• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparing Blood Brothers and Caucasian Chalk Circle.

Extracts from this document...


Brendon Borer Comparing Blood Brothers and Caucasian Chalk Circle Caucasian Chalk Circle and Blood Brothers both have similarities and differences, which I will discuss in the following essay. Blood Brothers is a play about two boys split at birth who, by fate, meet again. Caucasian Chalk Circle, on the other hand, is a play about a women who steals a baby and looks after it for years before the real mum tries to claim it back after war. Both plays include children who aren't looked after each other for different reasons. In Caucasian Chalk Circle it is because the mother forgot or left her child and in Blood Brothers it was because the mother believed she could afford the child and it would live a better life somewhere else. I believe however hard and stressful that was it was the right decision because she unselfishly gave up her blood in order to not only give that child a higher standard of living but her other children as well. She should not be regarded as nasty and someone who absconded from her children. In both plays children were brought up in poverty. In Blood Brothers it was Mickey and his brothers and sisters brought up without money at their dispense. ...read more.


The characters weren't all appointed names so we didn't feel emotionally involved in their affairs. Also people played more than on character and most of the time appeared on stage. This is all apart of alienation or verframdungseffen. They always face the audience to talk so I doesn't always seem as they are talking to the other characters to let you know it isn't real. They sing songs to make you realise they aren't really the person they are playing. The same reason they stand on stage. The singer sets the seen and as this play is epic theatre, it also sets the time. When the songs are sung everyone not in character joins in. I discussed multi role the reason this is evident in Caucasian Chalk Circle is because if you see someone as two people then you will remember he isn't really feeling this emotion, he isn't really dying for example. In Blood Brothers there is a pacific narrator so you feel he is a higher figure telling you what is happening, informing you. He is not a multi role. He doesn't draw us to far out. Although to me, he did slightly. ...read more.


With the naughty children and the hard working mum. In Caucasian Chalk Circle every character is exaggerated and stereotyped so he/she isn't all that realistic. Like the Priest. He is over the top and a stereotype. You hear of many drunk, staggering frauds as priests. Mainly because their job is so holy people want them not to be seen as so innocent. So in Caucasian Chalk Circle you see the priests as one of these but overly exaggerated. He asks for huge sums of money for a illegal marriage and also is drunk well passing it. The costumes in these two pieces were pretty similar. They were as the character would were them. Eg Mickey was poor had poorish clothes, Azdak believed in not showing wealth wore raged clothes. In conclusion I'd like to point out the fact Blood Brothers started at the end and then went to the beginning whereas Caucasian Chalk Circle worked the chronological way through. Also we had to make many decisions in our group. We elected Tom Wells as our leader and most discussions we had ended in some sort of rational decision. Many times one of us took the role as director and edited certain scenes. Finally I'd like to point out that although very different styles, both performances were equally enjoyable and I thought both in and out of school quality was in evidence. ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Blood Brothers section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Blood Brothers essays

  1. The play we saw was Blood Brothers at the Phoenix Theatre in London. It ...

    Social, Historical and Cultural Elements The play Blood Brothers was based in 1980s Britain when the country's Prime Minister was Margaret Thatcher. A key event that happened in the 1980s was the minors strike when Thatcher annoyed trade unions by taking away many rights.

  2. Blood Brothers review

    size of the house which contrasted hugely to the impoverished street that Mrs. Johnstone lived in. These few simple props worked to great effect and really helped to highlight the Lyons luxurious surroundings. Another factor that I had noted was that while the Johnstone's lived in their old neighbourhood, we

  1. Blood Brothers. In my essay I will discuss the way the actors played the ...

    The pair continued talking and then after a reflective pause Edward asked Mickey if he wanted to be his best friend. Mickey said yes but wasn't bothered then they both exchanged names moreover Mickey said that he will call Edward Eddie his face expressed that he didn't understand differences between

  2. Blood Brothers response

    We used a sound collage to add variety to our drama and to build suspense. We used sounds such as eerie whines and blowing winds to create a feeling of a haunted mansion that is spooky. We used physical theatre to actually create the tower that the stone tablet was in.

  1. Blood Brothers

    I am now going to contrast and compare Blood Brothers with Blue Remembered Hills; our piece was set in the 1950's. However, the other play was set in 1943 during the Second World War. The plays were similar because they both started off with people very happy, playing and enjoying themselves.

  2. The structure of 'Blood Wedding'

    Expressionism almost acts as the inner voice of the artist, conveying their own thoughts on society, traditions and people. An expressionistic play consists of many qualities; it is centred around a message that is being conveyed to the audience. In 'Blood Wedding' the main message seems to be the inevitability

  1. Blood Brothers

    The other two people symbolizing the upper class were pointing at the lower class and looking disgusted and horrified, which showed that they didn't consider the lower class to be any better than zoo animals and they were disgusted by the sught of them.

  2. Review of "Blood Brothers".

    Although the set was largely static, elements of scenery are moved in and out of the stage to focus the audience?s attention and to allow the audience to understand the location of a scene. For example, during Mrs Johnstone?s job cleaning for the Lyons family, a dining table is pushed

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work