• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

'Both Antigone and Creon deserve our sympathy'. Discuss.

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Elena Solaro 12E 'Both Antigone and Creon deserve our sympathy'. Discuss In his tragic play 'Antigone', Sophocles presents the audience with a variety of interesting protagonists. One of the main characters is Creon, regent of Thebes and brother in law of former king, Oedipus. Another important character is Oedipus' daughter/sister, and Creon's niece, Antigone. She is a character for whom the audience will undoubtedly have great sympathy, and even more so as her tragic fate unfolds over the course of the play. Indeed, the same could be said of Creon, although perhaps initially, we do not feel so well disposed towards him. However, the audience may have greatly mixed views on these characters as different events occur in the play, and as such we can neither completely condemn nor praise their actions. Antigone's traumatic background and troubled past induces pity within the audience right from the beginning of the play. By a tragic and unfortunate series of events she and her siblings came to learn that their father Oedipus was also their brother. These terrible circumstances rendered Oedipus' children outcasts in society, destined to live a life of misery and disgrace. suffering at the hands of fathers misguided actions, not their own. The fact that Antigone's suffering was at the hands of another's misguided actions and not her own fills us with pity for her. When, in her opening speech she says "There's nothing, no pain-our lives are pain-no private shame, no public disgrace, nothing I haven't seen in your griefs and mine", we feel immense sorrow for her. Also, the fact that there was nothing she could have done to avoid her destiny seems cruel and unjust, deepening our sympathy for Antigone, who is truly the tragic heroine. ...read more.

Middle

She says: "I'd never welcome you in the labour, not with me. So do as you like-whatever suits you best." This hot-headed response makes Antigone a far less favourable character in the audience's eyes, particularly considering Ismene's genuine anxiety and care for her sister. Similarly, when Antigone says "I'll hate you all the more for you're silence" we feel her contempt is unreasonable and unmerited. Even when the crime has been discovered, Ismene remains faithful to her sister and implores Antigone to let her "share the guilt and the consequence". This makes us all the more astonished at Antigone's fierce reply: "Who did the work? Let the dead and the god of death bear witness! I have no love for a friend who loves in words alone." When we consider that Ismene is totally innocent, and yet prepared to sacrifice her own life for her sister, Antigone's abusive behaviour seems ruthless and unacceptable. We can find no sympathy for such malicious conduct and blind obstinacy. Like Antigone, another character who arouses a mixture of emotions within the audience is Creon. In some instances we feel empathy for him, and are in accordance with his actions, whilst in others we find his behaviour far from laudable. Despite her troubled past and unnatural parentage, Creon has promised Antigone in marriage to his own son, Haemon. This was a magnanimous decision on his part, particularly considering the disadvantage Oedipus' female children would find themselves at in acquiring a husband. Indeed, Oedipus himself said that no man would ever want to marry them for the shame and disgrace he had brought upon their heads. ...read more.

Conclusion

In fact, an argument ensues, in which Creon calls Haemon "you degenerate". We feel Creon is very foolish in ignoring his son's advice, particularly seen as Haemon acts as the voice of public opinion. The audience at this point have no sympathy for Creon and would gladly see him punished for his misdemeanours. When the chorus leader dares to suggest that the burial may have been a token act of the gods, Creon is furious. Although he believed himself to have been doing the gods a favour in punishing Polynices, in reality his actions were arrogant and egotistical. He has overstepped the mark in thinking he can act as an equal to the gods, who regard it as their duty to punish the perpetrators of sacrilege. Not only this, but in priding himself on being a man who abides by the laws of state, he has forgotten that he is breaking the unwritten laws of the gods. It was also the custom and tradition of Thebes to bury traitors outside of the city walls. In conclusion, I would say that both Antigone and Creon deserve our pity, however, not in equal amounts. Overall, I felt Antigone to be the more deserving character. Although at times she is capricious and hot tempered, it was her love for her family and a respect for the gods that drove her to carry out her crime. Creon, in contrast shows none of this love. He initially believes that money was the sole reason for the crime, never suspecting that it might have been committed for a different motive. He shows himself to be cold and heartless, turning on the members of his family and severing the bonds of kinship with ease. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Classics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Classics essays

  1. Peer reviewed

    Greek Gods and Mythology

    His first love was Merope, the daughter of the king of the islands of Chios. Meropes father held her off from Orion and then Orion tried to steal her away. Orion was a hunter. He did most of his hunting with the huntress queen, Diana.

  2. Who is the Tragic Hero and Why? (Antigone)

    and sell his own people into slaver-Polynices, I say, is to have no burial" (Scene 1, Line 39) Despite, the cruelty and ruthlessness of decisions made by Creon in the eyes of Antigone, Creon, in his defense, still has a rationalization, as described in the quotation.

  1. what was the purpose of hadrians wall.

    vallum takes the more sedate route, often over 1/2 mile away along the southern slopes. The Wall and vallum greet each other briefly near Great Chesters and re-unite again at Carvoran at the opposite end of the Peatsteel Crags, thereafter, the two linear barriers run almost parallel all the way

  2. Despite their differences in character, Antigone and Miss Julie encounter the same fate.

    "You are not ... play with fire?"4 Haemon, Creon's son, heir to the throne of Thebes, proposes marriage to Antigone and becomes unfalteringly loyal to her. On questioning his love, he professes his feeling with immense passion. Simultaneously honouring her solitude and freedom. Despite their love for each other, a sense of doom seems to follow them.

  1. Form and Structure - Antigone

    being crowned king, the bad event is the death of three people and his bad choice is ignoring other people's advice. Chorus Sophocles' plays were sometimes hard to comprehend. For this reason he uses the chorus to summarise complex pieces of plot.

  2. Who made the greatest contribution to the Athenian Constitution?

    have been acceptable in Peisistratos' time, it certainly isn't in the 21st Century. Cleisthenes: Cleisthenes was a figure whose contribution to the Athenian Constitution is as vast as Solon's was. His first reform was the reorganisation of governmental structures and the setting up of the Council of 500, or the Boule.

  1. Eye witness acount of Vesuvius eruption

    As we went we could see men running ramped in the darkness, with bags of gold and other valuables. Father kept saying he knew a man at the harbour who could take us to safety. That thought was all that was keeping us going.

  2. Existentialism in The Stranger

    Curious, she then asks, "Suppose another girl had asked you to marry her- mean, a girl you liked in the same way as you like me- would you have said "yes" to her too?" To which he replies in total honesty, "Naturally".

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work