• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

The Implications for Economy, State and Identity.

Extracts from this document...


Term 3 Article Review. Done by: Eugenia Toh (6) S410 Article E- Singapore: Place or Nation? The Implications for Economy, State and Identity. By Linda Lim. Throughout the article 'Singapore: Place or Nation?', there is a constant debate between forging a strong national identity versus flourishing economically or materialistically in physical aspects (i.e. architecture and infrastructure, research and development), which are brought about by globalization. Linda Lim argues that Singapore is often seen as a place much reliant on it's rich biodiversity and it's flourishing economy rather than a single, more unified nation where lifestyles are based on unique values and culture, hence leading to Singapore's lack of national identity. She blames economic priorities for apparently having an inclination to foreign capital and talent, claiming that the "Chinese-educated entrepreneurs who posed a potential political threat to the new government- were instead "crowded out" by these favoured foreign and state enteprises. From her perspective, the authoritatrian policies of repressing the growth of civil society for endangering apathetic and passive Singaporeans with little affiliation for their country beyond it's economic and materialistic value. She is adamant over the absence of a strong interest in Singapore's affairs and also mentions that foreigners and even locals consider Singapore a "stepping stone" to success in the West, indicating that is is not at all a nation at all but merely a place. In turn, it is evident that she believes national identity must have an aberrant and not just an economically rational component, arising from emotion ties rather than pragmatic self-interest. In summary, the gist of the article revolves around the notion of identity, due mainly to Singapore's pressing need to excel in economical aspects and at the same time, focus on cultivating a strong national identity and sense of patriotism within citizens. So she insists that Singapore is no more than a place. What Linda Lim fails to realize here is that a nation's identity and its economic prosperity are not mutually exclusive and achieving both of these successes is realistic. ...read more.


In Singapore's case, what distinguishes us from other countries is our own national identity. With the need for integration during globalization, it is inevitable that each and every nation or country has to prioritize it's needs, sometimes even having to sacrifice or pay lesser attention to the ones not deemed as top prerogative. This give and take is necessary so as to ascertain each nation's level of commitment towards contributing to the worlds economy. Firstly, her argument itself is flawed as seen from the above definition of the word "place". Professor Lim insinuates that because we are a "nation of immigrants", we lack identity and all physical embodiments of it have been "erased or reconstructed". A very plausible reason for this assumption might have been due to the fact that Singapore has a good geographical location that attracts foreign businessmen. They base themselves in Singapore for practical economical purposes without the intention of settling down here whatsoever. Hence, this would just be considered capitalism movement and does not have any associated with our national identity because they are foreigners and Singapore is not their motherland. The examples she speaks about are based on her own limited experiences and are centrically put across, this only lessens her reliability and makes her seem rather biased against Singapore and it's doings. Adversely, majority of the citizens of "Singapore-the place", as she affectionately speaks of her homeland, are able to identify with it because of the homespun accustomedness the island brings about. They do not think of the nation as merely a "stepping stone" or as a "hotel", instead they think of it as their home. Singaporeans have not been passively using the country just for its material purposes; active citizenship is now more rampant in society. For example, during the recent issue of the introduction to casinos for the newly planned Integrated Resorts (IR) development, many assiduous Singaporeans came forward to voice out their concerns. ...read more.


An excellent illustration of this is China. Before China was transformed into a first world country, its economy was isolated from the rest of the world leading it to have a large rural base instead of a vibrant, fast-moving and profit making one. However, after opening up it's market globally China has quickly emerged as a "rising dragon" and is taking over renowned well-developed countries economically. Singapore's receptiveness towards globalization, and its corresponding foreign cultural and economic infusion, has a meandering effect on the national ethos through the propagation of cosmopolitanism, resulting in openness. With a foreigner-local ratio of 1:4 and university enrolment of foreign students at 20% of yearly intake4, Singapore has demonstrated its adaptability and flexbility, thus explaining its ranking as the best place to live in Asia5. With prestigious evidence like this, it perturbs me that Linda Lim still continually insists that citizens do not identify with the nation and want to emigrate. Linda Lim also subtly prods at questions pertaining to Singapore's policy making challenges. Although we are receptive to globalization, we practice it selectively. Meaning that the government makes a conscious effort to encourage or discourage certain forms of it. The fact that our government bothers to put in place censorship bans to protect our typically Asian conservative society from receiving the ill of globalization exemplifies that we do not want to be culturally homogenous but instead we want to retain certain notions of tradition and conservatism. Despite the fact that the state garners international criticism, the realities of sustaining a multi-racial and multi-religious society remains, thus the practice of selective globalization expresses the need to "think internationally but act locally". I believe that national identity an ongoing process and not rigidly fixed on certain physically identifiable and exclusive manifestations. Lim's hasty fallacies and lack of empathy has not done any justice to both Singaporeans and non-Singaporeans alike, who have cooperated in making this city an improved place to live in. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Economy & Economics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Economy & Economics essays

  1. How did rubber and tin in the Malay States affect the Singapore economy in ...

    Hence, the total number of workers in fell from 170,000 in 1910 to 104,000 in 1920. The tin industry also affected the development of the Singapore economy in its circulating capital because at least four-fifths of the production costs was needed to maintain the mining labour force.

  2. Chinese economy sets for soft landing in 2005.

    Additionally, SOEs are enhancing their scientific and technological capabilities. Li noted that SOEs have often suffered because they had "too many mothers-in-law" telling them what to do. "If you leave them alone, then they will do better." For SOEs to become internationally competitive, they must make key strategic adjustments, said

  1. Discuss the extent to which the economic theories in the Market's Reader can be ...

    The 1970's period saw the company's internationalization by establishing manufacturing plants outside Japan in Taiwan, United States and Europe. This reflected Morita's philosophy of global localization, by familiarizing himself with the local economies. . By 1980 Sony faced an appreciating yen and intense price and quality competition, especially from developing Far Eastern countries, which affected its export figures.

  2. Is the Welfare State Desirable?

    They told him that he was not as great as Macbeth; however, his children will be greater than him. When the witches say "Lesser than Macbeth, and greater", Macbeth will have heard that Banquo's children will be greater than him, making him anxious.

  1. Split Votes: A Nation Divided on the Marijuana/Drug Legalization Debate

    For example, "in 1969, $65 million was spent by the Nixon administration on the drug war; in 1982 the Reagan administration spent $1.65 billion; and in 2000 the Clinton administration spent more than $17.9 billion" (DRUG WAR FACTS, Econ). This method of argumentation is the strongest for economists.

  2. Discuss the role Singapore can play in helping her ASEAN neighbours develop their economies, ...

    This hence is a viable avenue of foreign exchange earner for these ASEAN neighbours, backed up by the stability of and the confidence in the SGD. The push for entrepreneurship by the Singapore government, backed by financial incentives, hence seen the growth in outsourcing to ASEAN neighbours.

  1. coming up with investments from three geographical regions

    Thus on occasions it gets out of stocks before any gain is realised. The other thing of note about this fund is that is does not hesitate to be the only mutual fund to own a new stock. If it isn't already apparent from its performance, the fund is also more partial to mid-caps that other diversified equity funds.

  2. Scarcity and Unlimited Wants.

    * The food supply rises arithmetically, ie 1,2,3,4,5. Only way, famine and plague would prevent absolute poverty. Malthus did not take into account the spread of birth-control techniques which reduced the rate of population growth. Malthus also overlooked the effects of future farming inventions, and the development of foreign trade which dramatically increased the food supply.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work