• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Critically evaluate the view of Lord that strategic management accounting is nothing more than 'The Emperor's new clothes'

Extracts from this document...


CRITICALLY EVALUATE THE VIEW OF LORD THAT STRATEGIC MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING IS NOTHING MORE THAT 'THE EMPEROR'S NEW CLOTHES' BY SIOW WEI LOONG (03063277) ASSIGNMENT SUBMITTED TO: MR. MALCOLM WELLSTEAD THE UNIVERSITY OF HERTFORDSHIRE 12 DECEMBER 2003 Introduction Simmonds (1981, 1982) coined the phrase strategic management accounting for the accounting information that would assist strategic decision-makers. Further with Keith Ward (1992) defined strategic management accounting as 'management accounting in the context of the business strategies being planned and implemented by an organisation'. However, the term 'strategic management accounting' has been in the management accounting literature for more than a decade, but there only seems to be a paucity of examples of strategic management accounting actually being used in reality. Thus, the existence of strategic management accounting was doubtful. We might curious of what is strategic management accounting? Is it a prerequisite for survival in a global economy (another job to pad out the diminishing role of the accountants), or only the emperor's new clothes? This paper will concentrate on the discussion of whether the strategic management accounting was applicable in reality. A discussion of comparison between the theoretical and empirical study will be given in order to support the argument. ...read more.


This is conflict with the view of Simmonds, 'management accountants are the ideal people to collect and analyse external data'. Rob Dixon (1998) argued that the management accountant is only one users of the information, and each user can user the management information system at his or her discretion. The strategic management accounting was changing since Simmonds first used the term. Going through the case of Cyclemakers again, the competitor information was collected by the sales representatives, which means that the operational level involved in the process of collecting competitor information. This kind of circumstances occurred might due to the reason of changing in environmental factor. The view of collection of competitor information in strategic management accounting evolved in order to fit the environment meet. Competitive Advantages Porter (1980, 1985) sees competitive strategy as concerned with 'creating and maintaining a competitive advantage in each and every area of businesses. Others highlighting the competitive context include Ohmae (1982) and Henderson (1989); comment that business strategy is all about competitive advantage. Without competitors there would be no need for strategy, for the sole purpose of strategic management is to enable the company to gain, as effectively as possible, a sustainable edge over its competitors. ...read more.


And the author against the view of Simmonds (1981, 1982) coined the phrase strategic management accounting for the accounting information that would assist strategic decision-makers. This is because the view of Simmonds about strategic management accounting was too strict, and Simmonds' view of strategic management accounting was conceptual application but not in reality. The author's view of strategic management accounting is just act as a guard line for the company to develop strategy, but it is not necessary to follow completely the concept of strategic management accounting during implementing. The company can develop its own strategic management accounting based on its need. This is supported by Rob Dixon that strategic management accounting as a concept is acceptable but has practical limitations. Therefore, the strategic management accounting should alter its concept in order to fit in current environment. Moreover, the author' view of strategic management accounting was supported by Dimnik and Kudar (1989), strategic management accounting with accounting numbers should be used to guide decisions. Last but not least, the author would recommend that the company can adopt the strategic management accounting to guide the decision. And the company can come out with good strategy by using strategic management accounting with the cooperation of marketing managers and management accountants. (Rickwood et al, 1990). ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Accounting & Finance section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Accounting & Finance essays

  1. This paper discusses the statement 'in a politically charged rulemaking environment, conceptual frameworks has ...

    However, after reviewing the studies, the APB concluded that the recommendations contained therein were "too radically different" from existing generally accepted accounting principles for acceptance at that time (Peasnell, 1982). The study resulted in a third force for change which is included Moonitz and Sprouse-Moonitz monographs.

  2. Unit 5 Introduction to Accounting

    The effect of these is to make the income stream from preference shares more similar to that from debt than that from ordinary shares. Most importantly, fixed dividends are similar to interest payments. However, they are legally shares and are subject to the same tax treatment.

  1. Costs, Profits and Break-even Analysis.

    In other words just-in-time. This time period in some cases has been reduced to minutes or hours, and the raw materials arrive on site moments before they are needed. This can be wonderful for helping to reduce the need for working capital, but requires a very high level of organisational skill and a very close relationship with suppliers.

  2. Harmonisation of accounting standards in Europe

    The Commission should not have accepted this slow proceeding of its members and should have pressured them to implement both directives sooner. It should be clear that the aim of harmonisation of accounting standards is not pure uniformity. The term harmonisation does not suggest a rigid and narrow set of rules.

  1. The Purpose of Keeping Accurate Accounts

    and software, and the availability of user - friendly packages, the manual system has lost its comparative cost advantage. 2. Speed of processing: The computer can process many thousands of transactions at incredible speeds, and high - speed printers enable output to be produced at thousands lines per minute. 3.

  2. What does Finance involve.

    0 x 18.25p =� 0 187 x 18.25=�3412.75 274 x 18.25p =�6825.50 Fixed cost (stay the same throughout) �2363.28 �2363.28 �2363.28 Variable cost (average variable costs * number of products) 0 x �5.58 = �0 187 x �5.58 = �1043.46 374 x �5.58 = �2086.92 Total cost ( =fixed cost + variable costs)

  1. Enron Case Analysis

    Enron was seeking short term success while damaging their future. "It was Skilling's relentless push for creativity and competitiveness that fostered a growth-at-any-cost culture, drowning out voices of caution and overriding all checks and balances." [6] This describes the feelings of several of the accountants that were aware of what was happening.

  2. 'Historic cost accounting is the worst possible accounting convention, until one considers the alternatives.'

    Thus, the book value of a company, as reported in its financial statements, only coincidentally reflects the current value of assets. This quote outlines the main focus of the debate. Historical cost accounting information suffers from problems of relevance in times of rising prices.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work