• Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

Comparison between two Rebus's, the first Rebus will be the character from Ian Rankin's first book Knots and Crosses, and tne Rebus now from the latest Ian Rankin novel, 'A Question of Blood'.

Extracts from this document...


When Ian Rankin's creation Detective Inspector John Rebus gets involved in a case, he just does not get involved to assist in solving the case but makes it a personal objective to solve the case single-handed. In this essay I will conduct a comparison between two Rebus's, the first Rebus will be the character from Ian Rankin's first book Knots and Crosses from when Rebus was a DS in the force and compared to the Rebus now from the latest Ian Rankin novel, 'A Question of Blood' when he is a DI and biding his time until his pension. While I construct this comparison, I will also have a look at the progression of Rebus from then to now. When Ian Rankin introduces DS John Rebus of Lothian and Borders Police Service in 'Knots and Crosses', it is the first time that the reader hears of him. He is standing in the rain at the grave of his dead father in Fife, as it was the fifth anniversary since his death. This is compared to the modern day Rebus when he is in the hospital being treated for burns to his hands. Now in the modern day he is a DI and known in the force as one of the old school coppers left in the force. ...read more.


his Army days; while in 'A Question of Blood' the letters that Siobhan were receiving was from the deceased's girlfriend as she was blaming her for his death. Rebus has two options in both novels which determine the course of both stories, these decisions both involves his family and whether to carry on with the case. The first of these will happen in 'Knots and Crosses' when Rebus's daughter Sammy is abducted by the killer in an attempt for Rebus to realise who the killer was and when Rebus's bosses at Fettes pulled hi of the case; ha had decided to carry on personally to find his daughter and get revenge on his once best friend. Whereas in 'A Question of Blood' it was Rebus's cousin's son that was killed by the killer. When Rebus first heard his cousin's family name mentioned, a choice automatically appeared which was that if he told superiors of the family connections then he would be brought off the case and put on suspension for the other murder case that is going on in at that moment; or he can keep quiet and remain on active duty. The choice that he made in both novels was left to the readers own imagination. ...read more.


Whereas in 'Knots and Crosses' he did everything that his superiors had asked him to do until when he was told not to act on his own to deal with his daughter's abduction on his own terms which Rebus had just went and done. To conclude this essay it had looked like that Rebus had not changed as much in the terms of the way that he handles cases and the way he works to solves them. But what has changed is the way that he treats his family and the people that he holds close to him as he knows that he would be a lonely man if they left him and what has also changed is the way that he treats authority in the force as he will disobey direct orders and have raging arguments with his superiors; this compared to the first Rebus when he had just wanted to work hard and gained promotion so that he would not be giving such stupid jobs when major inquires occurred in Edinburgh but throughout the whole series he has been awkward towards his job and has a case of anti-authority towards his superiors.. John Marr 6S Ian Rankin Second Draft Specialist Study John Marr 6S ...read more.

The above preview is unformatted text

This student written piece of work is one of many that can be found in our GCSE Blood Brothers section.

Found what you're looking for?

  • Start learning 29% faster today
  • 150,000+ documents available
  • Just £6.99 a month

Not the one? Search for your essay title...
  • Join over 1.2 million students every month
  • Accelerate your learning by 29%
  • Unlimited access from just £6.99 per month

See related essaysSee related essays

Related GCSE Blood Brothers essays

  1. Sleepy Hollow (Tim Burton) and The Lost Boys (Joel Schumacher) are fairly recent films, ...

    and Edward Herrmann (Max.) Such examples of these are low angle camera shots to portray the person in a dominant position, and make them seem overpowering, usually used on the villain. A particular favourite of mine in The Lost Boys, is when the high angle, camera shot is used, as the Vampires draw closer too the couple in the car.

  2. Part 1 - Comparison of Blood brothers and Bouncers

    as he had a job, and Lynda went from wearing long skirts and blouses to wearing shorter skirts and looking generally more 'tarty'. The characters in Blood Brothers progress through their life as the play goes on. In the few hours it takes for the play to finish the main characters have grown from dependant children to fully-grown independent adults.

  1. Character Analysis of Sammy in "A&P"

    Rather than coherently explaining himself or his reason for quitting, Sammy recites a frivolous saying of his grandmothers. It is childish to dismiss an authoritative figure so easily with such a ridiculous phrase. This is supposed to be the dramatic conflict of the story, however, Sammy's immaturity hides him from realizing the importance of his actions at that moment.

  2. Analysis of 2 Texts : 'Eastenders' (Trevor and Mo) and 'Blood Wedding' by Lorca

    Here's an example In session 5 where we done a short piece on eastenders and I played Trevor. I spoke directly to the audience while the other members of my group still acted but did not pretend to hear me.

  1. To what extent can storytelling as a ritual be used as a dramatic force ...

    Jo Salas, who was an original member of Boal's Playback Theatre, has said that it relates to an 'ancient impulse to communicate and dramatise ones' experience'2 . I can agree with this quote as it has been proved correct as we are still telling stories today.

  2. This investigation will be comparing the accessibility of Stantonbury and Milton Keynes theatres to ...

    seats 9 Lots of seating is available but you have to ring prior to performance Toilets 9 Could have been slightly bigger. bar 9 Same as counter Area around theatre 10 No problems rails 10 Where ever needed Floor surface 9 Bit too smooth Fire escape 10 No problems total

  1. The beautiful lie.

    I couldn't fall asleep, so this morning, I got here at about five am." When Sam heard this, he sighed. His brother had been waiting there for five hours. He felt sorry and emotional. He looked at David carefully. He found that there were a few white hairs on David's head.

  2. A Specialist Study of the character of "Lyra" and how she develops in the ...

    This backs up previous comments about her character's childishness and mischievous nature. It also elaborates on her exact friendships: i.e. out of her many and "various" friends she has chosen one who is her "particular" friend. This quotation (and its context)

  • Over 160,000 pieces
    of student written work
  • Annotated by
    experienced teachers
  • Ideas and feedback to
    improve your own work