• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

"Is it necessary that there is a consensus among citizens if the general will is to prevail?"

Extracts from this document...


"Is it necessary that there is a consensus among citizens if the general will is to prevail?" First a broad definition of consensus which may later be modified. Defined as the "concord of different parts or organs of the body"1 the application to the members of any system seems natural. Defined secondarily as "the collective unanimous opinion of a number of persons"2 we have to consider very carefully about what extent and kinds of consensus we are talking about. A further definitional point this time from Rousseau himself. Rousseau sees an individual under the social contract as playing two roles at once. The individual as a citizen is a member of and indivisible from the sovereign. This can be seen in light of the other role of the individual which is as a member of the state, a subject. "Those who are associated in [the public body] take the name of a people, and call themselves individually citizens, in that they share in the sovereign power, and subjects that they put themselves under the laws of the state" What comprises this 'general will' on which Rousseau bases his quest for the 'Principles of political right'? The general will can be seen as distinct from a sum of coinciding private interests. ...read more.


(Levine Engaging Political Philosophy p87.) The general interest then can exists separate form the wants of any or all members of the body politic. If this is the case then the general will prevails only if it is 'discovered' by a relevantly high majority of the people in any given decision. Levine uses the analogy of a jury in court case. The jurors opinion about what they may want to happen independent of whether he/she is guilty or not, but these must be put aside and the case judged against a yardstick of truth on a matter of fact. A consensus opinion about what is in the general interest in this case may or may not be a correct one and therefore may not be the general interest - theoretically even unanimity is no absolute guarantee of a correct decision. A form of consensus is a necessary not a sufficient condition for the general will to prevail in such circumstances. Rousseau deals with this problem by "promoting a politics that forges the kind of community in which there is a strong consensus on ends, a community in which citizens do discover general interests"(Levine p87) In this community we can return to the idea of the general will as producing a consensus in itself. ...read more.


In our system of representative government it is not the people who are sovereign, but rather parliament. This makes a consensus of the people less important than a consensus of the representatives in parliament and in particular the parties. As well as parliamentary sovereignty we operate an adversarial system. Whether this would allow the kind of consensus necessary for the general will to prevail. The acceptance that the 'loosing side' is wrong is not always feature of our system of democracy. The opposition party are defeated on nearly every issue in the House of ommons. Having said this there is a strong tradition of adherence to the rule of law by both sides of any argument. Consensus is not always the symptom of a prevailing general will the example of the Hobbesian sovereign single actor does not constitute the general will. In Rousseau's society the general will would be represented by a consensus, but in a modern democracy the general will is hard to discern due to the preferential rather than the 'jury' nature of the system described above. If it was to prevail in the long run however the appearance would be one of consensus. Notes : 1. OED 2. OED ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Economy & Economics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Economy & Economics essays

  1. A Comparative Discussion of Different Approaches to Entrepreneurship.

    These are external determinations and share influences to an entrepreneur with each other. Neither one of them can successfully describe entrepreneurship in their own theory. Entrepreneurship is a dynamic process of creating incremental wealth, therefore, these three approaches should be connected with each other into a micro and macro consideration when explain the entrepreneurial phenomenon.

  2. Split Votes: A Nation Divided on the Marijuana/Drug Legalization Debate

    His stance is based on a perfectly neoclassical market, where illicit drugs can be bought, sold, and consumed like typical market goods. But what of proposals for marijuana bars where the product is sold only to adults and must be consumed on the premises? Scenarios such as this are ignored.

  1. It was suggested by Adam Smith in 1776 that individuals led by self interest, ...

    For example: The Department of Social Security are unable to turn people away once a limit has been reached, its expenditure, though it may be estimated it cannot be set. Total Managed Expenditure (TME) Total Managed Expenditure (TME) is a description of aggregate public spending derived from national accounts.

  2. Scarcity and Unlimited Wants.

    Marginal Cost Marginal cost, MC is the cost of producing one extra unit and is calculated by dividing the change, , in total costs by the change in output. Revenue * Total revenue, TR, is the money the firm gets back from selling goods and is found by multiplying the number sold, Q, by the selling price, P.

  1. The Quest for Optimal Asset Allocation Strategies in Integrating Europe.

    Therefore, the authors themselves put a critical note to this inference, mentioning that the increased integration among European stock markets might also be attributable to faster information transmission and processing due to technological advances, recent consolidation and merger of stock exchanges in Europe etc.

  2. The un-utopian issue

    to re-allocate the unemployed workers this policy could work and reduce scarcity. d) Sometimes planned economies resort to rationing, especially if the country is at war. The most commonly used system is the rationing coupons. By doing this, the government can easily estimate the amount needed and the amount that each person gets.

  1. Liberalization: where it has lead us and where it is headed

    I still believe that is the case, but I see now much more clearly than I did then some of the problems that exist. First, I have learned that many good products cannot be marketed profitably in India because the number of people who can afford them is too small.

  2. "ASI" LTD case study.

    started to develop in 2001. This activity includes organisation of architectural saloons and exhibitions, seminars and discussions on hot issues in the construction industry. "ASI" Ltd. provides also assistance to newcomers in the industry to established trade companies and representative offices that plan to launch a new product or construction technology.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work