• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

To what extent are the recent tax changes announced by the Singapore Government justified?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

To what extent are the recent tax changes announced by the Singapore Government justified? The recent tax changes mentioned in the title refer to the Singapore government increasing Goods and Service Tax (GST) by 1%, from 3% to 4%, starting from January 1st 2003, as well as reducing personal and corporate income taxes. The effects of these changes vary depending on which view we take when looking at these changes. There are three main perspectives to consider when looking at this. They include that of the Keynesian economists, the Monetarists, and the Supply-side view. Each of them deal with the aggregate demand and aggregate supply in the Singaporean economy, and how they are structured, as each of these groups have different views regarding the aggregate demand and aggregate supply models of the economy, both in the short and long run. GST is an ad-valorem tax, meaning that it is a percentage of the good or service purchased. The effect of this can be shown in the diagram below: The change in tax will have an impact on aggregate demand and supply, as they affect prices, which has a major say in deciding the level of both aggregate demand and supply. The other changes announced by the Singapore government regarding taxes are the decreases in both personal and corporate income taxes, (PIT and CIT) to a new low of 20% (eventually), from 26% and 24% respectively. "The aim in proposing these changes is to attract more businesses to Singapore and generate higher growth, more jobs and better incomes for all Singaporeans". ...read more.

Middle

An example of what the multiplier can achieve is shown in the diagram below: So the reason why the Keynesians prefer to see government expenditure rather than changes to taxes and restructuring schemes is because of the fact that they believe the aggregate supple curve is very elastic, which would negate the effects of tax changes, and would allow for government intervention to work much more effectively. Another reason why Keynesians do not prefer tax changes is because of the stickiness of wages and prices. With the tax changes, wages and prices would have to vary immediately for the effect to take place. However, it is believed that wages and prices do not often change at the same time as other changes such as tax increases, rather they remain the same for a period of time, and only of they believe that the change is likely to be long standing, do prices and wages become altered to reflect other changes within the economy. However, is has been argued that the trickle down effect loses its effectiveness when coupled with government intervention, as the trickle down effect needs to work independently and government spending might interfere with the trickle down effect and stop it working as it should do. With the Keynesian view in mind, the tax changes proposed by the Singapore Government might not be fully justified as they may not benefit as many people as they would harm, although, to an extent, they could be seen as an improvement over the previous situation. ...read more.

Conclusion

Prices may still rise in the economy due to the GST hike but with a larger disposable income for most households, they may still end up spending more on goods and services so as to create economic growth in the Singaporean economy. So it can be seen that the Singapore Government has made certain tax changes with careful consideration and has kept the individuals at mind when introducing these changes. Only after it became apparent that the government would be facing too great a revenue loss from the decrease in income taxes did they decide to increase GST from 3 to 5% (still one of the lowest rates in the world), and then revised that to just 1% this year with a further 1% next year. It has to be justified, considering that Singapore must boost its flailing economic fortunes in the face of newly found competition from the much bigger market of China, and has done so by reducing corporate and personal income tax as incentive for businesses to set up in Singapore to boost their economic growth through the multiplier effect and the trickle down effect. There will be a few negative effects of the changes in the short term, such as some people not being aware of and therefore not being able to take advantage of the ERS scheme, but in the long term, the tax changes are vital to Singapore maintaining its status as business hub in Asia and across the world. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Economy & Economics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Economy & Economics essays

  1. Economics - Classical School of Thought, Keynesian School of Thought, Supply Side School of ...

    This would happen by individuals & firms pursuing their self interest yet despite that apparent selfishness. T the invisible hand of free market stwill ensure the best out come for all concerned. Adam Smith is considerconsidered the founding ation father of modern economics.

  2. Retailing In India - A Government Policy Perspective

    The inadequate levels of urban infrastructure can be attributed to bankrupt local governments. The majority of municipal agencies in the country have limited funds to invest in infrastructure. Collections from property taxes and user charges, that are typically used to finance infrastructure, are low.

  1. Recession, Tax Cuts and Budget Deficits.

    Footnote here Overall, the decade of the 90's was a period of low inflation, low unemployment, and record budget surpluses. Did Clinton have anything to do with the shift to surplus? Clinton was President during a time of rapid business cycle expansion.

  2. how the changes of the working environment affect employee relations

    One of the biggest affect that inflation rate has on the working environment is that because the price of everything is rising, the same will happen to the employees pay because it should rise according to the inflation rate. Recession Recession is basically when the income and the output of

  1. Discuss the socio-economic impacts of globalization on Singapore.

    Thus, the Singapore government have boost efforts to develop a strong and resilient external wing to overcome our resource constraints, and to take advantage of the opportunities in the region and further afield. This has thus resulted in industrial development.

  2. Discuss the role Singapore can play in helping her ASEAN neighbours develop their economies, ...

    Development of the Brunei economy through Singapore's demand for oil is highly likely to increase, with it being a viable substitute in the light of growing problems with the oil-exporters of the Middle East. The importing of other natural resources comes in the form of water.

  1. Scarcity and Unlimited Wants.

    He does not have to sell personal belongings. Establishing a Limited Company Limited companies have their own legal identity. They can sue people and other companies and be sued themselves. Anyone wanting to establish a limited company must issue: * A memorandum of association stating the name, aims and address

  2. To what extent is income tax in the UK progressive? Discuss the likely effect ...

    Firstly, we can assess the demand-side effects of the tax cut. The fall in income tax, increases disposable income of the population, as less of the income is taken by the government in tax, leaving more money for workers to spend.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work