• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare Aeneas and Odysseus in Their Role As Leaders And Prospective Hero's?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Compare Aeneas and Odysseus in Their Role As Leaders And Prospective Hero's? Virgil's 'Aeneid' and Homer's 'Odyssey' are two very different stories, told from opposing viewpoints: that of the Trojans in 'The Aeneid,' and of the Greeks in 'The Odyssey.' The two leaders, Aeneas and Odysseus, that feature are therefore very different in their approach to leadership. However, despite their differences they both rise to the challenges set to them as true leaders. In each work, the first time the great leaders feature, the first impression given of each is hardly one of a strong leader and future hero. When we first meet the Greek hero, Odysseus, he is sitting on a rock despairing on the island of Ogygia, where the demi-goddess Calypso has kept him for eight years. He appears hopeless and defeated; not exactly typical leadership qualities. This mirrors the first appearance of Aeneas, except for the fact he is still amongst his own men, who is facing fierce sea storms ordered by the goddess Juno. He too is crying in desperation and appears to have lost all hope in his destiny: 'A sudden chill went through Aeneas and his limbs grew weak. Groaning, he lifted his hands palms upward to the stars and cried...' ...read more.

Middle

He manages to contract a plan to escape from the Cyclops cave before any more of his rapidly deteriorating army are eaten. He is clearly very passionate for success and kleos, which was a typical Greek characteristic. It is no doubt that his respect for the heroic code would set a good example to fellow Greek warriors, as it is what was expected of them. He is therefore a good leader of the Greeks. Aeneas' character is much more thoughtful. He is a very pious man and does not allow himself to act spontaneously, unlike Odysseus who foolishly calls out his name boastfully as they leave the Cyclopes island (allowing him to be cursed!) This calm, careful authority was looked for in a true Trojan leader. Aeneas gives up his love Dido in order to fulfil his duty and destiny. There are only a couple of occasions where we see him act upon his heart rather than his head, the most distinctive being when he kills his Greek rival Turnus: '"Are you to escape me now, wearing the spoils stripped from the body of those I loved? By this wound which I now give, it is Pallas who makes sacrifice of you. ...read more.

Conclusion

gates to man the walls, for these were the orders they had received form Aeneas, the greatest of warriors, as he left them: if anything should happen in his absence, they were not to dare take up position for a pitched battle or trust themselves to the plain, but only to stay and defend the camp and the walls.' It is clear that both are great leaders in their own rights and equally suited to their own race. 'The Aeneid' itself tells us that the Greeks were a much more scheming race and therefore the cunning, quick witted Odysseus is the ideal leader for their race. The Trojans on the other hand were a much more trusting city, as we see in their innocent but foolish acceptance of the scheming Sinon (he let the Greeks into Troy after gaining the Trojans sympathy and trust.) However, trust is not a downfall in Aeneas' case. It is this trust that allows him to be such a pious man; he takes the advice of the gods even if there is doubt in his mind. His fatherly care for his men and careful planning for war is ideally suited to the Trojan race. Both men live up to the reputations they have as great leaders, and each is successful in their quests. Louisa Sillem ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Classics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Classics essays

  1. Was Odysseus a hero?

    Due to this Odysseus was able to gain favor in Circe's eyes and he convinced her to turn his men back to normal.

  2. The Portrayal of Women in the Odyssey

    she insists he meet her mother first as opposed to her father. This demonstrates her respect for her mother, and her understanding of the way in which the system should work, but the knowledge of how it actually does. Finally, the good hostess and wife are portrayed by Penelope.

  1. Classics Essay, Compare and Contrast Penelope and Circe.

    She knows that if this really was Odysseus then he would know that he built it around a tree and it cannot be moved. This shows cunning and resourcefulness that Odysseus is also known for. Circe however is not like that at all and has had no mention of her

  2. How do Books 1 - 4 of the Odyssey prepare us for the introduction ...

    Another example of Telemachus growing in confidence is when he tells his mother to calm down and be in a more reasonable manner. He is calm but his words are true and effective. This is a trait of Odysseus that we see shine through Telemachus.

  1. Citizenship coursework - Planning

    Stage two: We wanted to do an issue that related to us and something that needed a lot of promotion. As a group then we voted on the issue we were going to do and then we brainstormed all the different ways which we could help.

  2. Science case study

    Tuberculosis Influenza http://www.ash.org.uk/html/factsheets/html/fact02.html - this website is reliable as it is a website from the government. Smoking causes a number of health problems and also smoking can develop a number of health problems such as lung cancer etc. By just smoking one cigarette, a person's blood pressure and heart rate

  1. From the books that you have read, what do you think is the most ...

    They then came to the land of the Lotus-Eaters. Odysseus sent some of them to go and explore the area. They soon found the Lotus Eaters who offered them some lotus: 'Those who ate the honeyed fruit of the plant lost any wish to come back and bring us news.

  2. Write a diary from the point of view of Achilles' during the Trojan War

    came to persuade me to come back. Apparently Agamemnon is offering me a wealth of gifts to bribe me to fight for him again including the girl Briseis and I was sorely tempted to accept but that would be spineless and it will be much funnier to spite him by remaining here.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work