Was the period 1918-39 a period of economic failure for Britain?

Authors Avatar

Aruni Mukherjee U6MVW

WAS THE PERIOD 1918-39 A PERIOD OF ECONOMIC FAILURE FOR BRITAIN?

Economic failure could be defined as a period in history in which industrial production and productivity fell, unemployment rose on the whole, exports decreased, imports increased and disposable income and consequently consumer spending fell. It is also indicated by the loss of competitiveness for the staple industries in the global market. Growth of new industries is negligible on the whole. However, there has been a great deal of argument about whether the inter-war period was one of economic failure for Britain and how far was its economy successful competing against its European neighbours and competitors overseas like the USA and Japan. Robert Pearce, in his ‘Contemporary Britain’ argues that the main problem in analysing Britain’s economic performance in the inter-war period is due to the fact that some parts of the economy suffered very badly due to the 1929 Wall Street Crash in America like the traditional staple industries while on the other hand, in his ‘Britain: Industrial Relations and the Economy 1900-39’ he points out that certain segments of the economy excelled during this period even during the Depression years. The period also saw the growth of many new industries like the service and retail sector, motor vehicles and electric industry. Pearce has also argued that figures can be manipulated by historians to render support to their argument. For example if we compare the figures of industrial production between the years 1928-1933 there is only a decline of 0.1% which suggests that the economy survived the Depression years quite successfully. However, if we compare the figures of 1929-33 we see there has been a decline of almost 5%, which suggests otherwise.

Join now!

                  Figures available of the inter-war period show that to a large extent Britain’s traditional staple industries performed poorly. During the Great War these industries had a great boost due to the demands of the war and this boom continued even after the war. Steel production went up by 50%. Industrial production, on the whole, went up by 20%. However, production soon exceeded consumption. In 1920 Britain produced 2 million tons of shipping which had to be cut back to ½ million. Its share in the world’s shipping output fell from 51% in 1926-29 to 34% in 1937-38. In 1936, ...

This is a preview of the whole essay