• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Act II, Scene 5: By looking closely at language and imagery, what impression is created of the brothers in the following dialogue? In what way is this scene significant in the play as a whole?

Extracts from this document...


Act II, Scene 5: By looking closely at language and imagery, what impression is created of the brothers in the following dialogue? In what way is this scene significant in the play as a whole? Act II, Scene 5 of John Webster's, The Duchess of Malfi is a crucial point for both the plot and of the critical understanding of two of the play's main characters: the Aragonian Brothers, Ferdinand and Cardinal. The scene is a dialogue between the two brothers and has an abundance of imagery, providing an insight into the pair's differentiating mentalities, moods and motives. The significance of this scene can be explained in terms of the recent developments of the plot and how the two brothers react to and intended to deal with them. These developments are the recent news that Bosola has brought to Ferdinand in the form of a horoscope, telling that "The Duchess was deliver'd of a son" [II.3.56]. This must mean that the Duchess has allowed someone to "sway your [her] high blood" [I.2.218]. The revelation of the birth of a son asks the brothers whether or not they are going to carry out their previous threats: "This was my father's poniard: do you see, / I'll'd be loathe to see't look rusty," [I.2.251-2]. Ferdinand begins to suggest means in which to punish and eventually kill the Duchess and her children: "I'll bequeath this [his handkerchief] to her bastard / .............to make soft lint for his mother's wounds, / When I have hewn her to pieces." ...read more.


The Cardinal, however, is far more concerned about the damage that could be done to his family's reputation: "Shall our blood? / The royal blood of Aragon and Castile, / Be thus attained?" [II.5.21-3]. He blames women for the downfalls within the human race as he blames the Duchess for his family's loss of honour, and he speaks of women as an evil with "...hearts / So far upon the left side" [II.5.32-3]. When he says this, he is referring to the belief that hearts on the left side "are full of deceit, / Truth freedome and loyalty are rare unknowne and exiled qualities"2 He continues to state that women consciously try and cause the downfall of men, "Foolish men, / That e'er will trust their honour in a bark, / Made of so slight, weak bulrush, as is woman, / Apt every minute to sink it." He feels that, men who trust in women are self destructive. His feelings towards the Duchess are far from Ferdinand's passionate desires, he sees her as an animal, "curs'd creature!" [II.5.31], and perhaps as a tool the family can use as a show piece to society. Their reactions, springing from different issues and emotions, also show their varying personas. Ferdinand reacts passionately to the news of his sister giving birth. His physical obsession towards her erupts in violent ideas by which to punish her, he threatens to revenge her with a bloody death, and says he will not calm until he has seen her dead: "'Tis not your whore's milk, that shall quench my wild-fire / But your whore's blood" [II.5.48-9]. ...read more.


The happy family unit of the Duchess and Antonio is now under threat and the hourglass has been turned; there is only a matter of time before this fresh optimism will be forced to come to an end. I feel that Webster uses this scene in the play to show his feelings, as an English Protestant, of the Spanish Catholics in Italy. We are already aware that the Cardinal is far from the respectful clergy man he should be, by our knowledge of his mistress, Julia. Now we see Ferdinand's inner-rage and incestuous wishes he holds towards his sister. By knowing this, the scene persuades the audience to feel for the Duchess, a young woman only trying to live her life as she wishes, under the forceful control of her brothers. We feel proud for her courage to break away from their demanding requests and separate herself from them. At the time it may well have been expected for the widowed sister to do as her brothers said, and by showing us this insight into the brothers' conversation, Webster has led us to a greater understanding of the Duchess, giving us permission to sympathise with her. 1Information gained from: http://virtual-park.uga.edu/~cdesmet/sabrin/malfi.htm 2From Matthieu's "History of Lewis the Eleventh", found in New Mermaids "The Duchess of Malfi" edited by Elizabeth M Brennan. (3rd edition, 1993) 3 From New Mermaids "The Duchess of Malfi" edited by Elizabeth M Brennan. (3rd edition 1993) 4 Information taken from: www.britannica.com/seo/h/humour-1/ ?? ?? ?? ?? Juliet Cook 20th January 2001 4 ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Blood Brothers section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Blood Brothers essays

  1. blood brothers coursewrok

    When Mrs Johnstone was crying for her sons the audience felt her sadness and empathised her. However when the Lyons' came onto stage, the actors used levels to imply superiority and the audience felt cold towards. The play is then viewed as a flashback from the very beginning, recounted by the narrator.

  2. Blood Brothers review

    It was used when the idea of superstition was brought up. One of the most memorable scenes where lighting was concerned, had to be the Madwoman chant, were Mrs Lyons stumbled into centre stage and fell to the floor, the stage was red washed and signified her spiralling down into her own personal hell.

  1. Blood Brothers, Review Of Play. A*

    The audience is knows that these two are brothers and there is a degree of dramatic irony taking place. Throughout all of Blood Brothers, we explore the Characters of Mickey and Eddie in great detail, their feelings and responses to all that is going on around them.

  2. Blood Brothers

    We end the role play with them frozen while having both their hands on the bible. In this drama we were asked to do an abstract role play showing that the twins were born, but Mrs Johnstone refuses to give one to Mrs Lyons.

  1. Blood Brothers response

    We tried to emphasize the line "But I'm not I'm nearly eight!' by saying the line as a chorus and increasing the tone of our voice. We did this because the poem is centred on the fact that Mickey wants to do the things that Sammy does.

  2. Blood Brothers

    was an outcast from the others' circle of friends and played by himself. The girls were again seen as a lower status than the boys. They did what the boys told them and saw it as the boys job to protect them.

  1. Blood Brothers Performance

    different actors playing the different roles, though the cast was very small, and it was the same actors playing the different parts, which, if it is done well, is very effective. When the actors playing Mickey (Richard Munday) and Edward are playing them as children, there are many things they

  2. Blood Brothers

    Ms Johnston on the other hand, was always wearing basic clothing with an apron, plus her outfit didn't change once throughout the play. Not only did Mrs Lyons and Ms Johnston's costume show the divisions between rich and poor but Eddie and Mickey's costume did too.

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work