• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Does economic theory suggest that monetary and fiscal policy play different roles in causing big exchange rate movements?

Extracts from this document...


EC201 Assessment Two Question: Does economic theory suggest that monetary and fiscal policy play different roles in causing big exchange rate movements? Discuss the extent to which examples of big exchange rate movements in recent history can be attributed to monetary and fiscal policy changes. In 1950s proponents of flexible exchange rates had assumed that flexible exchange rates would move relatively slowly and smoothly. But within a few years of the disintegration of the Bretton Woods arrangements, that assumption had been shown to be misplaced: there were large and sometimes rapid changes in exchange rates. Are there any suggestive theories behind the observed large fluctuations? The aim of this essay is to demonstrate the different roles that monetary and fiscal policy has played in causing big exchange rates movements and the empirical evidence in recent currency experience. The basic Mundell-Fleming model in 1960s is essentially intact as a way of understanding policy effects to exchange rates. The key assumption in this model is perfect capital mobility which indicates a horizontal BP curve. Firstly, let us discuss the fiscal policy under flexible exchange rate. If the government increases expenditures the IS curve shifts to the right in Figure 1. The domestic interest rate increases and as a result financial investors will want to hold domestic bonds. ...read more.


Thus, for aggregate demand to remain equal to output, a rise in e must be accompanied by a smaller rise in p. The GG curve in Figure 3 represents this and the AA and GG curves interest on the 45 line at the long-run equilibrium levels e and p. Figure 3 P AA GG (p = 0) e e In Figure 4, above the e = 0 schedule the price is above its long-run equilibrium, so the interest rate is above the foreign level and the exchange rate is depreciating. These movements are indicated by the horizontal arrows. To the left of the p = 0 schedule the exchange rate is below the level where aggregate demand equals output, therefore there is excess supply and the price is falling. These movements are indicated by the vertical arrows. The AA schedule then can be seen as the locus of the points at which the left-right and up-down movements combine to bring about a movement towards the full equilibrium. This is the "saddle path", which is the unique stable path along that full equilibrium can be approached in rational expectations models, and it is assumed that the economy 'jumps' on to such a path. Figure 4 AA GG (p = 0) ...read more.


Individuals face a signal extraction problem when observing a monetary shock and they must infer whether the policy change is permanent. Given imperfect information, the only way to do so is to apply a filtering rule which suggests an increased probability that a monetary policy is persistent the longer it lasts. Under this framework, the exchange rate adjusts slowly to a monetary shock as agents only slowly realize that the shock is persistent. Figure 7 Exchange rate overshooting models However, some economists argued that so little of the post-1995 appreciation was explained by the change in monetary policy by using UIP-based methodology and they believed the behaviour of sterling during that time was puzzle. There are also many alternative explanations such as that the real exchange rate was low by historical standards in early 1996; and the German unemployment increased sufficiently relative to UK unemployment which resulted a further appreciation. To sum up, both the Mundell-Fleming model and the Dornbusch model indicate that a contractive monetary policy or an expansionary fiscal policy will lead an appreciation and vice versa. However, the exchange rates only overshoot under monetary policy. The rise of dollars in 1985 was due to the mixture of monetary and fiscal policy, and the appreciation of sterling since 1996 was also due to the tight monetary policy. Therefore, these theories do explain exchange rates fluctuations with relatively strong evidence. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Economy & Economics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Economy & Economics essays

  1. What do you Consider the Key Elements of "New Classical" Macroeconomics? What are the ...

    This argument contradicts Friedman's view that worker's can be continuously fooled for long periods of time. According to Lucas, without the 'fooling' of workers, how is it possible for a business cycle to emerge? Lucas answers this, with reference to what he calls 'information barriers'.

  2. What might cause an appreciation of a floating exchange rate? Discuss whether an appreciation ...

    It is difficult for government's to offset the power of speculators because their reserves of foreign currencies are very small compared to daily turnover in the market. In 1997 and 1998 speculative attacks on currencies in Asia and seven years ago, the pound was forced out of the European exchange rate mechanism because of speculative selling of the pound.

  1. The Nature of Macroeconomics

    = ?C/Y * MPS (Marginal propensity to save) = ?S/?Y * MPC + MPS = 1 * Consumption function: C = a + bY o C = consumption o a = autonomous consumption when Y = 0 o b = MPC o Y = income * Saving function: S =

  2. The Quest for Optimal Asset Allocation Strategies in Integrating Europe.

    that caution must be made not to invest in the same sector in different countries when a geographical diversification strategy is chosen. Obviously, such a policy would limit the advantages of the diversification strategy as the same sector can be hit by a global shock that has similar effects in both countries.

  1. Supply side policy.

    The same effect can also be illustrated by an outward shift in an economy's production possibility frontier. Trade Union Reforms Some of the legal protections enjoyed by the trade unions have been taken away - including restrictions on their ability to take industrial action and enter into restrictive practices agreements with employers.

  2. Free essay

    From an economic perspective should my council do more to recycle a greater proportion ...

    This diagram shows a shift downwards (from MPC 1 to MPC 2) due to the increase in range of kerbside services. This means lower costs allow you to recycle the same/ higher amount (Q1 to Q2).

  1. Some economists argue that fiscal policy is an ineffective form of government intervention. Discuss ...

    Through the use of fiscal policy, an economy possess a powerful effect tool with which it is able to avoid large cynical swings and fluctuations throughout business cycles. Smith's laissez-faire economic basis of letting the economy run itself without intervention by the government due to fear of dwindling of the economy itself was widely preached until the Great Depression.

  2. Transaction Cost Theory

    For asset specificity, assets involved in the transaction are, by definition, not freely available for other uses. There are costs involved in applying them in any other than this particular transaction. This results in a need for continuity, so that those who have invested in the assets can derive revenues from them.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work