• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Why should financial comparisons of multi-national companies with subsidiaries in different countries be undertaken with caution?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Why should financial comparisons of multi-national companies with subsidiaries in different countries be undertaken with caution? A multinational corporation (MNCs) is, "an international or transnational company with its headquarters in one country but branch offices in a wide range of both developed and developing countries"1 It is generally accepted that a MNC involves producing and selling goods in several different countries. The expansion of corporations internationally tends to be one of the most important goals for continuing success. The creation of a subsidiary in a new country creates many problems for the corporation. Consideration will be given to both internally and externally financial reporting problems. The focus of this essay will be on the language, currency, Accounting Standards and external audit problems and why caution has to be taken when comparing MNCs. For MNCs, deciding on what language to use for reporting purpose can be a problem, this is because each subsidiary may have a different native language. Making this decision will depend on the language which is the most recognisable by their portfolio of investors. The majority of the MNCs would produce reports in English or have copies available in English. The language chosen does not tend to be a major problem to investors. This is due to English been well known globally and many investors being multilingual or having access to translation services.2 Terminology tends to be a bigger problem. ...read more.

Middle

Therefore translation from the foreign currency to local currency is required. Stable currency rates would create no problems. However, "exchange rates are seldom stable"6 and as a result it would increase the number of translation rates creating more foreign exchange gains and losses. There are three main exchange rate methods, historical, current and average. The historical exchange rate method would 'shield' whereas the current exchange rate method would 'cause' translation gains and losses.7 Therefore as different MNCs would use a different method, their financial statements would be incomparable, as they would not have been compared on the same basis. The MNCs would need to decide which currency to report in. This would depend on the location of major investors, areas of business activities, international recognition of currency and the country of domicile both legal and actual.8 Within the last five years or so many questions has been raised regarding auditing. The postulation that the high level of potential income that the auditors may receive from a client would influence the result of the audit, raises the question, how credible are the financial reports?9 The main challenges facing a user of financial reports are the credibility of the figures. The auditing profession has the problem of users not knowing whether the reports comply with the accounting standards. ...read more.

Conclusion

Unfortunately the problems of comparability are unlikely to go away, especially when the US offers the option of IAS or US GAAP, although international harmonisation processes may reduce them. In conclusion when comparing financial statements of MNCs that have subsidiaries it is worth being cautious. There are many areas that can be misleading when making this comparison. The terminology used in financial reports varies from country to country and as a result inaccurate comparison may be made. The accounting standards that need to be complied with by the MNC will vary depending on its domicile and if they are listed on any stock exchanges. As they may have to produce more than one financial report but complying with different standards it is likely that they only comply with the standard rather than try and provide a true and fair view. The translation exchange methods used to consolidate the reports will impact through gains or losses. As different MNCs would use different method of translation it would not allow a fair comparison. It is not possible to know whether the audit has been done accurately and correctly. The credibility of the audit report is still very much open to discussion. The Big Five are not answerable to anyone and they do have a tendency to sign off the audit report when accounting error exists with the financial report. Financial comparison between cross-border and within-border will blur with continuing globalisation and improvements in international accounting. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Accounting & Finance section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Accounting & Finance essays

  1. Compare the two companies Tesco's and McDonalds

    Technology and changing social attitudes * Pressure groups * Global factors This Activity needs to draw together these different areas to look at the ways in which businesses try to balance the competing stakeholder demands. Short term objectives . Keep making new advertisements for children etc.

  2. The purpose of this report is to explain the legal and regulatory influences on ...

    in financial statements. In the UK and the Republic of Ireland, VAT is a tax on the supply of goods and services that is eventually borne by the final consumer but collected at each stage of the production and distribution chain.

  1. Discuss the need for regulation in financial reporting.

    This would be standardization based on uniform accounting practice, and could be achieved with little more than the random selection of one accounting treatment from the range available. Financial reporting regulators in the UK responded to the diversity in reporting of barter of advertising transactions with official rulings, EITF 99-17[1] and UITF 26, respectively.

  2. Unit 5 Introduction to Accounting

    While intangible assets don't have the obvious physical value of a factory or equipment, they can prove very valuable for a firm and can be critical to its long-term success or failure. For example, companies such as Coca-Cola wouldn't be nearly as successful were it not for the high value obtained through its brand-name recognition.

  1. Management Accounting Report.

    manufacturer can supply similar food mixers for �250 each, the Managing Director of Oakdene Engineering argues that it will be cheaper if the company closed the production department and have the overseas supplier to supply the food mixers. To him it might be a very good idea but he has

  2. The Purpose of Keeping Accurate Accounts

    that are usually spread over a number of years, during which the organisation is expected to earn additional revenue out of the expenditure. While this treatment is an accepted principle, there may be a counter-treatment, argued by another group, to charge the item as an expense, the entire amount in the year it was spent, on the grounds of conservatism.

  1. Compare and contrast the approach of the US and UK financial regulatory bodies and ...

    Apart from EU level, UK also has its own financial regulators, such as Financial Services Authority (FSA). FSA is an independent body that is responsible for regulating financial services in UK. FSA has got the supervisory power on UK securities markets and the listed companies.

  2. Investment Portfolio - Shares and other investments

    46 0.81% 25-Feb-08 18.03 0.53 3.03% 5699.8 55.3 0.98% 22-Feb-08 17.5 0.74 4.42% 5644.5 -18.5 -0.33% 21-Feb-08 16.76 1.43 9.33% 5663 85.7 1.54% 20-Feb-08 15.33 -0.99 -6.07% 5577.3 -111.3 -1.96% 19-Feb-08 16.32 0.12 0.74% 5688.6 54.6 0.97% 18-Feb-08 16.2 -1.04 -6.03% 5634 -45.8 -0.81% 15-Feb-08 17.24 -0.31 -1.77% 5679.8 -68.4

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work