• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Taylorism Is An Outmoded And Outdated Form Of Technical Control

Extracts from this document...


Taylorism Is An Outmoded And Outdated Form Of Technical Control Perfected by Henry Ford, Taylorism was developed in the early 20th Century and was a revolutionary outlook on scientific management. Its aim was to make the workplace a science, taking all control away from the worker and placing total power in the hands of management. By observing workers behaviour and how long it was taking for tasks to be completed he believed he could say how much an average worker could produce under optimum conditions. Using this he devised a means of detailing a division of labour in time-and-motion studies and a wage system based on performance. At the time and throughout the last century Taylorism was and has been "the only" way to manage, but is it now outdated and irrelevant. I hope to be able to provide some of the arguments for and against this viewpoint and give examples of Taylorism. First, what exactly is Taylorism? Simply Taylorism is the breaking down of the production process into simple, menial tasks to the extent that even the most unskilled worker can be efficient. He researched these methods knowing that management lacked the knowledge to maximise production and that workers were not efficient. Taylor spoke about rewarding good men i.e. ...read more.


Taylorism is scientific management but how scientific is it? In Websters' book there is a case where a businessman complained about how slow his secretary worked and asked, "How many times a minute should she be able to open and close a file drawer?" The workers handbook's answer would be "Exactly 25 times." Times for other open and close operations would be .04 minutes for opening and closing a folder, and .026 minutes for opening a standard centre desk drawer (Webster, J 1990). Another example of the scientific nature of Taylorism can be seen in UPS, the parcel company. Management have said that workers should walk at 3ft per second, packages should be carried under the left arm and that drivers should step into the van with their right foot first whilst holding the keys in the middle finger of the right hand. These are two classic and blatant time-and-motion pigeonholing that leads to the de-humanizing of the worker. This pigeonholing can be classically seen in some of today's big business, especially in fast-food chains. McDonalds, the most classically discussed example, where there is absolutely no autonomy for the worker; they have no option about what to do. Machines are set to cook quarter-pounders in 107 seconds and fries in 150 seconds. ...read more.


The salesperson must have the freedom to react to the customers situation and what they say. There would be no way of, for example, telling sales staff that this type of person must have this product or that the sale must be complete in x minutes. It would be impossible to implement as, unlike McDonalds, every customer is different with different needs and without talking these needs cannot be ascertained to result in the sale of a product. Even shops are individual, while common theme run from shop to shop, where products are placed and how they are displayed is up to the mangers discretion and not controlled by main management. So to conclude; Taylorism is a very restrictive practise which leads to the de-humanising of the worker and complete management control. However it is an extremely efficient and productive system. I would say that in certain business environments, like McDonalds, it is the only way to manage that would produce effective results. However nowadays individuals require job satisfaction out of their roles and to that end Taylorism is outdated as it allows no sort of autonomy and thus make working very dull. To that end I cannot conclude either way; Taylorism is very effective in the food sector where customers are indistinguishable from each other but would be highly ineffective once individuals needs must be catered for. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE People in Business section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE People in Business essays

  1. Marked by a teacher

    McDonald's. What are the Management functions at McDonald's?

    5 star(s)

    Communications- sending and receiving messages, email, fax, dealing with other customers, colleagues and other visitors. Obtaining resources- providing stationary stock and other basic office items. At McDonalds there are 3 main activities of the administrations department are: 1. Clerical work, which includes mail handling, record keeping, document production, organising meetings, dealing with enquiries etc.

  2. Management & Enterprise - Introduction to McDonalds

    A manager will need to negotiate with subordinates, superiors, colleagues, trade unions, government official and outside agencies. Planning This is the means by which a forecast is acted upon. A plan is a detailed scheme, method or procedure for achieving an organisation's goals.

  1. Report: Type of ownership of J-Sainsbury

    The aim is to produce goods and services free of faults. If everyone involved in producing a product or service is doing their job properly then faults should not occur. 15j. J-Sainsbury's Quality Assurance Every Sainsbury's product undergoes a rigorous safety check by J-Sainsbury's team of product safety experts before it is approved for sale.

  2. Assess the view that bureaucracy is the most efficient form of organization.

    Conversely excessive paperwork can become cumbersome and inefficient as it slows down processes that could otherwise be performed immediately. Another vital part of a bureaucracy is the rules and procedures that all employees should be familiar with. Managers must create a distinct system of rules and standard operating procedures (SOPs)

  1. Classify the business according to its ownership - McDonalds

    Benefits for franchisor: * Low capital expenditure --- franchising is an excellent method of expanding your business with a limited amount of ready capital. Franchisor takes a share of profit without taking risk. Low risk route to expansion. * Personal commitment and motivation from franchisees is greater than from employees,

  2. The Different Management Theory's used Within Bodyshop and McDonalds.

    Taylor's scientific management has had some critics who have said that his theory, in some cases, contradicts itself and that it has been found to have fairly limited applications. To day Taylor's theory is still widely used in fast food restaurants and car factories to name a few.

  1. How Business Works - McDonalds.

    The Human Resource department supports the business by training and motivating staff, and if the business did not have the department then the business would have untrained and de-motivated staff! The Human Resources department is related to some of the aims and objectives this includes: * Sell high quality fast

  2. Quality Assurance and Quality Control.

    the added value raw materials have been covered all the cost of all the activities to producing and getting the diary milk to the customers. This shows that raw materials have gained CS a profit and that the added value of the raw material has been helped by the production

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work