• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparison of Hills like White Elephants and FAT

Extracts from this document...

Introduction

Comparison of Hills like White Elephants and FAT Both Hill like White Elephants and FAT are short stories about current issues that have to be resolved. The issue in FAT regards obesity in America and is shown as a conversation between the narrator and 'Rudy'. Hills like White Elephants, however, the issue is abortion and the author uses direct speech creating the effect that we are near the couple, eavesdropping on the conversation. In FAT, the author uses indirect speech because the person is retelling the past events to a friend. He does this to make it seem as if he is describing it to us (us being the friend). This creates trust for the narrator. To create the illusion of conversation and focus the reader on the issue at hand, in both stories authors do not develop the character fully. This is to ensure we focus on the action and the characters' situation. This also emphasises in fact that this is a situation that can effect anyone. In Hills like White Elephants this is performed by only using the characters' names once to increase their anonymity. However, this does give a clue the background/culture of the pair, e.g. ...read more.

Middle

In FAT, we are immediately made aware of the situation by the comical description of the 'fatty' who is 'the fattest man I've ever seen'. The repetition of 'fat' then keeps the issue fresh in our minds. In addition to this, the author describes the man's fingers as 'long, thick, creamy fingers'. The use of 'creamy' makes us think of something full of calories and fat like the man. On the other hand, Hills like White Elephants uses subtlety and the reader only begins to realise something is wrong when tension is built though interactions and until a point where the couple argue of a stupid matter of whether the man has seen a 'white elephant'. This further increases the awkwardness between the man and the girl, showing that something is building in both their minds, and that we are about to find out. This tension is maintained by the use of the only simile in the story about the girl believing there are 'Hills like White Elephants' in front of them, which is used to make the issue seem simplistic like the girls comment. Contrastingly, FAT uses many similes, to describe the man's 'long, thick, creamy fingers' and other matters relating to the issue of the man's obesity. ...read more.

Conclusion

This alienation, detachment and loneliness can be linked to the girl in Hills like White Elephants as she might as well be alone dining as the man is not listening to her or nurturing a relationship of any kind. At the end of the day, humans are social animals who like to feel part of a community and it is therefore striking when these characters are so obviously outcasts. However, the ending in FAT is very different to the ending in Hills like White Elephants. In Hills like White Elephants, the train comes and the couple leave, unlike in FAT where the narrator and Rudy get in bed and then as soon as Rudy 'gets on [her]' she feels 'terrifically fat'. We are not told why this is but we know '[her] life is going to change'. This is also shown by the mention of 'it is August', the change between summer and winter. Therefore, we can only assume that her outlook has changed as well as her prejudice. This makes the reader empathetic towards the fat man and we see that, like abortion, obesity is an issue that needs to be understood to be resolved. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Food Technology section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Food Technology essays

  1. heal and social unit 2

    He pays for his children education. I also think that his job influences him to do all of this. I think his love for his family made him forgive his wife and give her another chance. Mr David doesn't have any financial difficulties because he earns his living like other people and earns a lot on money doing this.

  2. What was it like in the trenches?

    ages, the water will soon root away the skin and inner side of the foot, later your feet will be swollen up, three times as big as normally. Many soldiers had to cut off their foot, because it was so painful, but when it was chopped of they felt no

  1. Because its Fat

    Comfort food are there to make us feel better, maybe that's why we can't stop ourselves to eat it. Comfort food is also eaten while we are watching TV. We can learn to change these habits by eating healthier foods such as carrot and celery sticks.

  2. mcdonalds in america

    In my oponion there is no doubt that McDonalds can seriously damage your health, but how can it be said that the obesity epidemic in America is entirely the fault of McDonalds? Do they force feed people there food? No.

  1. Deep Fat Fryer

    Raise the basket again when the frying time has elapsed. Rinse the handle and the basket after use, and dry thoroughly. Replacing the oil Make sure that the deep fryer and the oil have totally cooled off before replacing the oil.

  2. Find out whether, in general, more fat means more calories in food. I am ...

    Foodstuff Calories Fat content bacon cooked 692 72.8 baked beans 56 0.2 beans, runner, boiled 18 0.5 beef cooked 613 62.8 biscuits, fruit club (Jacobs) 496 25 bread, brown 218 2 breakfast cereals, alpen 364 6.8 breakfast cereals, ready brek 359 8.4 cake, bakewell tart.

  1. Proud to be an American.

    While we were there the team and I got the chance to have dinner with the head sports chairman. We ate in his private dinner hall with some other important figures as well. They brought us out so many weird foods that you would never even think of having in the United States.

  2. Members of this family have acquired their name 'Scorpaenidae' from the poisonous spines in ...

    In captivity these fish will usually only eat live foods initially like guppies or goldfish. Eventually though they may take frozen silversides or lancefish. Apparently eating a diet of goldfish and guppies alone may produce a deficiency of proper fatty acids (from Wittenrich, Sea Scope, Summer 1998).

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work