• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

GCSE Latin- Who is more reliable in their account of the druid culture- Julius Caesar, Tacitus or Pliny?

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Latin Essay- Whom is more reliable in their account of the Druids? Caesar in 'De Bello Galli', Pliny the Elder in the 'Naturalis Historia', or Tacitus? In comparing these sources, we must first take into account a number of factors. First, when was the account written? Second, what was its purpose? Third, did the opinions/beliefs/morals of the author have any effect on the tone of their account? It must also be noted that the Druids and their culture had been around for a long time before any of these authors started writing about them, and much of the information was already very old when it reached Caesar, Pliny and Tacitus. Nobody had written extensively about the druids, and much of the information was of unknown quality. Julius Caesar (who henceforth will be known as JC) is alleged to have written his accounts while making his slow, bloody way across much of Gaul (North-Western France) and Britain. ...read more.

Middle

popularity as people became disillusioned with the old polytheistic religion, and may have been slightly dismissive of the Druids religious beliefs - refers to them as 'cranks'. His account was written in 50AD, by which time the Druids were disappearing, and their culture was going with them. As a result, Pliny is much less likely to have seen many Druids, whereas JC would have seen many, and therefore his account was written from rumour, fable and hearsay, with the possibility of embellishment. Pliny was a believer in magic and superstition, and Naturalis Historia is full of unsupported claims, and Pliny's assertions, which we are unable to test. After being accepted as gospel for centuries, it was rejected by 17th century scientists. While JC's work is a tribute to Gallic custom, the purpose of Pliny's work is primarily botany, and concentrates less on the Druids' custom, but more on mistletoe, their sacred plant. ...read more.

Conclusion

In conclusion, all the accounts have their faults and merits, but I think that that of JC is probably the most reliable, as it is definitely true that Caesar travelled much of Gaul and Britain, and is likely to have seen some of their culture while there. Even if it is exaggerated, there is a lot more truth in it than that of Pliny, whose entire Historia Naturalis has been disproved, and of Tacitus, who holds the Druids in contempt on some moral principle. Both of these authors received their information indirectly, and although we can never prove which is actually correct (all three differ in their account of Druidic custom- although this could be due to the fact that their customs may have been different in different areas), it is fair to say that Julius Caesar's account has probably got more truth in it, although it itself is unlikely to be totally true. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Classics section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Classics essays

  1. Communication and Meaning in the Crying of Lot 49

    Communication in all forms is more important than the content that is being communicating, because of the power of interpretation. A single sentence can be decoded in multiple ways, and therefore it is left to the communicator to relay the message in his/her own way.

  2. Who made the greatest contribution to the Athenian Constitution?

    manageable level, and thus prevented them from raising an army to overthrow the leader. The liturgy functions similarly to income tax in the United Kingdom in 2010. The future system imposes a tax on working citizens, which is relative to their earnings.

  1. Paranoia and the Search for Meaning in the Crying of Lot 49

    and tries to make the connection between everything that is presented to her. In the end, as Nietzsche postulated, "There are no facts, only interpretations" (Nietzsche, from Sontag 5). It can be argued that, at the end of it all, Oedipa has lost her way in Pierce's web, and she

  2. The Druids

    This land was thought to be very sacred. Looking at the wider picture, this information about the Druids gives out a statement on just how dominating the Druids were in society. Basically, the Druids were the lawmakers and very much equivalent to policeman, lawyers and judges of today, but, my

  1. Latin Coursework Roman Culture

    The Iliad tells the semi- mythical story of the fall of Troy, Aeneas' home city, which was destroyed by the Greeks. Aeneas was said, in the story, to be a Trojan Lieutenant. Homer is considered to have written down the story of the Iliad, a story already part of Greek

  2. Roman Religion

    Aeneas is destined to settle in Italy and become a great leader. Aeneas is forced to suffer immensely throughout his journey. His first wife, Creusa, dies while Troy burns. With Creusa dead in Troy, Aeneas is free both legally and morally to marry another woman when he finally does arrive in Italy.

  1. Was Britain Worth The Romans Invading?

    This money was usually used to buy the troops corn for their bread ration. Most of the time, tax was paid in corn, rather than money. Not all the tax collected was used to help pay for the expenses to upkeep the province; some of it was sent back to Rome.

  2. Pericles and Athens in the 5th century BC

    To spread the valves of democracy and destroy tyranny, to liberate lionia from Persian influences to ransack Persian territory and take booty as compensation for the damage suffered in the Persian wars. To unite the disparate Greek states and to form a rival power bloc to the Peloponnesian league.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work