been rebuilt in stone in the 15th century. Although no written evidence of stables has been found, I think that

  2. With Reference to the French 'enlightenment' notions on femininity masculinity and the family, describe ...

    Ethical issues are raised as one question what good mothering is, as the real parents seem somewhat detached in comparison to the concern of the substitute parents. Despite this first impression however, Harry C. Payne argues that there are deeper more subtle symbols in the painting that give a sense

  1. We are more likely to be mistaken in our generalization than in our particular ...

    Again, you cannot say that is what the painting is about, due to the fact that you'll hardly ever know what the painter was thinking of when he did it, and you'll never know what the other people are thinking about it, that is, you will never know if other

  2. On the floor I am more at ease, I feel nearer, more a part ...

    Biographical Information: Jackson Pollock was born in Wyoming in 1912 and died on Long Island, New York in 1956. He was a leader of the New York action painters and a major contributor to Abstract Expressionism. He studied from 1929-1931 at the Art Students League in New York City and started working on government art projects in the late 1930s.

  1. The Romantic Age

    In England in 1825 he spent several months-absorbing English painting and making numerous studies of horses. As a tribute to Byron and the Greek War of Independence he painted Greece Expiring on the Ruins of Missolonghi.

  2. Frida Kahlo - life and works

    - In What Water Gave Me Frida painted her legs from the bath's viewpoint, partially blurred by the water. The big toe of the deformed right foot is cracked open which depicts the accident and her later operations. ?The arm of the seat went through me like a sword into a bull,? she explains.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work