• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Was it a credible commitment by De Beers to threaten to punish any defectors from the diamond cartel?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Was it a credible commitment by De Beers to threaten to punish any defectors from the diamond cartel? Cartel agreements are "an institutional form of collusion"1. They present an alternative to traditional models of oligopolistic interaction, such as Betrand or Cournot models, that assume that firms act solely in order to maximise their total profits. In cartels, firms cooperate in order to maximise their joint profits, eventually leading to higher profits from each individual firm involved. More specifically, firms agree to produce smaller quantities, in order to drive up the market price. Although this sounds ideal in principle, in practice there exists the incentive for firms to deviate from such agreements and produce more than their predetermined quota in order to reap the benefits of a high price on a larger scale. This will place downwards pressure on the artificially high price. Ideally, firms must be able to retaliate in the case of deviation in order to force firms to maintain their agreed quota. ...read more.

Middle

The validity of threats can be examined using the same framework, but from the point of view of the firm enforcing the cartel agreement. Assuming that deviation and punishment will be followed by a reinstatement of the previous cartel agreement and that no punishment will lead to a disintegration of the cartel agreement, it is again possible to use game theory to analyse the firm's strategic options: "punish" or "do not punish". If the firm has a low discount factor it will attach little value to future cash flows, and hence will not have incentive to punish. On the other hand, the threat to punish will be greater with a higher discount factor. Therefore, when determining the likelihood of retaliatory action, a firm will have to be aware of the enforcer's discount factor, and determine the most probable strategic choice in the case of deviation. In the case of De Beers, it is possible to analyse the factors affecting the discount factor. ...read more.

Conclusion

The same can be observed by the fall in prices it caused for Australia's Argyle. The Russian case, on the other hand, is slightly different: given the sheers size of the Russian diamond production, De Beers is in a more difficult situation. However, it has continued to attempt to gain control, by buying controlling shares in diamond fields and relying on Russia's need for hard currency. The only exception to De Beers' rule of retaliation is Angola, which was spared because it "was never perceived as a long-term threat to the CSO but rather as a product of the political turmoil in country at that time."3 Because it did not have a great impact on future cash flows due to the limited time span of the situation, De Beers did not believe it to worth punishing. Ultimately, De Beers' approach is consistent with the game theory applied to multiple interactions between firms, using the discount factor to determine the value of future cash flows, and proves the validity of its threat to punish firms and countries that dare to defy its power. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Economy & Economics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Economy & Economics essays

  1. Case Study: The Home Depot

    There are also some specific neighbourhoods, which have restrictions on building new houses in the neighbourhood. These two facts will for the coming years almost guarantee high demand for DIY and DIFM. Economy allowed and will allow Home Depot to grow, even in cases in which the economy wasn't and will not be that good.

  2. analyze an organization (ba)

    The extent of the threat from a particular substitute will depend upon the extent to which the price and performance of the substitute can match the industry's product and the willingness of the buyers to switch to the substitute.(Campbell, 2002).

  1. This report will establish the opportunities and threats presented to Sony by the EU ...

    UK is industrialised and highly developed also technologically advanced. Many of the EU countries invest in UK's economy also; this then looks attractive for other transnationals to invest into its markets because UK have a fast growing market of 3.6%, which increases the populace standard of living.

  2. Chinese car market overview. Citroen case study

    In recent years, EU companies have invested considerably in China (new annual flows of utilised FDI of around USD 4.5 on average in the last 5 years), bringing up stocks of EU FDI to over USD 25 billion. The EU trade deficit mainly reflects the effect of market access obstacles in China.

  1. What are Cartels?

    Diagram 2 shows a firm in a cartel. Before the cartel is formed produces an output of Q1 at a price of P1 and earns no profit. After joining the cartel it reduces output to Qc and changes the price to the cartel price, Pc.

  2. "ASI" LTD case study.

    Development and Public Works and all its institutes and structures, with the Union of Bulgarian Architects, Bulgarian Building and Construction Chamber and the professional building organisations at central and regional level. The audience of the newspaper is highly specialised, including: manufacturers, dealers and tradesmen of building materials and products applicable

  1. A study of Cartels.

    Each different member may have a different proposal, which means reaching an agreement would be difficult. Even once a policy is agreed there is still the problem of firms breaking this agreement, as there is a big incentive to do so.

  2. 'Critically assess the notion that 'corporatism' improves economic performance'. Does globalisation threaten or enhance ...

    Corporatist arrangements are also seen to seek to achieve a consensual framework in which durable, long term relationships between state, trade union and business can be fostered. There is the existence of a 'consensus' between labour and firms with shared perspectives on the goals of economic activity.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work