Comparing a devised piece with MacBeth

Authors Avatar

Harry Dayantis 11L                                                                                                                  

Part 1 – Comparison Essay - Devising

         I am comparing the two plays ‘Wake Up’ and ‘Macbeth’. Shakespeare wrote Macbeth in 1606, but it was set in around 1040. ‘Wake Up’, our devised piece, was written in 2005, where the play is also set.

        Macbeth is a Shakespearian tragedy, set loosely around the time of 1040. There are clear themes of suspicion, plotting, deception, blood and murder within the play. One of the reasons Shakespeare wrote the Macbeth was to please the king at the time, James I of England. The story of Macbeth is generally based around Raphael Holinshed's historical writing, Chronicles of England Scotland and Ireland, which depicts story of a Scottish king who murdered his way to the throne in 1040 as Macbeth does in the play. This tribute to James I’s Scottish ancestry, and the fact that Banquo is a noble man is not mere coincidence; this was the name of the founder of the royal family of Stuarts in Scotland, to whom James can trace his heritage. King James was also a sound believer in the occult, so Shakespeare included the supernatural idea of witches in order to appeal to James I’s theological interests.         

        ‘Wake Up’ was both written and set in 2005. It was written as a devised GCSE piece, and the stimulus for the idea was a piece of text about dreams and reality. There are various underlying themes, such as dreams and reality, deception, and Heaven and Hell. The idea was to create a play which, while being realistic, was at the same time surreal in places.

        The plot in ‘Macbeth’ centres around the rise and fall of Macbeth himself. It opens with Macbeth being made Thane of Cawdor for his bravery in battle, killing the opposing leader Macdonwald. At this point, Macbeth appears a strong, noble character He then meets witches, who tell him he will become King. Banquo is told that his descendants will become Kings. Banquo is suspicious, but Macbeth is easily swayed towards the witches favour, and his character weakens. After King Duncan has named his son the next King, Macbeth sees his chances dim; his intentions then turn malicious. Lady Macbeth learns of the prophecy, and plots with Macbeth to kill Duncan. After the deed is done,  Duncan’s sons flee, leaving Macbeth the throne. He feels victorious, as the prophecy has come true. Banquo becomes suspicious at this point, so Macbeth has Banquo and his son, Fleance, killed. This fills him with guilt, but he feels he has gone too far to back out at this point. Lady Macbeth then becomes insane, obsessed with ‘blood on her hands’ and commits suicide. Macbeth is disheartened by her death. Malcolm and Macduff plot against Macbeth and then attack. Macbeth feels invincible as he ‘cannot be killed by one of woman born’. But Macduff was born by caesarean so kills Macbeth. Malcolm becomes king.

Join now!

        In ‘Wake Up’, the plot is far simpler than Macbeth. In the beginning, Joe is a ‘nobody’ who lives with his football-crazed flatmate. He is quite depressed with his life. In his dreams, he meets his warped subconscious, Hughbert, and a being who he believes to be his ‘Guardian Angel’. Joe then brightens up, however Hughbert is suspicious of the ‘Angel’. The ‘Angel at this time believes that he has ensnared Joe, so is content but wary of Hughbert. As the play progresses, Joe’s flatmate, Junior, becomes concerned with his dream obsession. Joe obtains sleeping pills, and spends little time ...

This is a preview of the whole essay