• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Is Scientific Management Good Management?

Extracts from this document...


Is Scientific Management Good Management? In order to understand and explore the concepts and practicalities of Taylorism and Scientific Management, it is first necessary to understand the man himself, as when we understand his character it becomes easier to comprehend the reasoning behind his development of the theories. Frederick Winslow Taylor was born into an upper class liberal family on March 20th 1865. Taylor's Quaker upbringing instilled in him an ability to manage and resolve conflict, and great self-control. The nature of Taylor during his youth can be directly related to his later accomplishments as his actions, constantly measuring and counting, were symptomatic of an obsessive compulsive. In 1890, at age 25, Taylor earned an engineering degree whilst holding a full time job, despite this he chose to work at the Philadelphia based 'Enterprise Hydraulic Works'. Following this he moved to the 'Midvale Steel Company' where he progressed rapidly from common labourer to chief draftsmen. It is here that he devised many of his theories on scientific management, though unlike the work of Weber and Fayol, he looked into an organisation from the viewpoint of the workers rather than that of the management. As Taylor had once worked at the level of the common labourer he knew better than most the best ways to increase efficiency, to the benefit of both the worker and the owner. ...read more.


At Schmidt's place of work, The Bethlehem Iron Company (later the Bethlehem Steel Company), production was quadrupled using the Taylorist methods making Bethlehem "the world's most modern factory and potentially a prototype for manufacturers and engineers in other industries5". While the benefits of Taylor's scientific management methods are evident there remains criticism of his work as having a 'dehumanising' effect on the worker. While Taylor sought to simplify the worker/management relationship by offering enhanced pay schemes he neglected to consider other personal needs, made famous at a later date by the work of Maslow. Taylor's ignorance of the importance of social relationships was grounded in his view of interaction between workers as a mere inefficiency rather than an important factor in morale and increased productivity. Task allocation was another major factor of scientific management which came under heavy criticism. Taylor advocated "specifying not only what work is to be done but how it is to be done and the exact time allowed for doing it6" which left very little scope for the worker to show initiative. Coupled with this, despite the greater pay, workers were often hostile to scientific management as it was tedious and demanding while the greater productivity of the individual led to redundancy. ...read more.


The work of the Gilbreths was also an example of refining the Taylorist approach, focus being made on the efficiency of the workplace in general rather than the individuals and their work. Gilbreth also recognised the link between employee morale and productivity, later printing his findings in 'fatigue study', a book he co-wrote with his wife. Taylorism today could be perceived as archaic in its methodology, and indeed in its ideology. But in a progressive industry it sought to introduce a form of regulation to its employees, something evident in many services and industries today, with IBM's 'witness' monitoring program just one example of this. The massive increase in productivity was eventually overshadowed by the lack of thought to the effects of morale on yield, and the inclination towards a Humanist approach to management is due to the lessons learnt from the failure of Taylorism. Like any concept, Taylorism was flawed, but through the resultant lessons learnt it may be reasonably asserted that though scientific management is not solely viable as a management principle, its influence on models popular today cannot be underestimated or undervalued. 1 Scientific management Pg 13 2 Scientific management Pg 131 3 Wredge and Greenwood Pg 271 4 Scientific management Pg 25 5 Nelson (1980) 6 Scientific management Pg 39 7 Weisbord (1987) 8 Scientific management Pg 133-134 9 Maslow (1943) ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE People in Business section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE People in Business essays

  1. Report: Type of ownership of J-Sainsbury

    If the store is dirty and not safe, this will create a bad reputation for J-Sainsbury, which will mean less profit because of less people shopping in J-Sainsbury's. Also the administration department, have to make sure there is tight security in the store, so the store is safe for customer to shop in.

  2. What is the purpose of management theory? Explain how knowledge to understanding of management ...

    The intent of these studies was to determine the effect of working conditions on productivity. The illumination experiments tried to determine whether better lighting would lead to increased productivity. Both the control group and the experimental group of female employees produced more whether the lights were turned up or down.

  1. Performance Management/ Motivational Theory Performance Management

    This is known as piece rates, which Taylor himself designed, to encourage employees to produce more items. Employees who did not complete their work would be paid less. Employee who did more than fair day's work would be paid more (e.g.


    to production methods and administrative procedures * The role of training programmes in raising productivity through the development of new skills and techniques * The use of incentive schemes to encourage higher productivity such as bonus payments for higher output targets, sales commission and profit-sharing schemes allowing employees to gain some of the benefits of higher productivity.

  1. Introduction to management

    In the technological approach, knowledge is treated as more explicit, and therefore it is usually codified, in the belief that this guarantees efficiency. However this is rarely the case. Other approaches rely heavily on human knowledge but they are also unlikely to be successful if they are not integrated with approaches linked to modern technology.

  2. Free essay

    Principles of Scientific Management

    This technique is called time/motion study and was developed by both Taylor and Gilbreth (Wren, 1998). Through this scientific research, the 'First Class Man' standard was established, to which all other workers were expected to meet on a daily basis (Allen, et al.

  1. Recruitment and Selection - Next

    The benefits of internal recruitment are that the organisation will attract much better candidates if they are seen to have a future career in the organisation. The organisation will not have to rely upon external references when they are choosing from internal applicants, also many of the candidates will be

  2. First Defintion of knowledge management

    and use knowledge together for the benefit of the organisation, the people who work in it, and the organisation's customers ----------------------------------- The knowledge management lifecycle Some organisations measure the progress of their knowledge management activities in terms of their maturity - how far 'down the line' they are in implementing knowledge management practices and ways of working.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work