• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Compare and contrast act 1,scene1 of Shakespeares play 'Macbeth' with the cinematic interpretation by Roman Polanski of the same scene.

Extracts from this document...


Compare and contrast act 1,scene1 of Shakespeares play 'Macbeth' with the cinematic interpretation by Roman Polanski of the same scene. Macbeth is one of the great plays written by William Shakespeare in the sixteenth century ,over three and a half centuries ago .It is known all over the world and is still very popular even to this very day.It is the basis of many movies and theatrical plays .One film interpretation was made by Roman Polanski in 1971,centuries after it was first performed in Elizabethan sixteenth century England .Therefor there is a great difference between this and the original ,as things have changed greatly over the many years . Shakespeare was an amazing story writer and entertainer and obviously wanted to catch his audiences imagination ,but even for such a gifted person as he, it must still have been a very difficult task .He had to rely on vivid descriptions and whatever was available in his theatre and the imagination of the audience to put a picture in their heads of the setting, surroundings and and the mood of the play. The play Macbeth was written in sixteen century Elizabethan England .In very different times compared to today .The people of sixteenth century England were very superstitious, believing in witches ,evil spirits and the supernatural .They recognise that the banging of drums create the sound of thunder and signified the presence of evil .They also had a clearer understanding of the language used . ...read more.


As the witches leave, the eerie music returns .Polanski has effectively reflected the eeriness of Shakespeare's scene. When Shakespeare was writing ,most people believed in witches ,and recognised them as the devil's minions who only caused evil .Shakespeare therefore had little need to do more than present these creatures conventionally .Their language alone would have alerted the audience to their evil purpose and their capacity for supernatural powers . 'Fair is foul ,and foul is fair'. 'I come Grey malkin'. 'Paddock calls'. 'That will be ere the set of sun'. These lines alone simply ,and effectively reinforce for his audience that evil was present. Polanski, however, had to work harder to convince his audience of the witches' evil powers .The three witches enter to silence on a deserted, barren shoreline. They are hideous creatures ,their appearance is shocking and repellent ,defects all over there skin. The third witch enters first and digs a hole in the wet sand as if her life depended on it .The three witches were of three different ages ,showing witchcraft is present across the generations for one is deaf ,one is dumb ,and one is blind .They work together ,and need each other to survive ,and they do so well .They all look harmless ,but are capable of evil deeds using their supernatural powers and consequently have a deceptive nature ,belying their appearance .They all speak with a similar accent ,but each seems to have its own personality .They do not have familiars with them and do not cackle or laugh .Polanski did well in effectively showing the witches to a modern audience and portraying the evil present. ...read more.


Although Polanski has taken liberties with Shakespeare's text ,he did so to catch the atmosphere ,mood and the main themes of the original and therefore reflects Shakespeare's themes in his movie interpretation. I have greatly enjoyed both the original and Roman Polanski's version , both were very good each magnificent in its own way however, I personally favoured Polanski's over the original as he had access to all modern movie making equipment ,which in this day and age is very important .The original was a masterpiece which I very much enjoyed ,and this is the reason why it has been so popular and so many movie adaptations have been made over the three and a half centuries since it was written .It would be very hard and unfair to compare the two ,for if it had not been for shakespeare writing his original centuries ago Polanski would have nothing to work on .Polanski had to rely on Shakespeare who wrote the great play . Thanks to Shakespeare ,Polanski was able to do his movie interpretation .He retained the essence that Shakespeare wanted and he had , 'A healthy respect for the language'. Both great works created visual drama ,Polanski has done an excellent job as he has achieved the same gripping effect on his twentieth century audience as Shakespeare did in the sixteenth century .Polanski is a very talented director who has in his adaptation of Shakespeare's scene created an intimidating atmosphere, arousing his audience's curiosity and pulling them into the disordered world of 'Macbeth'! ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Other Shakespeare Plays section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Other Shakespeare Plays essays

  1. Discuss the role of the Mechanicals and the significance of their play in this ...

    This is shown by the resemblance of the characters between the plays. Pyramus and Thisbe face parental disapproval in the play within a play, similarly to Hermia and Lysander. Both plays also have a recurrent theme of romantic confusion; Pyramus believes that Thisbe has been killed by the lion, and

  2. William Shakespeare and his life.

    Although his plays didn't follow the other plays of his time, he swam upstream and didn't become a trout. He did what he preferred and never cared about anyone else's opinion. He was well educated and created many new words, like Assassination, and we would never know what that was if it was for Hamlet, let me tell you.

  1. A midsummers nights dream Act 3 Scene 1

    the play that they look to bottom for guidance and ask him "What say you bottom?" Flute would be completely absorbed in Bottoms movements and would sit contently and listen to him in amazement. Flute could rest his head in his hand with his eyes wide and mouth open.

  2. Critical Approaches to Shakespeare: Some Initial Observations.

    So we can find criticism by the analysis of character degenerating into explorations of the girlhood of Shakespeare's heroines, endless arguments about whether or not the Macbeths had any children, how old Hamlet might be or whether he is really insane or not, whether Falstaff is a coward or not,

  1. Concentrating on The Presentation of Character Setting and Sound Examine What Seems to You ...

    He made it shift from funny to scary by making them make fun of the nuns but as soon as they went the two enemies saw each other, and then he shifted it to the law taking action. He used music to shift it from funny to scary to the law.

  2. "The Life of the Great William Shakespeare"

    Pericles, Prince of Tyre (1608), Cymbeline (1610), and The Winter's Tale (1611), were his last complete plays. While using a humorous atmosphere, Shakespeare stages the dramatic plots, creating a mixture of two of his best types of plays. Besides containing the least amount of Shakespeare's works, it also contains the most controversial.

  1. Shakespeare as a Real Man in Shakespeare in Love

    Viola, as well as Juliet, becomes the unattainable. However, it is not only their love that causes the creative changes from Romeo and Ethel to Romeo and Juliet, but fertile exchanges of everyone involved in the creation of the play, especially actors (It is actually Ned Alleyn´┐Żs suggestion to call the play Romeo and Julie").

  2. The opening scenes of Shakespeare’s plays

    The tribal element and the gang warfare appealed greatly to popular imagination, and in fact still does. The scene can, and has been placed effectively in a modern setting. The first scene of Romeo and Juliet is crammed with sexual innuendo: "'Tis true, and therefore women being the weaker Vessels

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work