• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'Aeneas is little more than a puppet controlled by the actions of the gods.' Is this a fair assessment of Aeneas in books 1, 2, 4 and 6 of Virgil's Aeneid?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

'Aeneas is little more than a puppet controlled by the actions of the gods.' Is this a fair assessment of Aeneas in books 1, 2, 4 and 6 of Virgil's Aeneid? This description of Aeneas is a very controversial one and so I will analyse the quote in some detail. Fate plays a huge role in Books I, II, IV and VI of the Aeneid. From the very beginning of the Aeneid Fate decrees that Aeneas must reach Italy with all of his crew and go on to found Lavinium: "He was a refugee chased by Fate from the land of Troy, first to reach Italy where Lavinium was to be built." From Lavinium, Aeneas' son, Iulus, will leave to found Alba Longa. Years later Romulus and Remus will be born and their tale of how Rome was founded will become reality. Does Aeneas have a choice in whether these events happen? The answer is simple: no. This is because Fate is final and cannot be altered even by the gods. Whether Aeneas has feelings, emotions and wishes along the path to completing his fate, will in the end determine whether he is a puppet or not. It is important to realise that Fate is a greater power than Gods and Goddesses. ...read more.

Middle

He wanted to fight at Troy but Fate, through his father, Anchises, did not allow him: "My son, I consent, and no longer refuse to go with you." This scene at Troy shows that Aeneas had wishes but was not given the privilege of being able to follow them. In Book II Aeneas is free to act and follow his different impulses but ultimately his not staying to fight and die is decided for him by Fate. In the same book Hector and Creusa visit Aeneas in dreams and are representatives of Fate and through them Aeneas finds out that though he had thought that he had free will the Fall of Troy "has happened just as the Gods decreed." However, to show that Aeneas has wishes in Book IV he says: "...if the Fates allowed me to live my life as I wished." This clearly shows that Aeneas does have feelings and emotions and puppets do not have these qualities. However, Aeneas now finally understands his destiny that lies in Italy (as decreed by Fate): "But Italy, great Italy, is the land I must make for..." Gods other than Athena's role (mentioned above) intervened in the Greek siege of Troy. ...read more.

Conclusion

It seems that Juno and Venus acted on whims to encourage love between Dido and Aeneas. Ultimately, the final result of the love between Dido and Aeneas is that Dido curses Aeneas' descendants; and because of the curse Rome and Carthage will always be bitter enemies. There is a view taken by some that humans (therefore Aeneas) are puppets to the arrogant and omnipotent Gods, and that through disguises and tricks the gods are trying to either, help Aeneas successfully complete and meet his destiny of founding Rome, or to discourage him. The Gods and Goddesses (especially Juno and Venus) use Aeneas as a puppet and exploit his mortal qualities in an attempt to help or destroy him. Venus, unlike Juno is trying to help Aeneas fulfil his destiny. This is obviously because Aeneas is her son. It is true that all in all, the Gods and Goddesses use Aeneas, the Greeks and the Trojans for their own purposes in a show of their divine power and inner feuding. However, this view portrays Aeneas as a pure puppet of the Gods, which simply is not true as he has feelings, emotions and pietas. Aeneas is a mixture between a puppet and a free mortal because the end result of his actions in general are decided by Fate and when the Gods are not intervening, he does have Free Will. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Classics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Classics essays

  1. Peer reviewed

    Greek Gods and Mythology

    Hephaistos thought that the jewels would keep Aphrodite with him and not make others more attracted to her. Aphrodite had many sons. Not all of her sons were by her husband (Aphrodite, Internet). The war god Ares was also in love with Aphrodite and would always give her beautiful gifts (Ares, Internet).

  2. child development coursework visit 1

    Whilst cutting the fruit I will make sure that Harris is not in reach of any sharp objects for e.g. knives. For the ball game I will need to arrange a soft ball as I am not sure if Harris has any.

  1. Compare Aeneas and Odysseus in Their Role As Leaders And Prospective Hero's?

    and he sends one of his men to check the island for any possible hostilities. Aeneas and Odysseus's aims in the works are similar in the sense both men wish to reach their homeland. However, Aeneas is not trying to reach Troy but a found a new homeland for his

  2. From the books you have read so far, to what extent would you say ...

    When Odysseus has left Calypso island she helps Odysseus by checking the winds and 'binding them to calm' so that they would flatter the waves in Odysseus path. Also Athene puts the idea into Odysseus head that he should grab hold of the rock with both hands as he is swept in from the sea.

  1. How do Books 1 - 4 of the Odyssey prepare us for the introduction ...

    We first meet Telemachus when he is wavering between extreme emotions, imagining his father dead and then hoping for his safe return. This shows us he is not thinking straight and simply doesn't know what to believe. It makes him look very much like a lost little boy who needs his father to keep him straight.

  2. Free essay

    Who Do You Blame For The Tragedy Of Book IV Of The Aeneid?

    Virgil spends too long building up Aeneas's character for example for his demonstration of loyalty in Book II where his father Anchises refuses to leave Troy, "...Here I lie and here I stay..." so Aeneas refuses to leave as well, "...Did you think I could run away and leave my father here?

  1. Write a diary from the point of view of Achilles' during the Trojan War

    The warrior, who could only have been Ajax, was only stopped when Hector thought to chop the head of the spear, not that it made much difference in the hands of Ajax; I don?t think he probably noticed the loss for a while, until he became tired of smashing the heads of his foes.

  2. What limitations did vase painters face and how successfully did they overcome them?

    the Maenads, the heads being very close, the same body movement and both heels are lifting of the ground at the same time. We get a clear view of Dionysus acknowledging the offered hare through his movement of his left hand.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work