• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparative study, between the presentation of the characters Pechorin ("A Hero of Our Time") and Shukhov ("One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich").

Extracts from this document...


English Higher Level World Literature Assignment 1 Comparative study, between the presentation of the characters Pechorin ("A Hero of Our Time") and Shukhov ("One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich") Name: Masroor Butt Code: 0239 011 Date: May 2004 School: International School of Hilversum Code: 0239 Word Count: 1,495 words The two novels "Hero of Our Time" written by Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn and "One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich" written by Mikhail Lermontov will be compared for this World Literature Assignment (Comparative Study). The main characters of these two novels will be compared and distinguished. In "Hero of Our Time" the main character is Grigory Alexandrovich Pechorin and the main character in "One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich" is Ivan Denisovich (Shukhov). The novel "Hero of Our Time" is composed of five short stories and is about the adventures of the main character Pechorin. There are three main narrators in this novel, who are, the travel writer, Pechorin and Maxim Maximych. Lermontov has used three narrators so the readers can see three different perspectives making the reader see different views of the characters in the book. ...read more.


"A Hero of Our Time" involves women. Pechorin is scared to get in love or make any kind of commitment with any women since a fortune teller once told his mother that he would die when he gets married. Pechorin thinks about this and tries to avoid it, thus he makes excuses for not making any commitments with women. The reader gets the feeling that he is irrational, although it's clean-cut that he has an ambivalent character. Pechorin is a person who contradicts himself. He sets out to do something and at the end does the total opposite of it. This shows that he can be misleading. "I lied, but I wanted to bait him. I was born with a passion for contradiction. My whole life has been nothing but a series of dismal, unsuccessful attempts to go against heart or reason"3 Pechorin can be described as a womanizer since he likes to play against women's emotions and use them so they can benefit him and fulfill his personal desires. He gets this satisfaction when he uses women, making him feel like a 'hero'. The reader also learns that he is a character who can't even be honest to himself. ...read more.


In return he is also trusted and no one has ever hurt him before. The reader feels that Shukhov has inner peace and that he is a kind of freedom. On the other hand Pechorin does not have that inner peace which Shukhov has this is because he is a selfish person thinking only of his desires. Since Shukhov is in prison he has the freedom of his political ideas and these cannot be punished since he is already in prison. This again shows how Shukhov has the freedom to do this but Pechorin doesn't. It can be concluded that Shukhov has a stronger character than Pechorin. This is because Shukhov is in general a pleasant person who respects everyone. He is a civilized man and always thinks how he could survive the rest of the years so he can go back to his family. Pechorin is quite opposite to Shukhov, he has a weak character. This is because he is not trustworthy even at times not to himself because he contradicts him self a lot. It can be felt that Shukhov is the greater hero of his time since he makes the reader sympathise for him without creating sympathy. But Pechorin wants the readers to sympathise for him by explaining his feelings, emotions and actions all the time. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Reviews of Personal Performances section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Reviews of Personal Performances essays

  1. First night in prison in role diary entry 1.

    This was good because when people think of prison they think of murderers, rapists and paedophiles, and many of them don't realise that there are people in prison who have committed what could be called tame crime, and that these people are remorseful In my improvisation of a visit in

  2. Teechers characters

    Miss Whitham Miss Whitham is a fussy, hopeless teacher, who is desperate to leave the school. She is terrified of the children and can't control them. She is the exact opposite of Oggy Moxon who is the toughest person in the school; where as Miss Whitham is the hopelessly fastidious (yet powerless).

  1. one to one communication interaction

    This gives Mr A a feeling of confidence and higher self esteem. He sat down in his usual place. I asked him if it was ok to put an apron on him, he responded 'yeah' and lifted his arms up so I could tie the apron.

  2. How can the person-centred core conditions help me to understand and change my life?

    This idea sounds simple, but what if the person in front of you has committed murder, or child molestation? Within this model the counsellor is expected to separate the act from the person. It was a very bad thing to do but that does not make the client a very 'bad' person.

  1. Compare two short stories where the characters face difficult situations

    then they will try and rebel against you, but if your let it have freedom then it will return. She does this through symbolism, using the pigeon as a symbol of the granddaughter. In 'Flight' the granddad lets the pigeon free, for a few minutes, to spread its wings, which

  2. Our Day Out - By Willy Russell

    Character may hide their true feelings if they are ashamed, feel that it is too impolite, or just out of courtesy. Or simply, it gives the audience a better understanding of what is happening in the scene. It also enables the audience to know what someone thinks at important or insignificant moments.

  1. When looking at one of the last perspectives we have examined, the behaviorist perspective, ...

    I would become a non-conformist. One last aspect that will relate to my life, which is part of the Rogerian therapy is 'Pleasing Yourself'. In the process of finding my true self and fulfilling only my own needs we move away from pleasing others. Instead of trying harder and harder to please others, I let

  2. Consider Michael Frayn's presentation of Keith's Mother in the novel

    recollections of childhood, as does texture; Stephen says, "I can feel the delicious serrated texture of the snake's scaliness." (Noticeably, these more detailed memories are told in the first person.) Frayn describes Keith's mother as always, "Rested, calm and composed."

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work