Operational Motivation Plan: The Soft Firm.

Authors Avatar

Operational Motivation Plan      

Operational Motivation Plan: The Soft Firm

David P. Nicolette

ORG 502 Organizational Behavior

Nancy Riveiro Messer

July 8, 2001


Abstract

The operational motivation plan for the hypothetical company, The Soft Firm, is described.  Rather than attempting to overlay a theoretical motivation plan on top of a traditional organizational structure, The Soft Firm seeks to create an organizational structure and culture that is specifically designed to facilitate the motivational factors relevant to the types of employees needed to support the company’s business objectives. For that reason, the motivational plan cannot be discussed in isolation from the company’s structure and operation. This paper focuses on motivational issues and avoids going into detail about other aspects of the organization’s structure and culture, except to illustrate their relevance to employee motivation.


Operational Motivation Plan: The Soft Firm

The Soft Firm has a clear business focus: To provide information technology consulting services to clients in a broad range of industry sectors. Our business philosophy is that the most effective way to satisfy customers is to motivate the workers who are best able to provide for those customers’ needs. Since the core business activity is information technology consulting services, the most important employees are those who provide such services directly. The relative importance of other roles in the company is inversely proportional to their distance from the core business activity.

Therefore, we did not establish a conventional organizational structure and then attempt to overlay a separate motivation plan on top. Instead, we seek continuously to create an organizational structure and culture based on the fundamental philosophy that the needs and preferences of the core employees must be satisfied. The motivation “plan,” as such, is interwoven with all aspects of the company’s operation.

Company Background

The Soft Firm came in to existence as the result of a merger between Andrews Brothers Consulting (ABC) and Visionary Concepts Unlimited (VCU). ABC was the larger of the two, and acquired VCU outright. While both firms were information technology consultancies, ABC were specialists in IBM’s Transaction Processing Facility (TPF) serving the travel industry, while VCU were specialists in eBusiness, eCommerce, and the integration of Internet technologies with corporate information systems.

ABC purchased VCU for their expertise in leading-edge technologies, their business contacts, and their entrepreneurial mindset. Within two years, however, the VCU employees had assumed de facto leadership of The Soft Firm. They opened business in new industry sectors, expanded the operation of the company’s software factory to include emerging technologies, and built a successful technical training business on the foundation of the company’s original in-house training facility. When a downturn in the travel sector resulted in the loss of all but two of ABC’s TPF customers and led to the layoff of over 200 of ABC’s staff, the VCU executives bought out the ownership of the company and formally took control.

Fundamental Assumptions

To design an organization that encourages productivity and long-term employment on the part of information technology specialists requires an understanding of the general characteristics of people who tend to choose that profession and the motivational factors to which they respond.

Work-Related Motivating Factors

In general, professional personnel respond best to the following motivational factors:

  • Intrinsic interest of the work itself
  • Opportunity for professional development
  • Work that is meaningful and worthwhile
  • Opportunity to meet challenges and solve problems
  • Recognition by peers
  • Equitable, skills-based compensation
  • Flexibility to define methods for achievement of goals

In terms of ERG Theory (existence, relatedness, and growth needs), IT professionals tend to score highest in growth needs and second highest in relatedness needs (Robbins, 2001, p. 161). In the context of their work, “growth” means to learn new things, to meet new challenges, and to expand one’s technical knowledge and capabilities; “relatedness” means one’s relationship to the professional community of one’s peers, especially recognition and praise from peers whose technical knowledge is respected.

In terms of McClelland’s Theory of Needs (Robbins, 2001, p. 162), IT professionals tend to have a strong need for achievement, a moderate need for affiliation, and a weak need for power. It has been shown that people can be trained to stimulate their need for achievement and to approach their work in ways that maximize achievement (Holly, 1991, p. 128). This can be accomplished through a combination of Goal-Setting Theory, Reinforcement Theory, and Expectancy Theory. Since IT professionals tend to have strong achievement needs from the outset, by establishing an organizational structure and culture that encourages high achievement and by providing ongoing training and support, employees can be motivated to maximize productivity while enhancing job satisfaction.

The Soft Firm’s motivation plan includes elements based on the application of Cognitive Evaluation Theory (Robbins, 2001, pp. 164-165) to create and maintain a working environment that encourages self-assessment of competence. According to a model proposed by Guay, Boggiano, & Vallerand (2001), autonomy supportive techniques can help create an environment that encourages positive changes in perceived competence which in turn lead to an increase in intrinsic motivation. This approach is intuitively consistent with IT professionals’ preference to set their own goals and to determine the manner and method of achieving those goals, and their desire to continue professional development throughout their careers. The Soft Firm hopes to gain productivity, long-term commitment, and employee satisfaction as results of developing high intrinsic motivation.

Another work-related motivating factor is the nature of the work environment. Contemporary work environments in information-related fields differ from traditional work environments in several key ways. Of particular interest are the growing popularity of virtual work environments, the use of virtual monitoring and coaching, the dynamic and flexible nature of the workforce, increasing worker diversity, and the aging of the workforce (Gibbon, 2001b, July 8), especially at the high end of the skills scale.

Generational Motivating Factors

The IT professionals available for hire today comprise two major cohorts. One is the so-called Generation X cohort, born between 1961 and 1981, slightly overlapping the Baby Boom generation. The other is an underutilized resource (Matloff, 2001) of tremendous potential (Gibbon, 2001c, July 8): Experienced professionals aged 45 and above.

On the whole, Gen-Xers tend to value flexibility, a balanced life, long-term relationships, and job satisfaction. Employees of this cohort combine those values with the general traits common to IT professionals (Gibbon, 2001a, July 8). The Soft Firm’s motivation plan must take into account the values of this workforce to be successful.

The stereotypical Boomer values hard work, financial success, and achievement, and is strongly focused on career, sometimes to the detriment of personal relationships and personal interests. However, IT professionals of this cohort tend to vary from the stereotype in significant ways. Their strong work ethic is motivated more by a desire to excel than by a drive for position or wealth. They bring a broad base of life experience to the table, along with deep and sophisticated technical know-how. In many respects, their terminal values coincide with those of Generation X.

Therefore, one of the fundamental assumptions on which the motivation plan is based is the belief that the same motivating factors will apply to both Generation X and Baby Boom employees.

In some ways, Baby Boom employees may be easier to motivate than Gen-Xers. Their experience and maturity tends to set their expectations of work differently. The difficulty they face in finding employment (Matloff, 2001) may act as a self-motivator for long-term commitment.

Stereotypes about older IT professionals tend to operate in our favor for recruiting purposes. Our business model demands personnel who are both highly competent and highly creative. A prevalent stereotype about IT workers over 45 is that they are set in their ways and uncreative. The reality is that creativity is an inherent trait. It is not something that fades with age. If anything, a mature person with long and varied experience of life enhances his/her native creativity through that experience. Any older worker who has consistently updated his/her skills in leading-edge technologies probably possesses many positive characteristics of interest to The Soft Firm, including intelligence, proactiveness, enthusiasm, professional commitment, and creativity. Because conventional wisdom fails to recognize these facts, The Soft Firm is presented with a rich pool of desirable candidates.

Join now!

Cultural Motivating Factors

The Soft Firm has operations in the US and Europe. The subsidiary that handles Web design work for consultancy projects is located in Italy, and the TPF group that supports the two remaining ABC customers is located in Ireland. (Neither of these business units is shown on the organization chart in Figure 1.) The rest of the company operates in a virtual office environment, with employees located in a wide range of locales. These are primarily located in North America and western Europe.

Therefore, western European values and priorities form a part of the corporate culture. ...

This is a preview of the whole essay